# Field Notes webinar — decision log

Status as of October 20, 2026, 10:00 Pacific. Draft for the project team; nothing has been sent, published or tested by the coordinator. All dates are 2026 and all times Pacific (inputs/01-original-brief.md). Revised after self-review; see change-log.md. The first submission is kept in output/original-submission/.

## Source key

| Short name used below | File | Heading or record |
|---|---|---|
| 01-original-brief | inputs/01-original-brief.md | Original brief, October 14, 09:00 |
| 02-meeting-notes | inputs/02-meeting-notes.md | Planning notes, October 16, 14:00 |
| 03-email-thread | inputs/03-email-thread.txt | "Field Notes decisions": Priya Oct 18 09:00; Alex Oct 18 12:30; Jonah Oct 19 08:10 |
| 04-approved-change / CR-07 | inputs/04-approved-change.md | Approved change request CR-07, approved by Priya Oct 19 16:00 |
| 05-open-questions | inputs/05-open-questions.txt | Mei to Priya, October 20, 09:30 |

## How conflicts were resolved

1. An item counts as **agreed** only if a source records an explicit approval: Priya's "Approved:" email (inputs/03-email-thread.txt, Priya, Oct 18 09:00) or the approved change request CR-07 (inputs/04-approved-change.md, approved by Priya Oct 19 16:00).
2. Where two approved instructions conflict, the later one wins. Order of sources: brief Oct 14 09:00 → planning notes Oct 16 14:00 → Priya email Oct 18 09:00 → CR-07 Oct 19 16:00.
3. Earlier instructions that no later approval touches still stand (for example, 45 minutes and the CAD 1,200 cap).
4. Suggestions, proposals and questions with "no decision" or "no approval" are listed as proposals or open issues, not decisions.

## Agreed decisions

| ID | Decision | Approval | Replaces |
|---|---|---|---|
| D01 | Event is October 30 at 11:00 Pacific; this is final. Guest speaker confirmed the slot. | Priya, Oct 18 09:00 (03-email-thread); CR-07 "is final" (04-approved-change); guest confirmation reported by Alex, Oct 18 12:30 (03-email-thread) | October 29 at 10:00 (01-original-brief) |
| D02 | Duration 45 minutes. | Priya, Oct 18 09:00 (03-email-thread) | Unchanged from brief |
| D03 | Free entry. | Priya, Oct 18 09:00 (03-email-thread) | Unchanged from brief; closes the paid-ticket proposal (P02) |
| D04 | Budget cap CAD 1,200. | Priya, Oct 18 09:00 (03-email-thread) | Unchanged from brief |
| D05 | Platform is MeetRoom. | Priya, Oct 18 09:00 "Keep MeetRoom" (03-email-thread) | Closes the StreamHall suggestion (P01) |
| D06 | Attendee cap is 80, because the plan does not include more. | Priya, Oct 18 09:00 (03-email-thread) | 120 maximum (01-original-brief) |
| D07 | All launch copy stays in draft until the platform test passes. | Priya, Oct 18 09:00 (03-email-thread); consistent with 02-meeting-notes | — |
| D08 | Registration opens Oct 23 at 09:00 Pacific, only if the captions and capacity tests pass on Oct 22. Captions are a launch requirement. | CR-07 (04-approved-change); 02-meeting-notes | No opening date was set in the brief |
| D09 | Priya must assign the platform test owner by Oct 21 at 12:00. | CR-07 (04-approved-change) | — |
| D10 | Jonah owns landing page corrections, due Oct 21 at 17:00. | CR-07 (04-approved-change) | "Landing page by Oct 21" (01-original-brief) |
| D11 | Mei owns invitations, due Oct 22 at 12:00. | CR-07 (04-approved-change) | "Emails by Oct 22" (01-original-brief) |
| D12 | Alex owns slides, due Oct 27 at 17:00. | CR-07 (04-approved-change) | Slides by Oct 26 (01-original-brief) |
| D13 | Alex owns speaker consent follow-up, due Oct 21. | CR-07 (04-approved-change); Alex, Oct 18 12:30 (03-email-thread) | — |
| D14 | Priya owns final launch approval, due Oct 22 at 17:00. Landing page publication still needs Priya's approval. | CR-07 (04-approved-change); 01-original-brief | — |
| D15 | No recording or replay promise may appear without written speaker consent. If consent is absent, the event runs live-only. | CR-07 (04-approved-change) | "Record the event and email replay to all registrants" (01-original-brief) |
| D16 | Paid advertising stays on hold until there is a separate written campaign approval. Speaker confirmation alone does not authorize spending. | CR-07 (04-approved-change) | "No paid campaign until the speaker confirms" (Priya, 02-meeting-notes) |

## Superseded instructions — do not act on these

| Old instruction | Source | Current position |
|---|---|---|
| October 29 at 10:00 Pacific | 01-original-brief | October 30 at 11:00 Pacific (D01) |
| 120 attendees maximum | 01-original-brief | 80 (D06) |
| Record the event and email a replay to all registrants | 01-original-brief | Live-only unless written speaker consent exists (D15) |
| Slides by Oct 26 | 01-original-brief | Oct 27 at 17:00 (D12) |
| Paid campaign can follow speaker confirmation | 02-meeting-notes | Needs separate written campaign approval (D16). The speaker confirmed on Oct 18, and that does not release any spend. |

