# Review and change log

## Result

The recommendation remains **O2 / F16-32 from Harbour Tech**, CAD **2,098.88** landed with **101.12** headroom, guaranteed October 22, 2026. It is the sole qualifying offer under the GPU-type interpretation now explicitly disclosed. No arithmetic or source-conflict correction was needed.

## Changes

- Preserved both original deliverables byte-for-byte in `output/original_submission/` before editing.
- Added an explicit hardware interpretation to the recommendation and every CSV row: S1 names GX GPUs and provides VRAM but does not explicitly state “discrete.” Treating these as discrete is an interpretation, not a separately verified fact. The recommendation and GPU pass checks are conditional on it. Also clarified that 1,024 GB meets the 1 TB SSD minimum. [ `inputs/S1-manufacturer-specs.csv`, all six SKU rows. ]
- Added `original_listed_delivery` to the CSV alongside the effective delivery, making O6’s superseded October 23 date and corrected October 27 date directly inspectable. [ `inputs/S2-store-offers.csv`, O6; `inputs/S3-store-correction.md`, “S3 — Direct Aspen correction — October 19, 2026, 08:45 Pacific,” O6/A15-32. ]
- Reworded the tax note to say listed discounts are already applied, rather than implying independent knowledge about further discounts. [ `inputs/00-source-register.md`, “Scenario sources — captured October 19, 2026, 09:00 Pacific.” ]

## Checks actually performed

- Re-read all five supplied input files and both submitted deliverables.
- Recomputed subtotal, 12% tax, landed total and budget headroom for all six offers using Python Decimal arithmetic. Totals in O1–O6 order: CAD 2,238.88; 2,098.88; 1,790.88; 1,902.88; 2,126.88; 2,037.28. Compared the saved CSV directly against the raw S1 and S2 fields and re-derived each requirement check. [ `inputs/S1-manufacturer-specs.csv`, all SKU rows; `inputs/S2-store-offers.csv`, O1–O6; source register tax rule. ]
- Confirmed O3 has 16 GB/512 GB and O4 has 6 GB VRAM despite their titles. Confirmed O5 is estimated, not committed, and S3 explicitly overrides O6 irrespective of snapshot timestamp ordering; no expedited service is offered. [ S1 F16-16 and V15-32; S2 O3–O6; S3 O6/A15-32; full filenames above. ]
- Confirmed S4 supports only the exact F16-32 single plugged-in UHD H.264 test: 8 minutes 40 seconds, no export errors and noticeable fans. The recommendation does not generalize this to a ranking, battery work, ProRes or measured decibels. [ `inputs/S4-independent-test.md`, “S4 — Edit Bench lab note — October 17, 2026.” ]
- Checked that the fallback is conditional on obtaining a new delivery commitment for O5; it is not presented as an existing qualifying alternative. Checked for unsupported purchase/contact/test claims: none are asserted as performed by the assistant.
- Parsed the revised UTF-8 CSV successfully: six unique offer rows, consistent columns, no missing cells or extra fields. Confirmed cited files exist, all six landed totals appear in the Markdown, and the recommendation remains within 650 words. These are programmatic/text checks, not a spreadsheet-app or rendered-Markdown inspection.
- Verified archived originals against SHA-256 digests captured before revision. No raw input files were modified by this review script.

## Limitations and handoff

Revised deliverables: `output/recommendation.md` and `output/comparison.csv`. This log: `output/review-change-log.md`. Originals: `output/original_submission/recommendation.md` and `output/original_submission/comparison.csv`.

No live availability, checkout, Vancouver address-specific delivery verification, retailer contact, purchase, hardware inspection or new performance testing was performed. For this scenario, delivery commitments are applied as supplied in S2/S3; GPU type remains an expressly disclosed interpretation. If literal independent confirmation of “discrete” is required, obtain it for F16-32 before purchase; it is not present in this packet. The O5 fallback likewise needs a new written delivery commitment, not assumed availability.

Estimated human follow-up: **5–10 minutes** to review the deliverables and initiate GPU-type/checkout confirmation; retailer response time is additional and unknown. This is an estimate, not a measured result.

Recommendation word count (whitespace-delimited): **611**.

Archived original SHA-256 digests:

- `recommendation.md`: `a136228449ce0815c1b437294c43c0934492aacf41de86570ea5f42b029e9622`
- `comparison.csv`: `5362bb1826161188f14d1547a84dc11f8f19b15fb033cf6b31dc3c66b567f2d3`
