# Review change log

## Revised deliverables
- `output/handoff.md` — 696 whitespace-delimited words; limit is under 900.
- `output/requirements.csv` — 14 rows; required five-column schema retained.
- Original files preserved byte-for-byte in `output/original_submission/handoff.md` and `output/original_submission/requirements.csv` before revision. Their SHA-256 digests were checked again after revision.

## Corrections and clarifications
1. **Distinguished requirements from evidence and working notes.** AW-03 now explicitly tracks duplicate-test evidence; AW-12 tracks reported runbook readiness rather than inventing an ongoing maintenance requirement. AW-13 and AW-14 label scope/evidence boundaries and working-note expectations, not additional approved launch gates. (inputs/archive.md, TEST-11, MAIL-28, NOTE-001–NOTE-060; inputs/approved-changes.md, CR-12–CR-13.)
2. **Labeled inferred ownership.** Theo's feature ownership is inferred from his documented engineering remit, not a separate explicit feature assignment. Unspecified operational owners remain unspecified. (inputs/archive.md, DEC-01.)
3. **Aligned rollback wording.** Both deliverables now identify attachment before signoff review and deployment as conservative sequencing of CR-13's “attached first” rule, rather than presenting the pre-signoff order as an explicit quotation. The missing plan remains a blocker. (inputs/approved-changes.md, CR-13.)
4. **Improved usability and action claims.** Corrected the case of `requirements.csv`, stated the common status cutoff, added 2026 to CSV deadline/slot dates, and distinguished document validation actually performed from product tests not performed.

## Review checks actually performed
- Re-read assignment instructions and the approved register. Reviewed all six non-routine archive records and all 60 routine notes; a local normalization check confirmed the routine-note bodies differ only in workstream, panel and ticket identifiers.
- Reconciled DEC-01 and rejected EMAIL-19 with CR-12; retained Atlas Mobile, copy drafts and quoted TICKET-223 outside release authorization. Rechecked operator restrictions and the reserved-slot staffing gap against CR-13 and MAIL-28.
- Rechecked every reported test count: a17 CSV 12 positive plus 4 invalid-format, search 8; a19 duplicates 3/3, CSV 12/12, search 8/8; historical email failures 2/5. No counts were added across builds or presented as unique-test totals. No numeric correction was needed. (inputs/archive.md, TEST-07, TEST-11.)
- Rechecked coverage of scope, consent cap, conditional target, accessibility deadline, written signoff, operator eligibility, rollback attachment and post-deployment/pre-access smoke test against CR-12–CR-13. No approved requirement was found missing.
- Ran local standard-library validation: word limit; exact CSV headers; 14 unique IDs; five nonempty fields per row; cited record IDs present in the supplied sources; UTF-8 readback and CSV parsing. Reviewed the revision diff. Original-file hash checks passed.

## Unchanged conclusion and limits
Hold launch. The earliest defensible action is preparation and blocker resolution, not deployment; October 30 remains conditional. No passing keyboard evidence, rollback attachment, written signoff or assigned backup is supplied. Production smoke testing is still a later gate. (inputs/approved-changes.md, CR-12–CR-13; inputs/archive.md, TEST-11, MAIL-28.)

This review used only supplied documents and local file validation. No product tests, communications, exports, deployments or production access occurred. Underlying test logs and runbook contents remain unavailable. Estimated human review/assignment effort: 15–30 minutes, not measured; engineering remediation and launch completion cannot be estimated from this evidence.
