The review left the recommendation unchanged: O2 (Forge Studio 16, SKU F16-32, Harbour Tech) at a landed total of CAD 2,098.88 is still the only qualifying offer. I did correct several documentation and assumption gaps, and the original files are preserved unmodified in `output/original_submission/`. ## Change log 1. **Discrete-GPU assumption recorded.** The packet never calls any GPU "discrete", and the original marked that requirement as met without saying so. The recommendation now states the assumption, and `comparison.csv` has a `discrete_gpu_ok` column set to `ASSUMED` for every row. 2. **Citations tightened.** The recommendation now has a source key with exact `inputs/` filenames and the exact heading of each markdown source. The CSV sources carry the `inputs/` prefix. 3. **Unknowns made consistent.** The original listed "stock not stated" only against O2. Stock and order cut-off time are unstated for every offer, and every row now says so. 4. **O6 traceability.** `comparison.csv` now shows the superseded October 23 date (`delivery_date_S2`) beside the corrected October 27 date. 5. **S3 timestamp remark removed.** The original implied a tension between the correction's 08:45 time and the register's 09:00 capture time. The 09:00 time is when the packet was captured, and the offers file has no timestamp of its own, so there is no conflict. 6. **Word-count margin.** The O2 requirement table became a bullet list to make room for items 1 and 2. The recommendation is now 645 words by whitespace count (the original was 649 against the 650 limit). ## Checks that support leaving the rest unchanged I ran the revised `check.py`, and it confirmed: - **Calculations:** subtotal, tax, landed total, budget margin and each computed pass/fail flag match a recomputation from the two input CSVs, with the October 27 date applied to O6. - **Qualifying offers:** O2 is the only offer passing every computed requirement. "New" comes from the register's default and "discrete" is assumed; neither is computed. - **File usability:** all six offers are present in `comparison.csv`, and every row has the same 33 columns. - **Citations and quotes:** all five input filenames and the three markdown headings appear exactly in the recommendation. The quoted listing notes and the "Delivery estimates are not commitments" line match the inputs verbatim. - **Preservation:** `original_submission/` holds the three original files. The treatment of the O3 and O4 listing titles, the O5 estimate, the O6 correction and the fallback approach was re-read against the inputs and left as it was. ## Remaining limitations - The packet gives no stock levels or order cut-off times, so O2's October 22 guarantee for an October 19 purchase should be confirmed at checkout. - Performance evidence exists only for F16-32, from a single export run. - No store was contacted; the written-guarantee step for O5 is a proposed action for the buyer. **Estimated human time to finish:** about 5–10 minutes to review and place the order. This is an estimate, not a measurement. Files are in `output/`: - `recommendation.md` - `comparison.csv` - `CHANGELOG.md` - `check.py` - `preserve_v1.py` - `original_submission/`