# Change log: revision 2 against the original submission

The original submission is preserved unchanged in `output/original-submission/` (article.md, metadata.json, editor-notes.md, and the first check script as check-v1.py).

## Review findings

No factual error, miscalculation or unreconciled source conflict was found in the original. The review did find gaps in citation coverage, three places where wording went slightly past the source, one missing evidence caveat, and incomplete price wording in the metadata. Those are corrected below.

## article.md

| # | Change | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Added a citation (S1-announcement.md, "Features") to the opening paragraph. | The page-linked-citation feature was stated without a source. |
| 2 | Added a citation (S2-pricing.md, "Current plans") to the overage example and marked the USD 24 as my own figure ("which I make"). | The paragraph used a source rate without citing it or flagging the result as derived. |
| 3 | "The pricing page" became "The vendor's pricing document". | The packet does not say S2 is a web page. |
| 4 | "so the number cannot be checked from the outside" became "so readers have nothing to check the figure against". | The original was a broader claim than S1 "Vendor test" supports. |
| 5 | Bullet "The waitlist is your only route for now" became "The announcement offers you a waitlist, not access." | S1 "Access" does not say whether a new customer can gain access another way. |
| 6 | Added: "Both tests also used only procurement documents, so neither covers other kinds of paperwork." | Missing evidence limit: S1 "Vendor test" and S4 "Method" both cover procurement documents only. Labelled as my observation in the editor notes. |
| 7 | "Count your documents before you count seats." became "Estimate your monthly uploads before you commit." | The brief says to avoid slogans. |
| 8 | Removed "If you saw the lower number, discard it." and "That one miss is the detail I would hold on to."; shortened "Treat those as plans, not as dates to schedule around" to "Those are plans, not dates". | Word budget for the additions above. No facts were removed. |

Word count moved from 780 to 777 (whole file).

## metadata.json

| # | Change | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| 9 | Excerpt now says "USD 29 per seat per month, three seats minimum" (40 words, was 35). | "USD 29 per seat" omitted the billing period and the minimum, which could mislead on cost. |
| 10 | Search description now says "USD 29 per seat per month" (still 152 characters). | Same reason. |

Headline unchanged (61 characters).

## editor-notes.md

- Updated the check results to revision 2 figures and described what each check can and cannot show.
- Added the new inference (item 6) and the reworded ones (items 3–5) to "Assumptions and gaps in the sources".
- Added a pointer to the preserved original and to this change log.

## Checks

- New script `output/checks/check_v2.py`, placed inside `output/` so it travels with the deliverables. It adds three checks the first script lacked: every paragraph containing a figure carries a citation or is a declared recap; every numeral traces to S1–S4 or a declared derived value; the metadata is scanned for the excluded claims as well as the article.
- The first run of the new script reported one failure, on the USD 19 context check. The cause was the script's own text window being too short to reach the word "incorrect", not the article. I widened the window and re-ran; the final run reported all checks passing.
- Original files were copied before any edit and their hashes matched the sources of the copy at that point.
