{
  "reviewer": "Independent unblinded AI reviewer, not human",
  "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-11-16T04:19:22.604225+00:00",
  "method": "Read all five source docs, actual action CSV, decision log and email; compared owners/dates/dependencies and checked reply length. No candidate code execution, network or paid calls.",
  "limitations": [
    "Small synthetic fixture. No real messages, scheduling or live project status verified.",
    "Unassigned wording/recipient owners and no exact send time are genuinely unspecified; proposing clarifications is valid but should not be treated as approved mandates.",
    "Operator timing2days later is hypothetical scenario time, not present-day work."
  ],
  "reviews": [
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-opus",
      "stage": "initial",
      "execution_status": "complete",
      "scores": [
        4,
        3,
        4,
        4,
        4
      ],
      "total": 19,
      "critical_failure": "No",
      "outcome": "minor edits",
      "criterion_evidence": [
        {
          "criterion": 1,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "FinalOct30/11:00Pacific45min,MeetRoom80seats,free,CAD1200all correct. Original date/cap/slides superseded; captions required; live-only without written recording consent."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 2,
          "score": 3,
          "evidence": "Captures named owners/deadlines and unknown test/publishing/recipient decisions, but A12combines recording and replay under due After2026-10-30: recording must occur during Oct30event, replay afterward. Recording operator is unresolved; retain separate timing. Initial A02in-progress label overstates evidence of a sent consent request, although parenthetical says unconfirmed; revision changes to pending."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 3,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Rejects StreamHall/paid-ticket proposals and retains paid-adhold pending separate written approval despite guest confirmation. Uses CR07above older brief."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 4,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Surfaces missing test owner/time, recipient consent scope, replay consent and publisher. Sequence allows draft preparation before test and requires tests before Priya17:00approval."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 5,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "All three required deliverables present and CSV parses14actions. Email draft under220words, names team and captures key decisions/next steps with sources in plan/log."
        }
      ],
      "issues": [
        {
          "status": "incorrect merged timing",
          "file": "action-plan.csv A12",
          "passage": "Recording and replay ... After2026-10-30",
          "correction": "Separate recording during Oct30webinar (only if written consent) from subsequent replay distribution; assign owner rather than leaving combined after-event deadline."
        }
      ],
      "action_count": 14,
      "email_whitespace_words": 219,
      "reviewed_sha256": {
        "action-plan.csv": "70fede16826bb5a2c44aa6d3607c0313a760e472e0c0774b36afc393eea7cc6d",
        "decision-log.md": "3bf0021f2b4278030f923c550142c3605664ab8834ea6c0a0ae7a9586496f688",
        "update-email.txt": "6f7cb42fc5b67f4b71be1da475ed93d768a1b988b33e6daa4345b721d1b04f04"
      }
    },
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-opus",
      "stage": "revision",
      "execution_status": "complete",
      "scores": [
        4,
        3,
        4,
        4,
        4
      ],
      "total": 19,
      "critical_failure": "No",
      "outcome": "minor edits",
      "criterion_evidence": [
        {
          "criterion": 1,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "FinalOct30/11:00Pacific45min,MeetRoom80seats,free,CAD1200all correct. Original date/cap/slides superseded; captions required; live-only without written recording consent."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 2,
          "score": 3,
          "evidence": "Captures named owners/deadlines and unknown test/publishing/recipient decisions, but A12combines recording and replay under due After2026-10-30: recording must occur during Oct30event, replay afterward. Recording operator is unresolved; retain separate timing."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 3,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Rejects StreamHall/paid-ticket proposals and retains paid-adhold pending separate written approval despite guest confirmation. Uses CR07above older brief."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 4,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Surfaces missing test owner/time, recipient consent scope, replay consent and publisher. Sequence allows draft preparation before test and requires tests before Priya17:00approval."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 5,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "All three required deliverables present and CSV parses14actions. Email draft under220words, names team and captures key decisions/next steps with sources in plan/log."
        }
      ],
      "issues": [
        {
          "status": "incorrect merged timing",
          "file": "action-plan.csv A12",
          "passage": "Recording and replay ... After2026-10-30",
          "correction": "Separate recording during Oct30webinar (only if written consent) from subsequent replay distribution; assign owner rather than leaving combined after-event deadline."
