{ "review_id": "review-b", "review_date": "2026-10-19", "review_type": "Independent anonymized AI visual review of retained sampled stills", "reviewer_model_identity": "unavailable", "reviewer_model_identity_note": "The current agent is presented as Codex, but no exact runtime model identifier is exposed to this review. No specific model/version identity is inferred.", "human_acceptance": null, "packet_path": "[assessment]/private/reviewer-packet.json", "source_truth": "One upright matte dark forest-green KINGY FIELD BOTTLE, 500 mL, ochre dot above KINGY, flat black cap, rounded shoulders, silver base band. Preserve every letter, color, proportion and the entire bottle. Cream background and stable contact shadow. No additional objects, people, claims, watermarks or invented text.", "source_asset_reviewed": "[workspace]/outputs/kingy-ai-launch-sprint-20260927/agent-cohort-v1/public/fixtures/kingy-field-bottle.jpg", "source_observation": "One complete upright forest-green bottle on cream. Flat black cap, rounded shoulders, silver base band, ochre dot above exact KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL. Soft contact shadow extends right.", "review_order": [ "A09", "A08", "A07", "A06", "A05", "A04", "A03", "A02", "A01" ], "review_order_method": "Reverse of reviewer-packet.json entry order", "inspection_method": { "image_tool": "view_image with detail=original", "source_images": 1, "contact_sheets": 9, "sampled_stills_per_final": 15, "total_sampled_stills_seen_in_contact_sheets": 135, "additional_full_frame_views": 28, "sample_times_seconds": [ 0.0, 1.0, 2.0, 3.0, 4.0, 4.958333333333333, 5.0, 6.0, 7.0, 8.0, 9.0, 9.958333333333334, 10.0, 12.0, 14.958333333333334 ], "content_0_10_sample_count_per_alias": 12, "original_static_endcard_10_15_sample_count_per_alias": 3 }, "criterion_interpretation": { "product_framing": "Full cap, body and base are inside every examined frame. Copy overlap is graded separately.", "product_identity_geometry": "Source-compatible single bottle, shape, proportions, cap and base; color/material uncertainty recorded when lighting prevents confident source-appearance comparison.", "product_label": "Exact KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE, 500 mL plus the ochre dot; hidden, blurred or unresolvable text/color is uncertain, not automatically incorrect.", "added_copy": "Exact expected hook/detail/CTA in their sampled segments, legible and free of obstructive overlap or invented extra claims.", "sampled_consistency": "Consistency of the product and required grounded/stable contact-shadow appearance across examined stills. A planned segment cut or modest change in scale is not alone a product-morphing failure; strong visible lighting/shadow excursions are recorded. No continuous-motion guarantee." }, "entries": [ { "alias": "A09", "brief_id": "retarget", "expected_copy": { "hook_0_5": "Still thinking it over?", "detail_5_10": "Meet your next bottle", "cta_10_15": "Take another look" }, "contact_sheet_reviewed": "frames/A09/contact-sheet.jpg", "samples_reviewed_via_contact_sheet": [ { "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A09/sample-001.png" }, { "time_seconds": 1.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 24, "path": "frames/A09/sample-002.png" }, { "time_seconds": 2.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 48, "path": "frames/A09/sample-003.png" }, { "time_seconds": 3.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 72, "path": "frames/A09/sample-004.png" }, { "time_seconds": 4.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 96, "path": "frames/A09/sample-005.png" }, { "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A09/sample-006.png" }, { "time_seconds": 5.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 120, "path": "frames/A09/sample-007.png" }, { "time_seconds": 6.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 144, "path": "frames/A09/sample-008.png" }, { "time_seconds": 7.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 168, "path": "frames/A09/sample-009.png" }, { "time_seconds": 8.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 192, "path": "frames/A09/sample-010.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 216, "path": "frames/A09/sample-011.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A09/sample-012.png" }, { "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A09/sample-013.png" }, { "time_seconds": 12.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 288, "path": "frames/A09/sample-014.png" }, { "time_seconds": 14.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 359, "path": "frames/A09/sample-015.png" } ], "additional_full_frames_inspected": [ { "time_seconds": 0.0, "path": "frames/A09/sample-001.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "path": "frames/A09/sample-012.png" }, { "time_seconds": 10.0, "path": "frames/A09/sample-013.png" } ], "criteria": { "product_framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A09/sample-001.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The full cap, shoulders, body and base have visible surrounding background." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A09/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The complete bottle remains in frame at 9.958s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A09/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 10.000s, the original-image endcard visibly shows the complete source-matching bottle on cream, with the expected CTA above it." } ], "reason": "All 12 examined 0-10s contact-sheet samples retain the cap, complete body and complete silver base within the image. No sampled product edge is cropped. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "All 12 examined 0-10s contact-sheet samples retain the cap, complete body and complete silver base within the image. No sampled product edge is cropped." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "All three endcard samples (10.000, 12.000 and 14.958s) retain the entire bottle." } }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A09/sample-001.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "One bottle with source-compatible cap, shoulders and base; no additional objects." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A09/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The same one-bottle structure remains visible at the last content sample." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A09/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 10.000s, the original-image endcard visibly shows the complete source-matching bottle on cream, with the expected CTA above it." } ], "reason": "The sampled content retains one upright green cylindrical bottle, rounded shoulders, a flat black cap and silver base band in source-compatible proportions. No second product, people or extra physical objects are visible. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The sampled content retains one upright green cylindrical bottle, rounded shoulders, a flat black cap and silver base band in source-compatible proportions. No second product, people or extra physical objects are visible." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The endcard has the source shape, colors, cap and base, with one product and no added physical objects." } }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A09/sample-001.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL and the ochre dot are readable." