{
  "run_id": "T01-R2-qwen4",
  "model": "qwen/qwen4-max",
  "effort": "high",
  "started": "2026-11-16T05:04:45.253578+00:00",
  "attempt": "approved completion pass",
  "stages": {
    "initial": {
      "status": "complete",
      "answer": "Task 1 complete. All deliverables are in `output/`.\n\n## Results (October 2026, CAD — provisional)\n\n| Metric | Workshop | Course | Combined |\n|---|---:|---:|---:|\n| Paid orders | 5 | 4 | 9 |\n| Gross sales | 1,920.00 | 900.00 | 2,820.00 |\n| Applied refunds | 240.00 | 60.00 | 300.00 |\n| Net revenue | 1,680.00 | 840.00 | 2,520.00 |\n| Ad spend | 300.00 | 150.00 | 450.00 |\n| Contribution after ads | 1,380.00 | 690.00 | 2,070.00 |\n| Net revenue / paid order | 336.00 | 210.00 | 280.00 |\n\nProvisional because settled refund RF05 (refunds.csv R06) has a missing amount — preserved as unknown, never zero, per policy.\n\n## Handoff\n\n**Output files**\n- `output/cleaned-sales.csv` — 9 paid October orders (source row IDs preserved; S03;S04 collapsed, S10 kept over S09 per latest `updated_at`)\n- `output/cleaned-refunds.csv` — 2 applied refunds (RF01, RF02; product inherited from linked order)\n- `output/cleaned-ads.csv` — 5 October ads (AD03 duplicate collapsed, channels normalized)\n- `output/exceptions.csv` — 13 entries covering all duplicates, the superseded conflict, and every exclusion/flag (pending, cancelled, out-of-period, orphan order N9999, missing refund amount)\n- `output/summary.md` — full reconciliation, method, assumptions, recommendation (resolve RF05/RF04 first; cautious Workshop budget tilt; contribution ≠ profit since COGS, fees, salaries, overhead are not supplied)\n- `output/reconcile.py` — reproducible script (stdlib only), identical to the executed version\n\n**Checks actually performed**\n- Ran the script; assertion passed: all 29 raw row IDs accounted for exactly once across cleaned provenance + exclusions (15 sales, 7 refunds, 7 ads)\n- Hand-calculated totals independently — matched script output\n- Verified both applied refunds ≤ their order's paid gross (240≤480; 60≤240)\n- Read back all four output CSVs line by line; fixed two issues found during checks (row-ID accounting logic for collapsed duplicates; duplicate-detail wording)\n- Raw inputs untouched (only read; sizes listed post-run)\n\n**Remaining limitations**\n- Net revenue/contribution provisional until RF05's amount is recovered (combined floor 2,040.00 if RF05=360.00 cap and RF04=120.00 proves valid)\n- RF04's order N9999 is absent from sales data — needs source-system follow-up, not resolvable from inputs\n- No causal ad-attribution or cost data; refund product attribution assumed from linked order (documented in summary.md)\n- Only Task 1 inputs were supplied; no site/ exists for a Task 3\n\n**Estimated human finish time:** ~20–30 minutes (review exception dispositions, confirm RF05/RF04 externally, sign off) — an estimate, not a measured result.",
      "elapsed_min": 3.631765602783465,
      "finished": "2026-11-16T05:08:23.160517+00:00"
    },
    "revision": {
      "status": "complete",
      "answer": "Review complete. The core reconciliation was correct — no included record, exclusion decision, or monetary total changed. Three presentation/preservation issues were found and corrected.\n\n## Review findings and change log\n\n**Verified correct (no change needed):**\n- All totals recomputed via an independent checker (`output/verify.py`) using hand-derived expected records and integer-cent arithmetic, a separate code path from `reconcile.py`: Workshop 1,920.00 / 240.00 / 1,680.00 / 300.00 / 1,380.00 / 336.00; Course 900.00 / 60.00 / 840.00 / 150.00 / 690.00 / 210.00; Combined 2,820.00 / 300.00 / 2,520.00 / 450.00 / 2,070.00 / 280.00 — all matched.\n- Policy applications re-audited against `inputs/policy.md`: DD/MM slash dates (S02, S07, R02), latest-`updated_at` conflict resolution (S10 over S09), duplicate collapse (S04, R03, A04), pending/cancelled/out-of-period exclusions, orphan N9999 flag, missing RF05 amount kept unknown → provisional status, refund ≤ gross checks. All correct.\n- All 29 raw row IDs accounted for exactly once; date/money formats valid; derived claims (5.6× ratios, 2,040.00 floor) arithmetically correct.\n\n**Corrections made:**\n1. **exceptions.csv (S09 detail)** — now preserves the discarded conflicting gross (`gross_cad 120 superseded by 180`), not just timestamps, better satisfying \"preserve unresolved values without guessing.\"\n2. **summary.md (RF03)** — the first pass said a later settlement \"would fall\" on October net revenue; that was period-ambiguous. Under the settlement-date rule, it reduces October only if settled with an October date (to 1,440.00 Workshop), otherwise the later month. Reworded.\n3. **summary.md (share precision)** — Workshop contribution share \"66%\" corrected to 66.7% (1,380.00 / 2,070.00). Also fixed verify.py's hardcoded check count to report the actual number (23).\n\n## Deliverables\n- Revised: `output/cleaned-sales.csv`, `cleaned-refunds.csv`, `cleaned-ads.csv` (byte-identical to first pass, hash-verified), `exceptions.csv`, `summary.md` (with revision log), `reconcile.py`\n- New: `output/verify.py` — independent checker, **all 23 checks passed**\n- Original preserved unmodified: `output/original-submission/` (all 6 first-pass files, hashes recorded)\n\n**Checks actually performed this pass:** ran `output/reconcile.py` directly (assertion passed); ran `output/verify.py` (23/23 passed); SHA-256 confirmed the three cleaned CSVs unchanged and output/work script copies identical; read back revised exceptions.csv and summary edits via the checker's string assertions.\n\n**Remaining limitations:** unchanged — net revenue provisional pending RF05 amount; RF04/order N9999 needs source-system follow-up; no cost data so contribution ≠ profit.\n\n**Estimated human finish time:** ~15–20 minutes to confirm RF05/RF04 externally and sign off (estimate, not measured).",
      "elapsed_min": 3.323828263200024,
      "finished": "2026-11-16T05:11:42.594553+00:00"
    }
  }
}
