Gemini Meets Reality: Google Slams the Brakes on Ask Photos
Google’s AI ambitions just ran into a speed bump. Late Tuesday, the company confirmed that it has paused the limited rollout of Ask Photos, an experimental Google Photos feature that lets you interrogate your library with natural-language prompts. Product manager Jamie Aspinall admitted on X that the tool still struggles with latency, answer quality, and the overall user experience. So the experiment is going back to the lab for “about two weeks” of re-tooling before anyone new can touch it. The Verge first spotted the move, and Engadget later confirmed the pause.
A Quick Refresher: What Exactly Is Ask Photos?
Unveiled at I/O 2024, Ask Photos promised to put Gemini’s multimodal chops inside Google Photos. Instead of scrolling through thousands of thumbnails, you could ask questions like “What theme did we use for Maya’s sixth birthday?” or “Show me every sunset I shot in Boracay.” The system would parse faces, text, objects, and EXIF data, then answer in plain English while surfacing the relevant pictures. Google’s own blog framed it as a stress-buster for people drowning in 6 billion daily uploads.
Latency, Quality, UX: The Triple Culprit
Why the sudden stop? Early testers complained that answers felt sluggish and sometimes missed obvious matches. In other cases, replies were oddly hallucinatory Gemini would insist a photo of grandma’s garden contained a cat that wasn’t there. Internally, Google flagged three issues:
- Latency – Responses lagged far behind the snappy keyword search users are accustomed to.
- Answer quality – The model sometimes returned irrelevant or incomplete sets.
- User experience – The chat-style overlay hid key photo controls and confused people who expected a traditional grid.
Those problems, Aspinall said, “undercut the magic.”
From Wait-List Buzz to Whiplash: How Testers Reacted
Eight months of quiet wait-list excitement on Reddit and forums just flipped to disappointment. Some early adopters call the pause refreshing honesty; others say Google is “shipping betas as betas.” Over on 9to5Google’s comment thread, users admitted they were impressed by voice queries but frustrated when the feature timed out. A few even rolled back to the old Photos APK to dodge the buggy UI.
Meanwhile… Old-School Text Search Gets a Facelift
Google tried to soften the blow with a consolation prize. Classic keyword search inside Photos now supports quotation marks for exact text matches across filenames, captions, camera models, and OCR’ed words inside images. Drop the quotes and you’ll still get the familiar visual matches. The tweak feels minor, but power users say it finally brings Photos’ text handling in line with Gmail’s.
Déjà Vu: Google’s Growing Pattern of AI Pauses
If this storyline sounds familiar, that’s because it is. Earlier this year, Google yanked its Gemini image generator after historical inaccuracies went viral. The company also throttled “AI Overviews” in Search when the bot suggested adding glue to pizza sauce. Each retreat underscores how fast-moving AI rollouts can trip over real-world edge cases and how quickly Google will pump the brakes to protect brand trust.
Privacy and Trust: The Elephant in the Cloud
Performance isn’t the only worry. Ask Photos runs on a specialized, private instance of Gemini that (Google claims) never uses personal images to train models. Still, privacy advocates note that “private” doesn’t always mean “immune to leaks,” and the feature’s chat-style summaries could expose sensitive details (think medical bills photographed for insurance). Google says users must opt in and can turn off the assistant at any time, but critics want clearer data-retention policies before the public rollout resumes.
What Happens Next: Two Weeks and Beyond
Aspinall’s two-week estimate feels aggressive. Engineers need to tighten latency, retrain retrieval pipelines, and redo UI polish. If they hit that deadline, expect a fresh wave of invites later in June likely still capped to a “very small number” of users while metrics improve. Longer term, insiders hint at integration with Memories and automatic trip-highlight creation, plus a “privacy sandbox” where queries stay fully on-device. But none of that ships until the current trio of issues is solved. For now, your best bet remains old-fashioned scrolling or those newly buffed quotation-mark searches.
Comments 2