# Review change log

## Revised deliverables
- `output/handoff.md` — 675 whitespace-delimited words, below the 900-word limit.
- `output/requirements.csv` — exact requested five-column schema; 16 local tracking entries.
- `output/check_deliverables.py` — strengthened, rerun validation script.

## Corrections and clarifications
1. **Export claim narrowed.** Replaced the ambiguous “No export was made” with a distinction between this investigation (no export performed) and archive history (not established). TICKET-223 records a request, not execution or approval. (inputs/archive.md, TICKET-223.)
2. **Evidence separated from requirements and owners.** Marked test-count tracking as evidence rather than newly approved acceptance gates. Replaced “maintain support runbook” with reported readiness; Nora is identified as reporter, not an inferred maintenance owner. Unspecified owners remain unspecified. (inputs/archive.md, TEST-07, TEST-11, MAIL-28; inputs/approved-changes.md, CR-13.)
3. **Build-specific evidence tightened.** Explicitly calculated a17 CSV tests as 12 + 4 = 16; clarified that 3/3 duplicate tests address the gap on a19, not on an untested later build. Did not add counts across builds or infer a19 invalid-format coverage. (inputs/archive.md, TEST-07, TEST-11.)
4. **Operational fallback clarified.** A later deployment requires a confirmed slot and Theo’s confirmed availability, not assumed availability. The rollback-before-deployment sequence remains a conservative recommendation; no extra pre-signoff policy is asserted. (inputs/archive.md, MAIL-28; inputs/approved-changes.md, CR-13.)
5. Added a complete filename citation for alert exclusion inside the evidence table. Expanded validation to check source-file/record pairing, every NOTE-range member, CSV row width and snapshot integrity.

## Review and checks actually performed
- Rechecked the assignment, all six non-routine archive records and the authoritative register. Programmatically checked all 60 routine notes for the shared demo-only, no-production-approval, data-preservation, Mobile-exclusion and unmeasured-copy qualifications.
- Reviewed revised Markdown and CSV after writing them. Reconciled DEC-01 and EMAIL-19 against CR-12, and TEST-11/MAIL-28 against CR-13. No change to the hold recommendation was warranted.
- Ran `output/check_deliverables.py`: PASS for 675-word limit, 16 rows, exact header, unique IDs, populated fields, correct row width, cited source files/IDs, NOTE ranges, arithmetic and original snapshot hashes. Citation existence checks are not automatic proof of factual entailment.
- No deployments, messages, customer exports, production access or product tests were performed. Only local document review and validation scripts were executed.

## Preservation and limitations
Original deliverable files are preserved in `output/original_submission/` (`handoff.md`, `requirements.csv`, `check_deliverables.py`), with `sha256.json`; hashes verified unchanged after revision. Raw inputs were not modified. Review helper scripts are `output/review_submission.py` and `output/apply_review.py`; these are audit helpers, not release procedures.

The source packet remains summary-only: no underlying test artifacts, rollback plan, written signoff, assigned backup or later acceptance evidence was supplied. No exact release time or remediation duration can be established. Estimated human time to review the revised documents: **5–10 minutes**, not measured; actual release completion depends on unresolved gates and cannot be estimated from this packet.