## Proposals — not approved

| ID | Proposal | Raised by | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| P01 | Move to StreamHall because captions might be better | Jonah, Oct 16 (02-meeting-notes) | No decision at the meeting; closed by "Keep MeetRoom" (D05). It is not an approved fallback. |
| P02 | Paid tickets to offset costs | Mei, Oct 16 (02-meeting-notes) | Not approved; free entry was approved on Oct 18 (D03). |
| P03 | Paid advertising campaign | Discussed Oct 16 (02-meeting-notes) | On hold. No written campaign approval exists in the inputs (D16). |
| P04 | Interim dates and owners marked "proposed" in action-plan.csv (A03, A05, A06, A08, A10, A12) | Coordinator, this draft | Suggestions only, for Priya to accept or change. None appears in a source. |

## Unresolved issues

### Ownership
- **U01 Platform test owner.** Not assigned. Priya must assign by Oct 21 at 12:00 (CR-07). The tests in A08 and A09 cannot be scheduled or run until this is done.
- **U02 Who confirms the landing page replacement wording.** Jonah asked "Please confirm replacement language" on Oct 19 08:10 without naming anyone, and no reply is in the inputs (03-email-thread). CR-07 sets the constraint (no recording or replay promise) but approves no wording.
- **U03 Who publishes the landing page and opens registration on Oct 23.** Jonah owns corrections and Priya owns approval; no source assigns the publishing step.
- **U04 Who verifies mailing-list consent scope.** Mei cannot verify it from her file (05-open-questions). No verifier is named.
- **U05 Replay email owner.** The brief required a replay email but named no owner. Only relevant if written speaker consent arrives.
- **U06 Campaign approval.** CR-07 requires a "separate written campaign approval" but names neither requester nor approver.

### Scheduling
- **U07 Test time on Oct 22.** CR-07 gives the date only. Results must reach Priya before the 17:00 launch approval. Mei's invitation drafts are due at 12:00 the same day and may precede the results, which is acceptable only because they stay in draft (D07).
- **U08 Pass criteria.** No source defines what "pass" means for the captions or capacity tests. A08 assumes capacity is tested against the 80-seat cap.
- **U09 No fallback if a test fails.** Registration then does not open on Oct 23 (D08). No alternative date or platform is approved.
- **U10 Consent deadline versus landing page deadline.** Speaker consent follow-up is due Oct 21 with no time; landing page corrections are due Oct 21 at 17:00. The plan therefore uses live-only wording by default and changes it only if written consent arrives.
- **U11 Invitation send time.** Not set. It cannot precede launch approval (Oct 22 17:00) or registration opening (Oct 23 09:00).
- **U12 Recipient decision deadline.** Not set (05-open-questions). It must be made before any send.

### Consent
- **U13 Speaker recording and replay consent.** Not held. The guest consents to live attendance only; Alex committed to requesting recording and replay consent by Oct 21 (03-email-thread, Alex, Oct 18 12:30). The inputs do not show whether the request has gone out, or whether the live-attendance consent itself is in writing. Until written consent exists: no recording, no replay, no promise of either on the landing page, invitations or slides (D15).
- **U14 Invitation recipients.** All 600 newsletter subscribers or the webinar opt-in segment only: no decision, and the consent scope is unverified (05-open-questions, Mei to Priya, Oct 20 09:30). No invitation should go out until this is decided.

## Assumptions

- Terms carry forward unchanged where a later approval is silent (D02, D04, D06).
- "Platform test" in Priya's Oct 18 email and "captions and capacity tests" in CR-07 are treated as the same gate.
- Alex still hosts (01-original-brief); no later source changes this.
- "Run live-only" (CR-07) is read as: no recording is made and no replay is sent unless written speaker consent exists.
- The inputs contain no cost or spend figures, so status against the CAD 1,200 cap cannot be assessed.
- Final launch approval (A11) is not made dependent on the recipient decision (A06). CR-07 conditions registration opening on the tests only; the recipient decision gates sending invitations (A13).
- Completion status is taken from the inputs only. Jonah's Oct 19 offer to update the date and cap "today" is not confirmed as done.

## Sequence of next steps

Dates and owners taken from CR-07 are agreed. Anything marked "Proposed" is a coordinator suggestion with no source deadline or confirmed owner.

| When | Step | Action IDs |
|---|---|---|
| Oct 20–21 | Alex requests written recording/replay consent. Mei continues drafting. Proposed: replacement wording for the replay line is confirmed, and the consent scope of the lists is checked once someone is assigned. | A02, A07, A03, A05 |
| Oct 21, 12:00 | Priya assigns the platform test owner. | A01 |
| Oct 21, 17:00 | Jonah's landing page corrections are complete, in draft, with the replay promise removed. Proposed: test time and pass criteria are set by the same time. | A04, A08 |
| Oct 21 (no time stated) | Alex's consent follow-up is due. With no written consent, everything stays live-only. | A02 |
| Oct 22, 12:00 | Mei's invitation drafts are complete, with no recipients selected. | A07 |
| Oct 22 (time not set; before 17:00) | Captions and capacity tests run on MeetRoom; pass/fail is reported in writing. Proposed: the recipient decision and a test-failure fallback are settled by 17:00. | A09, A06, A10 |
| Oct 22, 17:00 | Priya gives or withholds final launch approval. This does not wait on the recipient decision. | A11 |
| Oct 23, 09:00 | If the tests passed and approval was given: registration opens. Invitations go only after the recipient decision, to the approved segment. | A12, A13 |
| Oct 27, 17:00 | Alex delivers slides. | A14 |
| Oct 30, 11:00 | Live webinar, 45 minutes, MeetRoom, 80 seats. Recording off unless written consent is on file. | A15, A16 |