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A09/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The exact three label lines and ochre dot remain readable." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A09/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The source label is clearly readable on the original-image endcard." } ], "reason": "The inspected full frames visibly read KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL, with an ochre dot above KINGY. The remaining sampled thumbnails show no apparent contradictory lettering; this is a sampled visual judgment, not OCR or an all-frame lettering certification. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The inspected full frames visibly read KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL, with an ochre dot above KINGY. The remaining sampled thumbnails show no apparent contradictory lettering; this is a sampled visual judgment, not OCR or an all-frame lettering certification." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "At 10.000s full resolution, KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL and the ochre dot match the source; the 12.000 and 14.958s thumbnails show the same label." } }, "added_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A09/sample-001.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected hook is readable: Still thinking it over?" }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 5.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 120, "path": "frames/A09/sample-007.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "At the 5.000s boundary the overlay changes to the expected detail: Meet your next bottle" }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A09/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected detail remains readable: Meet your next bottle" }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A09/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected CTA is readable: Take another look" } ], "reason": "The examined samples show the expected hook in 0-5s and the expected detail in 5-10s, with correct spelling, no extra claims and no sampled overlap that prevents reading. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The examined samples show the expected hook in 0-5s and the expected detail in 5-10s, with correct spelling, no extra claims and no sampled overlap that prevents reading." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The 10.000, 12.000 and 14.958s samples show the exact expected CTA without overlap." } }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A09/sample-001.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Bottle retains cap/body/base, front label and ground contact." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A09/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The same visible product features and ground contact remain at 9.958s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A09/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The source-image composition starts at 10.000s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 14.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 359, "path": "frames/A09/sample-015.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "The source-image composition and CTA remain visually stable at 14.958s." } ], "reason": "The 0-10s sampled bottle composition is visually near-static, retaining its label, cap, base and soft rightward shadow. The endcard is separately stable; sampled stability does not establish motion quality or continuous fidelity.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The 12 content thumbnails are visually near-static and retain the same complete bottle, label and soft rightward contact shadow." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The three endcard thumbnails show a visually stable source-image composition with its CTA." } } }, "notes": [ "The content samples appear near-static. These stills cannot establish whether the requested camera movement or light change occurs between samples." ] }, { "alias": "A08", "brief_id": "launch", "expected_copy": { "hook_0_5": "Meet the Field Bottle", "detail_5_10": "KINGY \u2022 500 mL", "cta_10_15": "Explore the collection" }, "contact_sheet_reviewed": "frames/A08/contact-sheet.jpg", "samples_reviewed_via_contact_sheet": [ { "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A08/sample-001.png" }, { "time_seconds": 1.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 24, "path": "frames/A08/sample-002.png" }, { "time_seconds": 2.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 48, "path": "frames/A08/sample-003.png" }, { "time_seconds": 3.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 72, "path": "frames/A08/sample-004.png" }, { "time_seconds": 4.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 96, "path": "frames/A08/sample-005.png" }, { "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A08/sample-006.png" }, { "time_seconds": 5.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 120, "path": "frames/A08/sample-007.png" }, { "time_seconds": 6.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 144, "path": "frames/A08/sample-008.png" }, { "time_seconds": 7.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 168, "path": "frames/A08/sample-009.png" }, { "time_seconds": 8.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 192, "path": "frames/A08/sample-010.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 216, "path": "frames/A08/sample-011.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A08/sample-012.png" }, { "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A08/sample-013.png" }, { "time_seconds": 12.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 288, "path": "frames/A08/sample-014.png" }, { "time_seconds": 14.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 359, "path": "frames/A08/sample-015.png" } ], "additional_full_frames_inspected": [ { "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "path": "frames/A08/sample-006.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "path": "frames/A08/sample-012.png" }, { "time_seconds": 10.0, "path": "frames/A08/sample-013.png" } ], "criteria": { "product_framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A08/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The full cap, shoulders, body and base have visible surrounding background." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A08/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The complete bottle remains in frame at 9.958s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A08/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 10.000s, the original-image endcard visibly shows the complete source-matching bottle on cream, with the expected CTA above it." } ], "reason": "All 12 examined 0-10s contact-sheet samples retain the cap, complete body and complete silver base within the image. No sampled product edge is cropped. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "All 12 examined 0-10s contact-sheet samples retain the cap, complete body and complete silver base within the image. No sampled product edge is cropped." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "All three endcard samples (10.000, 12.000 and 14.958s) retain the entire bottle." } }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A08/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "One bottle with source-compatible cap, shoulders and base; no additional objects." