# Change log — review pass on Task 5 editorial package

Original submission preserved unchanged in `output/original-submission/`
(article.md, metadata.json, editor-notes.md), copied before any revision.

## Changes to article.md (2 corrections)
1. **Removed unsupported free-waitlist claim.**
   - Before: "The waitlist costs nothing but patience, and Q1 2027 is a plan, not a promise."
   - After: "Joining the waitlist is the only step available to you today, and Q1 2027 is a plan, not a promise."
   - Why: S1-announcement.md ("Access") says new customers can join a waitlist but
     states no cost. "Costs nothing" was an inference presented as fact.
2. **Corrected evidence-exclusivity wording.**
   - Before: "DeskLab's six files are the only hands-on evidence in them."
   - After: "DeskLab's six files are the only independent hands-on evidence in them."
   - Why: the vendor's internal test (S1, "Vendor test") is also hands-on evidence;
     DeskLab's distinction is independence (S4-independent-review.md).

Word count after edits: 744 excluding H1 / 754 including — still within 600–800.

## Changes to metadata.json
None. Re-verified: headline 52 chars (50–70), excerpt 37 words (≤45),
search description 154 chars (140–160), exactly the three required keys,
H1 in article matches headline.

## Changes to editor-notes.md
- Updated word counts to the revised article.
- Added "Review-pass corrections" section documenting the two fixes.
- Added assumption: waitlist cost unknown; no claim made.
- Expanded the checks list to include checks actually run in this pass
  (exact JSON key set, H1/headline match, no verbatim voice-sample overlap,
  preservation of originals) — the earlier notes listed the JSON key-set check
  before it had been explicitly scripted; it is now genuinely performed.
- Adjusted the human-finish estimate to 15–25 minutes (still an estimate).

## Checks re-run on revised deliverables (all PASS)
Via check_package.py and review_checks.py: word/character limits; all 9
filename+section citations resolve; arithmetic (87 / 99 / 8.00); banned
unsupported terms absent; JSON validity and exact keys; H1/headline match;
no verbatim sentence overlap with voice-sample.md.

## Not changed, with supporting checks
- All factual claims re-read line-by-line against S1–S4: launch date, access
  geography/channel, feature bounds (50 MB, OCR add-on, no payments/emails/
  contracts), vendor test figures and caveats, DeskLab 5-of-6 result and untested
  areas, pricing/correction, retention/deletion/backup windows, external
  processing — all match the packets as cited.
- All six S5 claims remain excluded; the only "USD 19" mention is the correction.
- Inputs untouched; no external research or testing claimed.
