# Review and change log

## Outcome
Reviewed the assignment, current deliverables and all supplied policy/order/ticket evidence. **No decision, refund amount, priority or human-review flag required correction.** Minor wording and citation clarifications are included in the revised files. Only local standard-library processing was used; no operational actions were performed.

## Changes
1. `replies.md`: scoped the draft banner and T703/T705/T706 action-status wording to this assignment. The original “no reversal has occurred” / “not processed yet” language could imply knowledge of historical activity that the supplied records do not establish. Revised drafts state what this draft does not execute, rather than making that broader claim (`inputs/policy.md`, Evidence).
2. `triage.csv`: made the same clarification in T705/T706 reasons; decisions and amounts are unchanged.
3. `README.md`: clarified the limits of historical refund-status knowledge and added explicit order/ticket citations to the T701/T703 action summary.
4. Preserved all three initial deliverables byte-for-byte under `output/original_submission/`. The archive is superseded; use the files directly under `output/` for current work.

## Evidence review and recalculations
Assessment date remains October 20, 2026 (`PROMPT.md`, Task 7). Tickets without timestamps are still assumed received that day; no prior request dates are invented. Policy source is `inputs/policy.md`, version October 1, 2026.

| Ticket / order | Rechecked result | Applicable policy section |
|---|---|---|
| T701 / A701 | September 20 to October 20 = 30 days. Unopened claim; CAD 180 conditional on receipt; customer pays return shipping. | Returns; Evidence |
| T702 / A702 | September 19 to October 20 = 31 days. Outside the return-request window. | Returns |
| T703 / A703 | October 15 to October 20 = 5 days. Missing photo; verify before requested replacement or alternative CAD 60 refund, with prepaid shipping. | Defects and duplicates; Evidence |
| T704 / A704 | October 9 to October 20 = 11 days, but exactly 20% viewed is excluded. Manager approval claim is unsupported, not a policy override. | Returns; Evidence |
| T705 / A705 | October 8 to October 20 = 12 days and 10% viewed. Eligible for CAD 120 merchandise refund. | Returns; Evidence |
| T706 / A706 | Two settled captures; customer reports two CAD 30 charges. CAD 30 duplicate refund requires payment-team verification. | Defects and duplicates; Evidence |
| T707 / A707 | One settled capture plus one pending authorization. No duplicate-charge refund; no bank-release date promised. | Defects and duplicates |
| T708 / A708 | October 17 to October 20 = 3 days. Smoke/sparks take precedence: highest-priority human safety escalation, keep unplugged, no retesting, private order/contact confirmation. Remedy undetermined; no compensation promise. | Safety; Defects and duplicates; Evidence |
| T709 / A709 | Personalized mug matches customer's order; change-of-mind return excluded regardless of its 12-day delivery age. | Returns |
| T710 / UNKNOWN | No matching order. Request identification privately; eligibility/amount undetermined; refuse other-customer information. | Returns; Safety; Evidence |

Table record citations: `inputs/orders.csv`, each listed order (UNKNOWN has no record); `inputs/tickets.csv`, each listed ticket. Customer viewing/payment claims agree with supplied records. The T704 approval claim has no supporting record, and T710's order is missing; neither is treated as verified evidence. No conflicting policy version was supplied.

## Checks actually performed on revised files
- Parsed UTF-8 inputs and revised CSV; verified the exact required seven columns, ten unique rows, input-ticket order and coverage, valid yes/no flags, no malformed rows, and two-decimal nonnegative populated amounts.
- Recomputed delivery/purchase ages for every known order; asserted the boundary tests and the two digital viewing thresholds. Checked settled/pending capture counts and all ten refund fields against the reviewed outcomes.
- Compared original/revised rows: decisions, amounts, priorities, review flags and source fields are unchanged.
- Parsed the saved Markdown: exactly one correctly mapped reply per ticket. Counted each reply, its source note, and its heading; even the entire block is under 120 words.
- Checked cited policy section headings exist and source notes cite the policy, order export and ticket export. Checked no reply block contains another ticket's numeric order/ticket ID. Also reviewed reply content for privacy, safety instructions, unsupported promises and customer instructions to ignore policy; the ID check alone is not a comprehensive privacy test.
- Verified archived files byte-for-byte against the initial files and compared input hashes before/after this review. Raw inputs were not edited.

### Saved reply word counts
| Ticket | Reply only | Including source note | Including heading and source note |
|---|---:|---:|---:|
| T701 | 59 | 68 | 71 |
| T702 | 45 | 53 | 56 |
| T703 | 59 | 70 | 73 |
| T704 | 66 | 75 | 78 |
| T705 | 58 | 67 | 70 |
| T706 | 59 | 70 | 73 |
| T707 | 47 | 57 | 60 |
| T708 | 72 | 84 | 87 |
| T709 | 40 | 48 | 51 |
| T710 | 79 | 92 | 95 |

Counts use whitespace-delimited words; headings exclude the Markdown `##` marker. Adding that marker still leaves every block under 120.

## File usability and remaining limits
`triage.csv` is a standard quoted CSV with the requested header. Positive conditional amounts are potential merchandise refunds, not executed payments; T703's amount is an alternative to replacement. Blank T708/T710 amounts mean undetermined, not zero. These conventions and human-review flags are explained in `README.md`. Internal citations in `replies.md` should be removed before sending, and each ticket's block must be sent only to its own customer.

No replies were sent, refunds issued, returns arranged, photos verified, or safety/payment reviews routed by this assignment. Prior refund activity is not established. T708 still requires immediate human routing; T701/T703/T706/T710 depend on receipt, evidence or verification. Taxes and shipping amounts are unavailable (`inputs/policy.md`, Evidence).

Estimated remaining human effort: **15–25 active minutes** to review and initiate actions; this is an estimate, not a measured result. Final closure depends on customer responses, receipt and team reviews and cannot be timed from the supplied evidence.

## Current deliverables
- `output/triage.csv`
- `output/replies.md`
- `output/README.md`
- `output/change_log.md`
- Initial submission: `output/original_submission/triage.csv`, `output/original_submission/replies.md`, `output/original_submission/README.md`.
