Review complete. Two genuine issues were found and corrected; everything else passed re-verification. ## Revised deliverables (in `output/`) - `article.md` — revised (744 words excl. headline / 754 incl., within 600–800) - `metadata.json` — unchanged (headline 52 chars, excerpt 37 words, search description 154 chars) - `editor-notes.md` — updated counts, new checks, new assumption (waitlist cost unknown) - `change-log.md` — brief log of this pass - `original-submission/` — first submission preserved byte-for-byte before revision ## Corrections made 1. **Unsupported free-waitlist claim removed.** "The waitlist costs nothing but patience" → "Joining the waitlist is the only step available to you today." S1-announcement.md ("Access") states a waitlist exists but gives no cost; the original wording presented an inference as fact. 2. **Evidence-exclusivity wording fixed.** "only hands-on evidence" → "only **independent** hands-on evidence" — the vendor's internal test (S1, "Vendor test") is also hands-on; DeskLab's distinction is independence. 3. **Editor-notes honesty fix.** The original notes listed an "exactly three JSON keys" check that hadn't been explicitly scripted; it is now actually performed (`review_checks.py`) and passes. ## Checks supporting the unchanged parts (all actually run) - Line-by-line re-read of every factual claim against S1–S4: dates, access geography/channel, feature bounds, vendor-test figures/caveats, DeskLab 5-of-6 result, pricing/correction, retention/deletion/backup windows — all match as cited. - Scripted: all 9 filename+section citations resolve; arithmetic 3×29=87, +12=99, 100×0.08=8.00; all length limits pass; banned S5 terms absent (only "USD 19" mention is the explicit correction); JSON valid with exact keys; H1 matches headline; no verbatim sentence overlap with voice-sample.md. - Diff confirms the revised article differs from the preserved original in exactly the two intended sentences; metadata is byte-identical; inputs untouched. **Remaining limitations:** unchanged — no hands-on testing possible, vendor raw data unpublished, OCR/privacy/workflow untested, waitlist cost unknown. **Estimated human finish time:** 15–25 minutes (estimate, not measured).