# Change log — review of Task 2 submission

The original submission is preserved unchanged in `output/original_submission/`.
The revised deliverables are `output/recommendation.md` and `output/comparison.csv`.

## Outcome

The recommendation (O2), every landed total, every pass/fail result and the fallback are unchanged.
The review found no calculation or source-conflict error. It found five presentation and evidence-wording issues, corrected below.

## Corrections

1. **Unstated assumption about "discrete" GPU.** The assignment requires a discrete GPU. No source uses that word; S1 only lists a named GPU and a VRAM figure per SKU. The original treated this as verified. The revision records it as an assumption in `recommendation.md` and in a new `gpu_discrete_basis` column.
2. **Overstated wording on O3/O4.** The original said their hardware "cannot be fixed". The packet only says not to assume configurable upgrades (`inputs/00-source-register.md`). The revision says that instead.
3. **Source IDs.** The register says to use source IDs. The revision cites S1–S4 with a filename key at the top of `recommendation.md`, and adds source IDs and the `inputs/` prefix to the `sources` column.
4. **CSV usability.** The original O5 delivery cell mixed a date with text ("2026-10-22 (estimate only)"). The revision has two clean date columns, `s2_delivery_date` (as listed) and `effective_delivery_date` (after the S3 correction for O6), and adds `budget_margin_cad`. O2's `unknowns` cell now records that stock is not in the packet.
5. **S4 wording.** "One 4K export" changed to "one completed UHD export", matching S4's own term.

## Checks run on the revised files (`check2.py`)

- All seven CSV lines parse to 29 columns.
- Price, shipping, store, subtotal, 12% tax, landed total, budget margin, spec fields (model, RAM, SSD, GPU, VRAM, weight, OS), listed and effective delivery dates, delivery type and status were recomputed or compared against `inputs/S1-manufacturer-specs.csv`, `inputs/S2-store-offers.csv` and `inputs/S3-store-correction.md`. All six rows match.
- Only O2 passes all hard requirements.
- Word count of `recommendation.md` is reported in the final handoff.
- The preserved originals have the same hashes as the files submitted in the first round.

## Not checked

- Rendering in a Markdown viewer or spreadsheet application.
- Anything outside the packet (stock, live checkout terms).
