# Review change log

## Revised deliverables

- `output/article.md`
- `output/metadata.json`
- `output/editor-notes.md`

Originals are preserved separately in `output/original-submission/`: the three original deliverables and original validator, plus `sha256.json`. All four were byte-compared when copied; the revised validator confirms their hashes remain unchanged. Raw inputs were not modified.

## Changes

1. **Clarified OCR wording.** Removed wording that might imply scans have a separate upload-counting classification. The evidence establishes a required OCR add-on, not different counting rules. [inputs/S1-announcement.md — Features; inputs/S2-pricing.md — Current plans]
2. **Qualified the minimum cost.** Added “before tax and overages” to the article's USD 87 figure and metadata excerpt. The calculations remain USD 87 for three seats and USD 99 with OCR. [inputs/S2-pricing.md — Current plans]
3. **Strengthened evaluation guidance and word-count robustness.** Added advice to set a cost-justifying savings target and involve the usual document checker. Renamed the final subheading to “evaluation.” The article now passes even when all headings and citations are excluded, rather than relying on subheadings contributing to the word count.
4. **Improved validation usability.** The check script now resolves paths from its own location, explicitly reads UTF-8, validates metadata string values, checks archived-file hashes and saves `output/check-results.json`. Updated editor notes to reflect the revised text and checks.

## Review outcome

Re-read the assignment and all supplied evidence. No calculation or substantive source-conflict correction was needed: the October 17 USD 29 correction still controls; the 60% figure remains confined to vendor-reported median draft time; announced access remains distinct from future API/EU plans. Unsupported internal-note claims remain excluded and explained. No firsthand testing is claimed. [inputs/S2-pricing.md — Correction; inputs/S1-announcement.md — Vendor test, Access; inputs/S5-internal-notes.txt — Unverified writer notes, October 18; inputs/editorial-brief.md — Assignment]

Executed the revised local validator successfully after updating the deliverables:

| Check | Result |
| --- | --- |
| Article paragraph words, excluding all headings and citations | 625; passes 600–800 |
| Article words including subheadings, excluding headline/citations | 659; passes |
| Article words including citations, excluding headline | 705; passes |
| Headline | 61 characters; passes 50–70 |
| Excerpt | 35 words; passes ≤45 |
| Search description | 151 characters; passes 140–160 |
| JSON, UTF-8 readability and headline consistency | Pass |
| Citation file/heading existence | 13 groups pass |
| Price and percentage arithmetic | Pass |
| Archived originals' SHA-256 integrity | Four files pass |

The article and metadata were also re-read after revision. Citation existence checks are not automated proof of factual support; support was reviewed against the supplied passages. No external research, product tests or rendered-layout checks were performed.

**Remaining limitations:** the packet cannot establish general accuracy, end-to-end savings, OCR performance, implemented privacy protections or business-specific regulatory suitability. **Estimated human finishing time:** 5–10 minutes for copy review and house-style citation handling, not a measured result.
