# Review change log

## Revised submission
- `output/action-plan.csv` — 15 actions, seven required columns.
- `output/decision-log.md` — authority, decisions, proposals and source register.
- `output/update-email.txt` — 205 whitespace-delimited words including headers; draft addressed to the project team.
- `output/build_deliverables.py` — updated generation/validation helper.

## Original preserved
The four original submission files are preserved byte-for-byte under `output/original-submission/`. `sha256-manifest.json` records their hashes. No raw input was edited. Archive hashes were checked after revision. `output/review-and-revise.py` records the one-time preservation, edits and independent checks; it refuses to overwrite the archive if rerun.

## Corrections and why
1. **Campaign approval ownership:** removed the unsupported assertion that Priya is the campaign approver. CR-07 requires separate written approval but does not name its approver (`inputs/04-approved-change.md`, “Approved change request — CR-07”). Priya remains project coordinator (`inputs/01-original-brief.md`, “Original brief — October 14, 09:00 Pacific”). Also corrected wording that could imply the October 16 notes had authorized spend once the speaker confirmed; they stated a prerequisite, not sufficient authorization (`inputs/02-meeting-notes.md`, “Planning notes — October 16, 14:00 Pacific”).
2. **Mei's ownership:** removed “Mei owns copy only.” CR-07 assigns Mei invitations, without an explicit copy-only restriction. Draft delivery is a stated interpretation of the draft hold and unresolved audience, not a direct quotation of CR-07. Send execution and timing remain to be confirmed, rather than denying Mei's invitation ownership (`inputs/03-email-thread.txt`, Priya, October 18, 09:00; `inputs/05-open-questions.txt`, Mei to Priya, October 20, 09:30).
3. **Dependencies:** removed consent/audience context from drafting prerequisites so that safe live-only copy and slides are not blocked unnecessarily. Identified the failure/escalation row as a trigger rather than requiring successful approval. Marked post-opening invitation sequence as proposed.
4. **Executable next step:** added A15, explicitly proposed coordination to confirm publication/send execution before launch, rather than leaving operator confirmation only inside the opening/send rows. Its October 22 target is proposed, not an approved deadline.
5. **Decision/proposal distinction:** explicitly labelled the mailing hold and verification process as proposed safeguards responding to the unresolved consent scope, not a new approval found in the evidence. Email now states the interpretation of Mei's draft deadline and preserves the <=220-word limit.

## Review and checks actually performed
- Reread `COMMON.md`, `PROMPT.md`, all five project inputs and all four original output files. Compared approved dates, roles, event parameters, superseded instructions and consent limitations against the source records.
- Recalculated 11:00 + 45 minutes = 11:45 Pacific. No timezone conversion is necessary; all source times and deliverable times remain Pacific.
- Regenerated the three deliverables; parsed the UTF-8 CSV with Python's standard-library CSV reader. Verified exact headers, 15 unique action IDs, seven fields per record, nonempty required deliverables, valid referenced action IDs and valid source keys mapped in the decision log.
- Checked the action-reference graph for cycles; none found. This is a structural check, not a scheduling simulation or proof that external deadlines can be met.
- Counted the entire email including headers: **205 words** using whitespace separation (limit 220). Checked team addressee and draft marking.
- Verified preserved original-file hashes and unchanged hashes for all seven supplied input files.
- No external access, platform tests, consent verification, operational actions or message sending occurred. These checks validate the documents, not project readiness.

## Remaining limitations and handoff
Test assignment, test slot/criteria/results, written speaker consent, subscriber permission evidence, recipient decision, publication/send execution and any campaign approver remain unverified or unresolved. No revised opening date is invented. Captions, 80-seat capacity and Priya's approval remain launch gates; live-only remains the no-consent default (CR-07 and cited records in the decision log).

Estimated human review/triage: **20–30 minutes**, excluding waiting for decisions, platform testing, copy production and event execution. This is a planning estimate, not measured work time.
