# Review and change log

## Result and revised deliverables

- `output/recommendation.md`: retained O2 / F16-32 at CAD 2,098.88 landed, CAD 101.12 below budget, with guaranteed October 22, 2026 arrival. No arithmetic or source-conflict decision required correction. Clarified Vancouver applicability as a scenario assumption and added address-specific delivery and discrete-GPU classification to pre-payment checks. Recommendation is 603 whitespace-delimited words, below 650.
- `output/comparison.csv`: retained all six offers, specifications, amounts, outcomes and citations. Added separate new-condition, RAM, SSD, Windows, discrete-GPU and VRAM requirement-status columns, plus the original store listing note. These make hard requirements and listing discrepancies easier to audit without conflating GPU interpretation with explicit source verification.
- Original deliverables are preserved byte-for-byte at `output/original_submission/recommendation.md` and `output/original_submission/comparison.csv`. Raw inputs were not modified.

## Checks actually performed

Read the assignment and all five input files, then reviewed the original recommendation and CSV against them. Ran a local Python standard-library review script (`review_submission.py`) successfully, and read back the revised recommendation.

Automated checks covered six unique offers; every hardware field against the matching SKU; prices and shipping against matching offers; taxable subtotals, 12% tax, landed totals and budget headroom; effective delivery dates and delivery statuses; Markdown/CSV financial consistency; expected hard failures; row-level hardware/commercial/register citation references; O6 correction citation; UTF-8 CSV readback with consistent fields; recommendation length; byte-for-byte original preservation; and unchanged input hashes during the review. No spreadsheet application or rendered Markdown viewer was used.

Verified landed totals, in offer order: O1 CAD 2,238.88; O2 CAD 2,098.88; O3 CAD 1,790.88; O4 CAD 1,902.88; O5 CAD 2,126.88; O6 CAD 2,037.28. Calculation: (price + shipping) × 1.12. Sources: `inputs/S2-store-offers.csv`, O1–O6; `inputs/00-source-register.md`, “Scenario sources — captured October 19, 2026, 09:00 Pacific”.

Source-conflict review confirmed:
- O3's 16 GB / 512 GB and O4's 6 GB VRAM override erroneous listing titles. Sources: `inputs/S1-manufacturer-specs.csv`, F16-16 and V15-32; `inputs/S2-store-offers.csv`, O3 and O4.
- O5's estimated October 22 arrival remains unconfirmed. Source: `inputs/S2-store-offers.csv`, O5; source-register section above.
- O6's October 27 guarantee supersedes October 23; no expedited service is available. Source: `inputs/S3-store-correction.md`, “S3 — Direct Aspen correction — October 19, 2026, 08:45 Pacific”, O6 / A15-32.
- Performance wording matches one plugged-in F16-32 UHD H.264 run (8 minutes 40 seconds), not a ranking or a test of other codecs/machines. Source: `inputs/S4-independent-test.md`, “S4 — Edit Bench lab note — October 17, 2026”. This source test was reviewed, not rerun.

## Remaining limitations and handoff

S1 does not explicitly classify GPU architecture; the disclosed interpretation of named GX GPUs and separately listed VRAM remains. Shipping/delivery terms are applied to Vancouver within the scenario, not independently address-verified. No retailer contact, new guarantee, purchase, hardware test or external research occurred. O5 is a conditional fallback only, not a second qualifying offer.

Estimated human follow-up: 5–10 minutes to review and confirm exact-SKU, GPU, checkout and address-specific delivery terms before purchase, excluding retailer response time. This is an estimate, not a measured duration. No further document work is identified.
