# Change log — review of the Task 10 submission

Original submission is preserved unchanged in `output/original_submission/` (handoff.md, requirements.csv). Revised files are `output/handoff.md` and `output/requirements.csv`.

## Conclusions unchanged
The review found no error in the five answers (who may launch, scope, evidence, blockers, next action). All 28 figures and phrases I rely on were re-matched against the two input files by script.

## Corrections to handoff.md
1. **Signoff wording.** "No signoff exists (TEST-11)" overstated what an Oct 26 record can show. Now: none recorded as of Oct 26 (TEST-11), and MAIL-28 (Oct 28) reports none.
2. **Fix-build wording.** "Nothing has been tested on a build containing Jules's fix" asserted a fact I cannot know. Now: the archive records no such build or test.
3. **Panel copy drafts.** The 60 draft copy updates (AT-101 to AT-160) were not addressed. They are now listed with the notes as drafts outside CR-12 scope.
4. **Unstated routing made explicit.** Sending the backup-operator and rollback-plan decisions to Maya is my assumption; the inputs do not say who decides. This is now stated under Assumptions.
5. **Date-order note.** "Out of date order after NOTE-027" was too narrow; the substantive records are also interleaved out of order. Now: "not in date order".
6. **Length.** The Oct 30 conditions list in section 6 was condensed to a reference to gates 1–4 to keep the file under 900 words after the additions.

## Corrections to requirements.csv
1. **R-18 owner.** Removed "(tickets AT-101 to AT-160)". Those tickets track the panel copy drafts; the notes do not tie them to the "instant sync" help text.
2. **R-19 added.** Panel copy updates 1 to 60 (AT-101 to AT-160): draft, not in CR-12 scope, no input makes them a launch gate.
3. **R-09 owner and status.** Owner now names Theo or a named trained backup (none assigned) instead of "Not assigned". Status now limits the block to the Oct 30 09:00 Pacific slot, which is all MAIL-28 supports.
4. **R-05, R-06, R-12 owners.** Reworded so they do not imply an assignment the inputs do not make (Nora reports consent; Maya is approver; R-12 has no stated owner).
5. **R-15 status.** Now labelled a working-note request, not an item in the approved change register.
6. **R-01, R-02 source.** Added DEC-01, which is the source for Theo as engineering owner.

## Checks run in this review (check2.py)
- Input files are byte-identical to the first run (hash match).
- Original submission copies match the hashes of the first-run files.
- 28 source phrases found in the inputs; none missing.
- Every record ID cited in the deliverables exists in the inputs.
- requirements.csv parses: required header, 19 rows, 5 columns each, no empty cells, unique ids.
- handoff.md word count: see the final response for the measured figure.

## Not checked
- No test, deployment, message or production access was performed or is claimed.
- Documents referred to but absent from the archive (test logs, runbook, consent records, rollback plan) could not be inspected.
