{
  "run_id": "T08-R1-qwen4",
  "model": "qwen/qwen4-max",
  "effort": "high",
  "started": "2026-11-16T03:52:09.525450+00:00",
  "stages": {
    "initial": {
      "status": "complete",
      "elapsed_min": 2.459385047233324,
      "answer": "All deliverables are written and verified.\n\n## Plan chosen\n**Main review: Tue Oct 27, 2026, 14:00–14:45 Pacific (21:00–21:45 UTC), Room C** — the earliest feasible start, as Maya's update requires. Theo prep 13:30–14:00 PT; assistant setup 13:50–14:00 PT in Room C; Maya+Jules remote follow-up 14:45–15:00 PT (21:45–22:00 UTC), inside the same availability windows as the review.\n\nKey finding: the morning's only people-feasible start (10:00) fails rooms — B opens 10:00 so the 09:50 setup violates \"room free throughout setup and main review\" (inputs/update.txt), and C closes 10:30 before the 10:45 review end. No constraint was relaxed; later feasible starts (14:05 C, 14:10 B, 14:15 B) were rejected only for being later.\n\n**One decision still needed:** whether the beta flag can be enabled — the security owner is unidentified in the material (inputs/update.txt); Maya is not assumed to own that approval.\n\n## Handoff\n**Outputs:** `output/schedule.csv`, `output/risk-note.md` (413 words), `output/invitation-draft.txt` (marked DRAFT — nothing sent or booked), `output/check_schedule.py` (verification script). Raw inputs untouched.\n\n**Checks actually performed (local Python):**\n- Confirmed 2026-10-27 is a Tuesday.\n- Exhaustive 5-minute-grid search of all starts × Rooms B/C against every hard constraint (attendees, prep, setup, follow-up same-window, lunch, 09:00–17:00, room free through setup+review): feasible starts are exactly 14:00/14:05 (C) and 14:10/14:15 (B); 14:00 C is earliest.\n- Asserted the final schedule.csv rows against inputs (durations, PT→UTC = +7h, all constraints pass); risk note word count 413 < 500.\n\n**Limitations / assumptions (recorded in risk note):**\n- Theo's \"no meeting overlap\" for prep is verified only against availability windows; no separate meeting calendar was supplied — confirm with Theo.\n- \"Same available window\" interpreted as Maya's/Jules's windows containing the review.\n- Zero buffer at Room C's 13:50 opening and 5 min at its 14:50 close; fallback Room B 14:10 PT documented.\n- No booking or sending capability was used or claimed; room/assistant availability is per the CSVs only.\n\n**Estimated human finish time:** ~10–15 minutes to confirm Theo's prep is meeting-free, verify Room C/assistant, identify the security owner, then send the invitation (estimate, not measured).",
      "finished": "2026-11-16T03:54:37.088828+00:00"
    },
    "revision": {
      "status": "complete",
      "elapsed_min": 2.658613613200093,
      "answer": "## Review verdict: schedule is correct; two minor documentation/usability fixes applied\n\n**No scheduling error was found.** The plan stands: main review **Tue Oct 27, 2026, 14:00–14:45 PT (21:00–21:45 UTC), Room C**; Theo prep 13:30–14:00 PT; setup 13:50–14:00 PT; remote Maya+Jules follow-up 14:45–15:00 PT (21:45–22:00 UTC).\n\n### Checks performed in this review (all executed locally)\n- **Stronger feasibility proof**: re-ran the full constraint search at **1-minute resolution** (not just 5-minute). Feasible starts are exactly 14:00–14:05 (Room C only) and 14:10–14:15 (Room B only) → 14:00 Room C is provably the earliest. Also proved all input boundaries/durations are 5-minute aligned, so the original grid couldn't have missed anything.\n- **Date/UTC**: 2026-10-27 is a Tuesday; every schedule.csv row's UTC = PT + 7h re-verified.\n- **Requirements**: invitation names required (Maya, Theo, Jules), optional (Nora, with reason), Room C, agenda, both time zones, DRAFT marker; risk note 433 words (<500); rejected alternatives and the single unresolved decision (beta-flag approval by an unidentified security owner, inputs/update.txt) present.\n- **Source conflicts**: none; the morning 10:00 rejection correctly applies update.txt's room-through-setup rule without relaxing anything.\n- **Preservation**: first submission copied byte-identically to `output/original_submission/`; input hashes recorded (inputs never modified). No sends/bookings claimed or made.\n\n### Corrections made\n1. `risk-note.md`: verification claim upgraded to the 1-minute result; later feasible starts stated as exact ranges (14:01–14:05 C; 14:10–14:15 B). 413→433 words.\n2. `check_schedule.py` (output copy): added RUN LOCATION header (must run from workspace root); re-executed successfully.\n3. `review_audit.py` added as evidence; its preservation check now reports identical-vs-revised instead of asserting pre-fix equality (one failed intermediate run of the audit was due to that stale assertion — fixed, no deliverable affected).\n4. `schedule.csv` and `invitation-draft.txt`: **unchanged** (verified byte-identical to originals).\n\n### Handoff\n**Outputs**: `output/schedule.csv`, `output/risk-note.md`, `output/invitation-draft.txt`, `output/change-log.md`, `output/check_schedule.py`, `output/review_audit.py`, `output/original_submission/` (4 preserved originals).\n\n**Remaining limitations** (unchanged, flagged in risk note): Theo's prep verified only against availability windows (no meeting calendar supplied); \"same available window\" interpreted as the review-containing windows; zero setup buffer at Room C's 13:50 opening (fallback: Room B 14:10 PT); security owner still unidentified — the one decision needed.\n\n**Estimated human finish time**: ~10–15 minutes (confirm Theo's prep, Room C/assistant, identify security owner, send invite) — an estimate, not measured.",
      "finished": "2026-11-16T03:57:16.608238+00:00"
    }
  }
}
