{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-09-21T05:04:57.994003+00:00",
  "historical_generation_date": "2026-08-26",
  "review_date_pacific": "2026-09-20",
  "scope": "Two unresolved retained outputs only",
  "sources": {
    "protocol": "https://kingy.ai/wp-content/uploads/kingy-proof-lab-01-20260919/proof-lab-01-protocol-v1.md",
    "original_geometry": "https://kingy.ai/wp-content/uploads/kingy-proof-lab-01-20260919/proof-lab-01-geometry-20260919.json",
    "original_reassessment": "https://kingy.ai/wp-content/uploads/kingy-proof-lab-01-20260919/proof-lab-01-retrospective-20260919.md",
    "recipe_pack": "https://kingy.ai/wp-content/plugins/kingy-workbench/assets/video-exact-text-recipe.zip"
  },
  "source_file_sha256": {
    "protocol": "e096eef2f6e9e82169aaa664bb9570670582b02b45914e15cd3fac5aee0f5b0f",
    "original_geometry": "8d8e67781587c2fed3a661b3793942e8687a141763d0d5c85fd92b2930881a29",
    "original_reassessment": "1a529da12c665ed053b0784bbf71625fec03fe253e01ca878d8d5b16335de1d5"
  },
  "reviews": [
    {
      "attempt_id": "video-exact-text-veo31lite-2",
      "sha256": "f54caf525e9e9d0e0d779ba3988daa527c2e4aeb30c42d592a50801be8bd4308",
      "verdict": "fail",
      "review_type": "AI-assisted retrospective negative finding, not independent human acceptance",
      "rubric": "PL-01-v1 (prepared 2026-09-19 after 2026-08-26 generations)",
      "historical_usable_label": true,
      "historical_label_changed": false,
      "criterion_results": {
        "file_usable": "pass: full local decode and native 1280x720 duration within tolerance",
        "exact_text": "not certified; no every-frame human text review",
        "card_retained": "not certified",
        "requested_movement": "fail: supplemental same-border endpoint range below 1.10",
        "temporal_integrity": "not certified"
      },
      "decisive_evidence": {
        "frame": 95,
        "time_seconds": 3.9583333333333335,
        "initial_width_px": 1040,
        "final_width_px_range": [
          1099,
          1114
        ],
        "ratio_range": [
          1.0567307692307693,
          1.0711538461538461
        ],
        "valid_endpoint_pairs": 24,
        "null_endpoint_pairs": 12,
        "illustrative_edge_error_stress_bound": 1.0907335907335907,
        "stress_bound_description": "Expand final width by 8px per edge and shrink initial by 2px per edge. This is illustrative sensitivity, not a confidence interval."
      }
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "video-exact-text-kling30standard-2",
      "sha256": "93e519efe1197916759b52e354767e28d5da83571a37069ad1d5e69dd5ca940a",
      "verdict": "fail",
      "review_type": "AI-assisted retrospective negative finding, not independent human acceptance",
      "rubric": "PL-01-v1 (prepared 2026-09-19 after 2026-08-26 generations)",
      "historical_usable_label": true,
      "historical_label_changed": false,
      "criterion_results": {
        "file_usable": "pass: full local decode and native 1280x720 duration within tolerance",
        "exact_text": "not certified; no every-frame human text review",
        "card_retained": "fail: original plus fiducials partially disappear",
        "requested_movement": "endpoint component provisionally within band; full movement acceptance not certified",
        "temporal_integrity": "fail: transient fiducial geometry damage at frame 8 and frame 32"
      },
      "decisive_evidence": {
        "frames": [
          8,
          32
        ],
        "time_seconds": [
          0.3333333333333333,
          1.3333333333333333
        ],
        "finding": "Upper-left plus loses its right arm at frame 8; lower-right plus loses most of its horizontal arm at frame 32. Both are inside the uncropped card. First and final frames retain full crosses.",
        "protocol_text": "Preserve all corner fiducials; no geometry tear violating preservation.",
        "not_claimed": "No text spelling failure is claimed; no full every-frame acceptance is claimed."
      }
    }
  ],
  "cumulative_retrospective_ai_review": {
    "previous_established_failures": 4,
    "previous_unresolved": 2,
    "new_documented_failures": 2,
    "now_documented_failures": 6,
    "remaining_unresolved_within_this_two_output_review": 0,
    "certified_strict_passes": 0,
    "independent_human_validation": false,
    "every_frame_text_acceptance": false
  },
  "boundaries": {
    "new_generations": 0,
    "new_provider_spend_usd": 0,
    "historical_six_attempt_provider_charge_usd": 1.81332,
    "human_repair_time": "unknown",
    "cost_per_strict_accepted_job": "undefined; no certified accepted result",
    "prospective_protocol": "unrun",
    "public_PL01": "September 19 report preserved; this dated addendum supplies subsequent review",
    "newsletter_send_or_schedule": "unchanged",
    "experiment_configuration": "unchanged"
  }
}