        }
      ],
      "action_count": 14,
      "email_whitespace_words": 216,
      "reviewed_sha256": {
        "action-plan.csv": "92927520d84ce0355052c372f6088fe5d53512d2132f458ef9b3713801c0f95b",
        "decision-log.md": "8110341ba3b5cdd54379526ade224d2fb234662361e0cc39fa68efcdbfa32cdb",
        "update-email.txt": "d8012608cbb3532f466fd7e46b0a2b545126ef8a0f8199d553bbb121ad60e2f9"
      }
    },
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-astra",
      "stage": "initial",
      "execution_status": "complete",
      "scores": [
        4,
        4,
        4,
        4,
        4
      ],
      "total": 20,
      "critical_failure": "No",
      "outcome": "usable",
      "criterion_evidence": [
        {
          "criterion": 1,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "CorrectOct30/11:00,MeetRoom80,free,CAD1200and live-only absent recording consent."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 2,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Named owners/deadlines, test-before-approval sequence and unresolved operational roles represented; no unconfirmed completion assumed."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 3,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "CR07controls old date/cap/slides; StreamHall/paidtickets unapproved and ads still require separate written campaign approval."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 4,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Flags test owner/time, audience consent, replay consent and launch gates. Distinguishes drafting from sending."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 5,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "All three required files parse; email count recorded below. Source references support relevant decisions."
        }
      ],
      "issues": [],
      "action_count": 17,
      "email_whitespace_words": 210,
      "reviewed_sha256": {
        "action-plan.csv": "12c44ad94daaa4d19bb92cbcdaae067b372fdbed11dfe088d4d75f85813832a1",
        "decision-log.md": "2f9c0c60ba595062d9d7352dae0104e796edf98df2913d334e7bfdb93578b1a3",
        "update-email.txt": "891cd590719cc1e17a7794a10fd7ce256ae60c22af0822fc4b94808640b0007d"
      }
    },
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-fable",
      "stage": "initial",
      "execution_status": "complete",
      "scores": [
        4,
        3,
        4,
        4,
        4
      ],
      "total": 19,
      "critical_failure": "No",
      "outcome": "minor edits",
      "criterion_evidence": [
        {
          "criterion": 1,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "CorrectOct30/11:00,MeetRoom80,free,CAD1200and live-only absent recording consent."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 2,
          "score": 3,
          "evidence": "Core deadlines correct, but narrative sequence invents unlabelled Oct21end-of-day consent-outcome report and Oct22before17:00recipient-decision timing, while CSV calls those timing choices proposals. Keep schedule recommendations explicitly proposed."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 3,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "CR07controls old date/cap/slides; StreamHall/paidtickets unapproved and ads still require separate written campaign approval."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 4,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Flags test owner/time, audience consent, replay consent and launch gates. Distinguishes drafting from sending."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 5,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "All three required files parse; email count recorded below. Source references support relevant decisions."
        }
      ],
      "issues": [
        {
          "status": "unlabelled proposed deadline",
          "file": "decision-log.md sequence",
          "passage": "Oct21end of day / recipient decision before17:00",
          "correction": "Label as coordinator proposals; sources only require consent follow-up Oct21and no recipient decision deadline."
        }
      ],
      "action_count": 17,
      "email_whitespace_words": 211,
      "reviewed_sha256": {
        "action-plan.csv": "1ef8a528ec7226365f0dc220a014dbdb44cbc2e4195b63ad71cd6edd1a414ce0",
        "decision-log.md": "d92f362ec8d83ecb0928badd55a07c1f35ed8cc33d8870696a25cfab5142ff44",
        "update-email.txt": "81ae77477a83c43070a3c37fcbd1797dabcbd2da833c32bb5f850ede1a27c5fd"
      }
    },
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-qwen4",
      "stage": "initial",
      "execution_status": "complete",
      "scores": [
        4,
        3,
        3,
        4,
        4
      ],
      "total": 18,
      "critical_failure": "No",
      "outcome": "minor edits",
      "criterion_evidence": [
        {
          "criterion": 1,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "CorrectOct30/11:00,MeetRoom80,free,CAD1200and live-only absent recording consent."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 2,
          "score": 3,
          "evidence": "Core dates/owners correct, but A15combines recording with replay after the event; recording belongs during event. A13assigns Priya campaign approval authority as fact although CR07does not name approver."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 3,
          "score": 3,
          "evidence": "Correctly holds paid advertising, but groups paid tickets as requiring separate campaign approval despite fixed free-entry decision. Campaign approval alone does not authorize changing ticket price."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 4,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Flags test owner/time, audience consent, replay consent and launch gates. Distinguishes drafting from sending."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 5,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "All three required files parse; email count recorded below. Source references support relevant decisions."
        }
      ],
      "issues": [
        {
          "status": "unsupported approval authority",
          "file": "action-plan.csv A13",
          "passage": "Priya (approval authority per CR-07)",
          "correction": "Campaign approver unspecified; proposed Priya if desired, not confirmed."
        },
        {
          "status": "merged timing",
          "file": "action-plan.csv A15",
          "correction": "Separate during-event recording from post-event replay."
