The review found no error in the five answers, but I corrected several wording and attribution issues and added one missing requirement row. The original submission is preserved unchanged in `output/original_submission/`. The conclusion stands: as of October 28 nobody may launch. Scope is CSV import and account search for at most 80 consented accounts. The same four gates are open: the keyboard-path fix, Maya's written signoff, the rollback plan and a deployment operator. ## Change log **handoff.md** - **Signoff wording:** "No signoff exists (TEST-11)" overstated what an Oct 26 record shows. It now says none is recorded as of Oct 26 (TEST-11) and MAIL-28 reports none. - **Fix-build wording:** "Nothing has been tested on a build containing Jules's fix" asserted something I cannot know. It now says the archive records no such build or test. - **Panel copy drafts:** the 60 draft copy updates (AT-101 to AT-160) were not addressed. They are now listed as drafts outside CR-12 scope. - **Routing to Maya:** sending the backup-operator and rollback-plan decisions to Maya is my assumption, since the inputs do not say who decides. This is now stated. - **Date order:** the note about archive ordering was too narrow and now says entries are not in date order. - **Length:** the first revision came to 912 words, over the limit, so I condensed the Oct 30 conditions list in section 6 into a reference to gates 1–4. **requirements.csv** - **R-18:** removed the AT ticket reference. Those tickets track the panel copy drafts, and the notes do not tie them to the "instant sync" help text. - **R-19 (new):** panel copy updates are drafts, not in CR-12 scope, and no input makes them a launch gate. - **R-09:** owner now reads Theo or a named trained backup (none assigned). The block is limited to the Oct 30 09:00 Pacific slot, which is all MAIL-28 supports. - **R-05, R-06, R-12:** owners reworded so they do not imply assignments the inputs do not make. - **R-15:** now labelled a working-note request, not an item in the approved change register. - **R-01, R-02:** added DEC-01 as the source for Theo as engineering owner. ## Checks performed in this review One script (`check2.py`) confirmed: - Both input files are byte-identical to the first run. - The preserved originals match the hashes of the first-run files. - All 28 figures and phrases I rely on appear in the inputs. - Every record ID cited in the deliverables exists in the inputs. - `requirements.csv` parses with the required header, 19 rows, 5 columns each, no empty cells and unique ids. - `handoff.md` is 879 words by whitespace count including table markup, and 843 with markup stripped. I ran no tests of the product and performed no deployment, message or production access. ## Remaining limitations - The archive holds only summaries; test logs, the runbook, consent records and the rollback plan could not be inspected. - The 4 invalid-format import tests are recorded on a17 only. - Whether the pilot needs a data migration is not stated (R-16). - The reading of "rollback plan must be attached first" as before deployment needs Maya's confirmation. - Theo's return time on Oct 30 is not stated. ## Estimated human time to finish About 15 minutes to review the files and confirm the two open readings with Maya. This is an estimate, not a measurement. Files are in `output/`: - handoff.md - requirements.csv - CHANGELOG.md - original_submission/handoff.md - original_submission/requirements.csv