The review changed no decision, refund amount, priority or needs-human value; it found one missed assumption and a few citation and usability fixes. The original submission is preserved unchanged in `output/original_submission/`. ## Change log 1. **Policy version vs. purchase date (missed first time).** `policy.md` is headed "version October 1, 2026", but orders A701 and A702 were purchased in September. I applied it anyway because it is the only policy supplied. This is now recorded in `notes.md` and in the T701 and T702 reasons. It matters most for T702, which is declined by one day; a human may want to confirm no earlier terms applied. 2. **Source lines in `replies.md`.** Each reply now has an internal "Source:" line naming the input file, section heading and record IDs. The first version cited only the policy section and order inside the reply text. 3. **T704 wording.** "The records available to me show no approved exception" became "I have no record of an approved exception", because the supplied records have no approvals field at all. 4. **File usability.** `triage.csv` and `replies.md` are now ASCII-only, so the CSV opens in spreadsheet tools without encoding settings. 5. **Action claims.** The T708 reason now states the safety escalation is not yet filed, and `notes.md` flags that the reply's "is being escalated" is only true once a person files it before sending. The T703 reason notes a person must verify the photo when it arrives. ## Checks performed in this review I ran `check2.py` once. It confirmed: - **Decisions and amounts:** an independent re-derivation from the policy rules and `orders.csv` matches all 10 rows, in both the original and the revised file. The refund total is CAD 330. - **Customer claims vs. records:** I compared them by reading and found no conflicts (T704 20%, T705 10%, T706 two settled captures, T707 one settled plus one pending). - **CSV structure:** the 7 required columns, 10 rows, ticket order matching `tickets.csv`, no empty fields. - **Citations:** every row and reply cites a policy section and only its own order; T710 cites no order. - **Word limit:** replies are 61–105 words, and each whole section including the Source line is under 120. - **Preservation:** the three original files are unchanged by hash. Tone, empathy and policy wording were reviewed by reading only. Nothing was sent, refunded or escalated. ## Remaining limitations - "Sealed", "unopened" and "cracked" are customer claims; nothing was inspected. - Taxes and shipping are not in the inputs, so only merchandise amounts are stated. - The inputs have no return address, label process or contact channel, so a human must add them to the T701, T703 and T708 replies. - Tickets carry no date; all are treated as received October 20, 2026. **Estimated human time to finish:** about 15–20 minutes to review the replies, add return and contact instructions, file the T706 and T708 escalations, and confirm the policy-version point for T702. This is an estimate, not a measurement. Files are in `output/`: - triage.csv - replies.md - notes.md - original_submission/triage.csv - original_submission/replies.md - original_submission/notes.md