# Change log — review of the first submission

The first submission is preserved unchanged in `output/original-submission/` (article.md, metadata.json, editor-notes.md, check_package.py). The revised files are at the top level of `output/`.

## What the review found

No factual error, wrong calculation or unreconciled source conflict was found. Four things were tightened.

| # | Issue in the first submission | Change | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The closing section said a trial "should cost you mainly time". That rested on an inference that the assistant is included in the Team price, which the packet never states. | The article now says the pricing page lists no separate fee but does not say outright that the assistant is included, and tells readers to confirm it. The word "trial" is gone, so nothing hints at a free trial. | S1-announcement.md, "Access"; S2-pricing.md, "Current plans" |
| 2 | Only the announcement carried a date. Price, data policy and DeskLab figures had no as-of date. | Added October 17, 2026 for pricing and the data policy, and October 18, 2026 for DeskLab. | Title lines of S2, S3 and S4 |
| 3 | The article said "its October 16 launch screenshot", attributing the screenshot to the vendor more firmly than S2 does. | Now "the October 16 launch screenshot", attributed to the pricing page's correction. "The pricing packet lists no annual offer" became "It lists no annual offer". | S2-pricing.md, "Correction" |
| 4 | The excerpt and search description gave USD 29 per seat without the three-seat minimum, which understates the entry cost for a small team. | Both now say "three-seat minimum". Excerpt is 41 words; search description is 158 characters. | S2-pricing.md, "Current plans" |

## Smaller edits

- **Article:** cut "not as something to budget around" from the Q1 2027 paragraph to keep the length inside 800 words.
- **Editor notes:** updated decision 1 and the counts; quoted the S3 compliance sentence in full instead of with an ellipsis; added a note that the article makes no claim about the external provider's own data handling; gave the voice sample's heading; noted that S5 has no section headings.
- **Check script:** added pass/fail labels, a figures-present check, a cited-paragraph count, and a "skipped" message if `inputs/` is not found.

## Checks that support leaving the rest unchanged

- **Calculations:** 3 × USD 29 = USD 87; USD 87 + USD 12 = USD 99. Both recomputed by the script.
- **Source conflicts:** USD 19 versus USD 29 is resolved in favour of the correction. The S5 "offline" claim is contradicted by S3 and stays out, as do the other five S5 claims.
- **Requirements:** word count 777 (limit 600–800), headline 62 characters (50–70), excerpt 41 words (at most 45), search description 158 characters (140–160). metadata.json parses and has exactly the three required keys.
- **Citations:** all 10 resolve to a real filename and section heading.
- **Testing claims:** the article states that neither the author nor Kingy used the product; a scan found no testing phrases.
