The review found no wrong conclusions, but I corrected one sequencing error and several precision and usability issues. The answers stand: nobody may launch as of October 28, scope is CSV import and account search for at most 80 consented accounts, and the next action is Jules's keyboard-path fix with passing evidence by Oct 29. ## Change log **handoff.md** 1. **Rollback-plan sequencing corrected.** The original placed "rollback plan is attached" after Maya's signoff. CR-13 says only that it "must be attached first", so it is now shown as a precondition of deployment that can be prepared in parallel. 2. **Gate count reconciled.** The bottom line said four gates while section 4 listed five blocked items. It now says four pre-deployment gates, and item 5 states that the smoke test and pilot access wait on them. 3. **Statuses dated.** The accessibility failure is now "last recorded result (TEST-11, Oct 26)" and signoff is "none recorded as of Oct 28". 4. **Project names.** Added that "Northline Atlas" is only the archive title and Atlas Web is the release. 5. **Minor edits.** Added a pointer to `requirements.csv` and tightened wording to stay under the limit. **requirements.csv** 1. **Status column normalised.** Every status now starts with one of eight keywords, so the column can be filtered. 2. **Owner inferences removed or labelled.** R-16 (the quoted customer request) is now "Not assigned in sources" rather than Maya. Where Maya appears only because she approved the change, she is labelled "CR approver". 3. **R-07 and R-08 statuses dated** to match the handoff. Rows, IDs and header are unchanged. ## Checks performed on the revised files - **Word count:** `handoff.md` is 848 words by whitespace split and 878 if hyphenated tokens are split, both under 900. - **CSV:** parses with the required header, 19 rows, 5 fields each, no empty cells, unique IDs. - **Citations:** all 11 record IDs cited exist in the inputs. - **Facts:** 16 quoted facts (test counts, builds, dates, the 80-account limit, slot time, operator and rollback statements) were string-matched against the input files and all matched. - **Inputs:** file sizes are unchanged. - **Original submission:** preserved in `output/original_submission/`; the copies were made before any edits. ## Remaining limitations - **Second-hand evidence:** test logs, the runbook and consent records are not supplied, so the archive's statements about them are unverified. - **Rollback timing:** I read "attached first" in CR-13 as before deployment. - **Backup operator:** I assumed Maya names the backup, since CR-13 does not say. - **Unresolved by the sources:** who owns the smoke test, whether a data migration is required, whether the 4 invalid-format tests were rerun on a19, and whether regression must be rerun after the fix. - **Not done:** the CSV was checked only with the Python parser, not opened in a spreadsheet. No messages were sent and nothing was deployed or accessed in production. Estimated human time to finish: about 15–20 minutes to review and confirm the assumptions with Maya. This is an estimate, not a measurement. Files are in `output/`: - handoff.md - requirements.csv - CHANGELOG.md - original_submission/handoff.md - original_submission/requirements.csv