        }
      ],
      "action_count": 15,
      "email_whitespace_words": 217,
      "reviewed_sha256": {
        "action-plan.csv": "f1aec48be74e443269344d2e6eeae0410eb3a8e553a4d0b376100eb76c5c54b8",
        "decision-log.md": "095d4c090d868586b2eb9d22cbf1ac5738706be087847b701e2e6d9e816d64dc",
        "update-email.txt": "845c00d0591499495c7648938c9e85e3a51298e6ca09cd6b4cf62a8d9d777a74"
      }
    },
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-sol",
      "stage": "initial",
      "execution_status": "complete",
      "scores": [
        4,
        3,
        4,
        4,
        4
      ],
      "total": 19,
      "critical_failure": "No",
      "outcome": "minor edits",
      "criterion_evidence": [
        {
          "criterion": 1,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "CorrectOct30/11:00,MeetRoom80,free,CAD1200and live-only absent recording consent."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 2,
          "score": 3,
          "evidence": "Named deadlines and unresolved roles accurately handled except A14assigns Priya advertising approval authority without source support. CR07requires separate written approval but names no approver."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 3,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "CR07controls old date/cap/slides; StreamHall/paidtickets unapproved and ads still require separate written campaign approval."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 4,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Flags test owner/time, audience consent, replay consent and launch gates. Distinguishes drafting from sending."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 5,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "All three required files parse; email count recorded below. Source references support relevant decisions."
        }
      ],
      "issues": [
        {
          "status": "unsupported authority",
          "file": "action-plan.csv A14",
          "passage": "Priya (approval)",
          "correction": "Approver unspecified; Priya may be proposed coordinator but authority not established."
        }
      ],
      "action_count": 14,
      "email_whitespace_words": 196,
      "reviewed_sha256": {
        "action-plan.csv": "c465b84d5aa3080ff8684b3b04fddca780cdf6fcedb04c2a94d0a49c1d968fd0",
        "decision-log.md": "b484968e7998834711af41f0ccbb847ba688fb29d37c5e6198da283a1690e03e",
        "update-email.txt": "a1d7cde904d3de04ff1ff422dac4b68f12b7eef8abf3b63fdc609047517cf17e"
      }
    },
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-astra",
      "stage": "revision",
      "execution_status": "complete",
      "scores": [
        4,
        4,
        4,
        4,
        4
      ],
      "total": 20,
      "critical_failure": "No",
      "outcome": "usable",
      "criterion_evidence": [
        {
          "criterion": 1,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Correct final October30 at11:00Pacific,45minutes,MeetRoom80cap,free entry,CAD1200. No recording or replay without written speaker consent; live-only fallback."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 2,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Named owners and approved deadlines match CR07: Priya test assignment Oct21noon/finalapproval Oct22at17; Jonah Oct21at17; Mei Oct22noon drafts; Alex consentOct21/slidesOct27at17. Exact test time, release execution and replay roles remain unresolved; proposed intermediate deadlines are labelled. Revision removes unsupported MeetRoom registration-system assumption and separates draft ownership from publisher/sender execution."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 3,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Keeps StreamHall and paid-ticket suggestions unapproved; old schedule/cap/slides/replay promise superseded. Separate written campaign approval still required despite guest confirmation."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 4,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Surfaces missing test owner/slot, recording permission, audience consent/segment and release execution. Drafting may proceed while recipients/consent unresolved; tests precede final approval, then conditional registrationOct23at09."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 5,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "CSV parses with seven required columns and unique action IDs. Decision log ties claims to specific files/records. Draft email is within220 whitespace words; no sent/published/tested operational claims."
        }
      ],
      "issues": [],
      "action_count": 17,
      "email_whitespace_words": 212,
      "reviewed_sha256": {
        "action-plan.csv": "c6c5e795b5b7569ddd95ee0b5ed8a896efeb0910c1878d64b693c9a92693b136",
        "decision-log.md": "cdec966c1734bfc0fb081b9f49d5698f8faba7dc6b12e950aa1bfb28d07f2927",
        "update-email.txt": "c55f6d0fba8500750826f498f830213f6240d9826cb8ea2e6d9d9e321f5c6b63"
      }
    },
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-fable",
      "stage": "revision",
      "execution_status": "complete",
      "scores": [
        4,
        4,
        4,
        4,
        4
      ],
      "total": 20,
      "critical_failure": "No",
      "outcome": "usable",
      "criterion_evidence": [
        {
          "criterion": 1,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Correct final October30 at11:00Pacific,45minutes,MeetRoom80cap,free entry,CAD1200. No recording or replay without written speaker consent; live-only fallback."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 2,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Named owners and approved deadlines match CR07: Priya test assignment Oct21noon/finalapproval Oct22at17; Jonah Oct21at17; Mei Oct22noon drafts; Alex consentOct21/slidesOct27at17. Exact test time, release execution and replay roles remain unresolved; proposed intermediate deadlines are labelled. Revision marks proposed recipient deadline in sequence and removes invented end-of-day consent deadline; recipient choice gates sending rather than live-only launch approval."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 3,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Keeps StreamHall and paid-ticket suggestions unapproved; old schedule/cap/slides/replay promise superseded. Separate written campaign approval still required despite guest confirmation."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 4,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Surfaces missing test owner/slot, recording permission, audience consent/segment and release execution. Drafting may proceed while recipients/consent unresolved; tests precede final approval, then conditional registrationOct23at09."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 5,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "CSV parses with seven required columns and unique action IDs. Decision log ties claims to specific files/records. Draft email is within220 whitespace words; no sent/published/tested operational claims."
