## Review result **One correction made; recommendation and all calculations stand.** ### Change log - **`output/recommendation.md`** — added one explicit assumption: S1's named GX GPUs with dedicated VRAM are treated as *discrete* (the hard requirement says "discrete GPU"; S1 lists GPU model + dedicated VRAM but never the word "discrete"). Word count 638 → 649, still ≤ 650. Diff confirms this is the only text change. - **`output/comparison.csv`** — unchanged; verified byte-identical to the original. - **`output/REVIEW-CHANGELOG.md`** — new, records the change and all review checks. - **`output/original_submission/`** — original recommendation.md and comparison.csv preserved before editing. ### Checks supporting the "no other corrections needed" conclusion (all actually run) 1. **Arithmetic re-done independently with `Decimal`** (not the float generator): all six landed totals and tax amounts match, and price + shipping + tax reconciles per row. O2 = 2,098.88 (headroom 101.12); O1 overage 38.88 confirmed. 2. **CSV usability**: parses cleanly, header + all 6 offers, every spec field matches the S1 join; delivery matches S2 except O6 (2026-10-27 guaranteed per S3). 3. **Qualification logic re-derived from scratch**: only O2 passes; per-offer failure reasons match (O1 budget; O3 RAM+SSD; O4 VRAM; O5 unconfirmed; O6 late). 4. **Conflict handling** re-checked against the register's authority rules (S1 > S2 titles; S3 supersedes O6; estimates ≠ commitments). Noted timestamp oddity (S3 08:45 vs capture 09:00) — register explicitly designates S3 as superseding, so no ambiguity; documented in the change log. 5. **Claim audit**: all six totals and all five filenames cited in the md; S4 facts quoted exactly (single run, plugged in, 8m40s, untested items); no benchmarks claimed for untested SKUs; fallback phrased as a proposed action, never a performed one. 6. **Inputs preserved** — all five files intact; no writes ever targeted `inputs/`. ### Handoff - **Outputs**: `output/recommendation.md` (revised, 649 words), `output/comparison.csv`, `output/REVIEW-CHANGELOG.md`, `output/original_submission/{recommendation.md, comparison.csv}`; working scripts `build_comparison.py`, `verify_submission.py`, `diff_check.py`. - **Limitations**: synthetic packet only — no stock/retailer/benchmark verification possible; "confirmed delivery" = guaranteed on/before Oct 23 (recorded assumption); discrete-GPU inference now explicit. - **Estimated human finish time**: ~5–10 minutes to review and place the order (estimate, not measured).