# Review change log

## Revised deliverables

- `action-plan.csv`
- `decision-log.md`
- `update-email.txt` (209 words including headers and sources)

Original submitted versions of these files and the original validation script are preserved byte-for-byte in `original-submission/`. The revised validation script is `check_deliverables.py`; results are in `review-checks.txt`. `review-integrity.json` records SHA-256 hashes for the archive and supplied files at the start of this review.

## Corrections and clarifications

1. **Future confirmation is not completed attendance.** Replaced the decision log's imprecise statement that guest attendance was “evidenced complete” with confirmation for the future event. The guest has not been represented as having already attended. Evidence: `inputs/03-email-thread.txt`, “Field Notes decisions”, Alex, October 18, 12:30 Pacific.
2. **Invitation deadline versus dispatch.** Explicitly marked draft delivery as this plan's interpretation of the invitation deadline, not wording quoted from CR-07 or a send authorization. Marked review of invitation drafts as a proposed coordination step rather than an additional approved registration gate. Evidence: `inputs/04-approved-change.md`, “Approved change request — CR-07”; `inputs/03-email-thread.txt`, Priya, October 18, 09:00 Pacific; `inputs/05-open-questions.txt`, October 20, 09:30 Pacific — Mei to Priya.
3. **Failure recovery.** Clarified that an initial failed test can be remediated/retested within October 22, retaining the original opening if all gates are satisfied. Seek a revised schedule only if the original gates cannot be met. No replacement date or successful retest is asserted. Evidence for the gates: `inputs/04-approved-change.md`, “Approved change request — CR-07”. Recovery sequencing remains proposed.
4. **Email and dependency usability.** Made year/timezone explicit in the email and grouped recommendations under “Proposed next steps.” Explained that CSV dependencies include conditional triggers and nonblocking checks, not only strict predecessors. Preserved the exact required seven-column schema and all 17 action IDs.

## Review and checks actually performed

- Re-read `COMMON.md`, `PROMPT.md`, all five evidence files, and the original deliverables; inspected the revised decision log.
- Compared operative decisions to the dated approvals: October 30 at 11:00; 45 minutes; MeetRoom; 80-person cap; free entry; CAD 1,200 cap; CR-07 deadlines, conditional opening, written-consent rule and separate advertising approval. No additional substantive conflict-resolution change was needed. Relevant records: `inputs/03-email-thread.txt`, Priya October 18, 09:00, and `inputs/04-approved-change.md`, “Approved change request — CR-07”; superseded requirements remain documented in the decision log.
- Ran revised `check_deliverables.py`: exact CSV header, 17 complete rows, unique action IDs, existing dependency references, no self-references, CSV round-trip, existing CSV-cited input files, expected owners/deadlines, unassigned tester, conditional registration opening, and advertising hold. All passed. This does not treat conditional references as a strict dependency graph or automatically establish citation entailment.
- Checked the email's addressee, draft marker, year/timezone and word count: 209 whitespace-delimited words, below the 220-word limit.
- Calculated 11:00 + 45 minutes = 11:45 Pacific on October 30, 2026. This is a derived end time, not a new approval.
- Verified archive and all seven supplied files against review-start hashes. All unchanged. Initial archive copies were also checked byte-for-byte against the then-current submitted files before revision.

## Remaining limitations and handoff

The packet still does not assign the tester, publisher, dispatcher or recipient-consent verification/decision roles; it supplies no exact test slot, recipient-scope evidence, written recording permission, test results or final launch approval. These remain open, not inferred complete. No platform tests, consent verification, approvals, sending or publication were performed; checks above are document checks only.

Estimated human effort: 15–25 minutes to review the revised plan and assign outstanding responsibilities. This is a planning estimate, not measured time; obtaining consent records/decisions and performing platform tests require additional time that cannot be estimated reliably from this packet.