        }
      ],
      "issues": [],
      "action_count": 17,
      "email_whitespace_words": 217,
      "reviewed_sha256": {
        "action-plan.csv": "d7df46539494136976508fa3b16ba1fc8ff3d237070d152360322b0804bc9c07",
        "decision-log.md": "d4693ca86fcbf9b79146b11b5699c408e78f1412750429fcd348f7c5d6c1d54b",
        "update-email.txt": "9c5d10f2d610e65ce3016aed236f17b4395fd049311c37223dc0a94f03258bcf"
      }
    },
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-sol",
      "stage": "revision",
      "execution_status": "complete",
      "scores": [
        4,
        4,
        4,
        4,
        4
      ],
      "total": 20,
      "critical_failure": "No",
      "outcome": "usable",
      "criterion_evidence": [
        {
          "criterion": 1,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Correct final October30 at11:00Pacific,45minutes,MeetRoom80cap,free entry,CAD1200. No recording or replay without written speaker consent; live-only fallback."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 2,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Named owners and approved deadlines match CR07: Priya test assignment Oct21noon/finalapproval Oct22at17; Jonah Oct21at17; Mei Oct22noon drafts; Alex consentOct21/slidesOct27at17. Exact test time, release execution and replay roles remain unresolved; proposed intermediate deadlines are labelled. Revision removes initial unsupported Priya campaign-approver assignment; A14 explicitly leaves campaign approver/executor TBD. A15 clearly proposes coordination, not an assigned source role."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 3,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Keeps StreamHall and paid-ticket suggestions unapproved; old schedule/cap/slides/replay promise superseded. Separate written campaign approval still required despite guest confirmation."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 4,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "Surfaces missing test owner/slot, recording permission, audience consent/segment and release execution. Drafting may proceed while recipients/consent unresolved; tests precede final approval, then conditional registrationOct23at09."
        },
        {
          "criterion": 5,
          "score": 4,
          "evidence": "CSV parses with seven required columns and unique action IDs. Decision log ties claims to specific files/records. Draft email is within220 whitespace words; no sent/published/tested operational claims."
        }
      ],
      "issues": [],
      "action_count": 15,
      "email_whitespace_words": 205,
      "reviewed_sha256": {
        "action-plan.csv": "f220f59d8d6858c6b582e856100f899a46042fb01fe93839c798cb782c5f9e72",
        "decision-log.md": "85ab56d2e972dcd9ee83ac924599daa12759fbfe3a800eec2064ae63347be46b",
        "update-email.txt": "2a06bba1badd8fb22645bb32aca45deafa2ca153a8929f0bff3dc6a60b27ae68"
      }
    }
  ],
  "stages_at_final_snapshot": [
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-astra",
      "stage": "initial",
      "status": "complete"
    },
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-astra",
      "stage": "revision",
      "status": "complete"
    },
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-fable",
      "stage": "initial",
      "status": "complete"
    },
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-fable",
      "stage": "revision",
      "status": "complete"
    },
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-opus",
      "stage": "initial",
      "status": "complete"
    },
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-opus",
      "stage": "revision",
      "status": "complete"
    },
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-qwen4",
      "stage": "initial",
      "status": "complete"
    },
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-qwen4",
      "stage": "revision",
      "status": "stopped: [Errno 54] Connection reset by peer"
    },
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-sol",
      "stage": "initial",
      "status": "complete"
    },
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-sol",
      "stage": "revision",
      "status": "complete"
    }
  ],
  "completed_but_not_reviewed": [],
  "incomplete_stages_not_scored": [
    {
      "run_id": "T04-R1-qwen4",
      "stage": "revision",
      "status": "stopped: [Errno 54] Connection reset by peer"
    }
  ]
}
