Reviewed the submission against the supplied policy and all three raw CSVs. **No numerical or CSV correction was needed.** ### Revised deliverables - [cleaned-sales.csv](output/cleaned-sales.csv) - [cleaned-refunds.csv](output/cleaned-refunds.csv) - [cleaned-ads.csv](output/cleaned-ads.csv) - [exceptions.csv](output/exceptions.csv) - [summary.md](output/summary.md) ### Change log and checks - Clarified why unmatched refund R05 remains excluded despite the policy’s general statement that refunds relate to October orders. - Added [review-change-log.md](output/review-change-log.md), [executed check results](output/review-checks.md), and a [re-runnable validator](output/validate.py). - Preserved all five original deliverables in `output/original-submission/`, with a SHA-256 manifest. Independent validation passed: source-field normalization, all 29 source rows, duplicate/latest-update handling, 13 exclusions, all 21 summary results, refund linkage, known refund caps, and archive integrity. The four CSVs remain byte-identical to the originals. **Remaining limitations:** R06’s amount is missing and R05 has no matching order (`inputs/refunds.csv`, R05–R06). Net revenue and contribution remain provisional. Estimated human completion effort: **15–30 minutes after missing records become available**, excluding retrieval time.