# Review change log — Task 2 (review pass, 15-minute window)

## Change made
- `output/recommendation.md`: added one assumption line — "S1's named GX GPUs with dedicated VRAM treated as discrete." The hard requirement says *discrete* GPU; S1 (`inputs/S1-manufacturer-specs.csv`) lists GPU model + dedicated VRAM but never uses the word "discrete," so the inference is now explicit. Word count 638 → 649 (limit 650). No other text changed (verified by diff).
- `output/comparison.csv`: unchanged (byte-identical to original submission; verified).

## Checks performed in this review (all passed)
1. Independent arithmetic with `decimal.Decimal` (not the float code that generated the CSV): all six landed totals and 12% tax amounts match; price + shipping + tax = landed for every row. O1 2,238.88 / O2 2,098.88 / O3 1,790.88 / O4 1,902.88 / O5 2,126.88 / O6 2,037.28; O2 headroom 101.12; O1 overage 38.88.
2. CSV parse-back: valid CSV, header + all 6 offers; every spec field matches S1 for the joined SKU; delivery fields match S2 except O6 (2026-10-27, guaranteed, per S3).
3. Re-derived qualification logic independently: only O2 passes; failure reasons per offer match the CSV (O1 budget; O3 RAM+SSD; O4 VRAM; O5 unconfirmed delivery; O6 late).
4. Source-conflict handling re-checked against `inputs/00-source-register.md` authority rules: S1 over S2 titles (O3, O4), S3 supersedes O6 delivery, estimates ≠ commitments (O5). Noted oddity: S3 is timestamped 08:45 vs register capture 09:00, but the register explicitly designates S3 as the superseding authority for O6, so no ambiguity remains; no change needed.
5. recommendation.md: all six landed totals present and matching; all five input filenames cited; S4 facts (12-minute UHD H.264, 8 min 40 s, plugged in, single run, untested items) quoted accurately; no benchmark claims for untested SKUs; fallback phrased as a proposed action, not a performed one.
6. Original submission preserved unmodified at `output/original_submission/` before editing; diff confirms the single added line.
7. `inputs/` untouched (all five files present; no write ever targeted inputs/).

## Verdict
Recommendation unchanged: O2 (Forge Studio 16, F16-32, Harbour Tech), landed CAD 2,098.88, guaranteed 2026-10-22. One documentation correction (discrete-GPU assumption); no calculation, conflict-resolution or coverage errors found.