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A08/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The same one-bottle structure remains visible at the last content sample." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A08/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 10.000s, the original-image endcard visibly shows the complete source-matching bottle on cream, with the expected CTA above it." } ], "reason": "The sampled content retains one upright green cylindrical bottle, rounded shoulders, a flat black cap and silver base band in source-compatible proportions. No second product, people or extra physical objects are visible. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The sampled content retains one upright green cylindrical bottle, rounded shoulders, a flat black cap and silver base band in source-compatible proportions. No second product, people or extra physical objects are visible." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The endcard has the source shape, colors, cap and base, with one product and no added physical objects." } }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A08/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL and the ochre dot are readable." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A08/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The exact three label lines and ochre dot remain readable." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A08/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The source label is clearly readable on the original-image endcard." } ], "reason": "The inspected full frames visibly read KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL, with an ochre dot above KINGY. The remaining sampled thumbnails show no apparent contradictory lettering; this is a sampled visual judgment, not OCR or an all-frame lettering certification. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The inspected full frames visibly read KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL, with an ochre dot above KINGY. The remaining sampled thumbnails show no apparent contradictory lettering; this is a sampled visual judgment, not OCR or an all-frame lettering certification." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "At 10.000s full resolution, KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL and the ochre dot match the source; the 12.000 and 14.958s thumbnails show the same label." } }, "added_copy": { "verdict": "fail", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 96, "path": "frames/A08/sample-005.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "The cap reaches the hook line in the 4.000s thumbnail." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A08/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 4.958s, the black cap overlaps the middle of Meet the Field Bottle, making that portion of the hook hard to read." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A08/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 9.958s, KINGY \u2022 500 mL is readable just above the cap." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A08/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Explore the collection is fully readable above the source-image bottle." } ], "reason": "The expected hook is present, but at 4.000s and especially 4.958s the enlarged black cap intersects the dark hook text. The central words lose contrast against the cap. The detail remains readable in the examined 5-10s samples. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "fail", "reason": "The expected hook is present, but at 4.000s and especially 4.958s the enlarged black cap intersects the dark hook text. The central words lose contrast against the cap. The detail remains readable in the examined 5-10s samples." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The original endcard CTA Explore the collection is readable and clear of the bottle." } }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A08/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Bottle retains cap/body/base, front label and ground contact." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A08/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The same visible product features and ground contact remain at 9.958s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A08/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The source-image composition starts at 10.000s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 14.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 359, "path": "frames/A08/sample-015.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "The source-image composition and CTA remain visually stable at 14.958s." } ], "reason": "Across the examined 0-10s stills, one bottle stays intact and grounded, with no visible object duplication or clear product morphing. Scale and lighting differences are limited to the recorded samples; continuous motion smoothness was not inspected. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "Across the examined 0-10s stills, one bottle stays intact and grounded, with no visible object duplication or clear product morphing. Scale and lighting differences are limited to the recorded samples; continuous motion smoothness was not inspected." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The three endcard thumbnails show a visually stable source-image composition with its CTA." } } }, "notes": [ "A size/position reset is visible between the 4.958s hook sample and the 5.000s detail sample. It is recorded as a segment change, not by itself classified as product morphing; full-speed transition quality was not examined.", "Although the hook collides with the cap, the bottle itself remains fully inside the sampled frame. The framing pass is not a copy-layout pass." ] }, { "alias": "A07", "brief_id": "launch", "expected_copy": { "hook_0_5": "Meet the Field Bottle", "detail_5_10": "KINGY \u2022 500 mL", "cta_10_15": "Explore the collection" }, "contact_sheet_reviewed": "frames/A07/contact-sheet.jpg", "samples_reviewed_via_contact_sheet": [ { "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A07/sample-001.png" }, { "time_seconds": 1.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 24, "path": "frames/A07/sample-002.png" }, { "time_seconds": 2.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 48, "path": "frames/A07/sample-003.png" }, { "time_seconds": 3.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 72, "path": "frames/A07/sample-004.png" }, { "time_seconds": 4.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 96, "path": "frames/A07/sample-005.png" }, { "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A07/sample-006.png" }, { "time_seconds": 5.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 120, "path": "frames/A07/sample-007.png" }, { "time_seconds": 6.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 144, "path": "frames/A07/sample-008.png" }, { "time_seconds": 7.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 168, "path": "frames/A07/sample-009.png" }, { "time_seconds": 8.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 192, "path": "frames/A07/sample-010.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 216, "path": "frames/A07/sample-011.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A07/sample-012.png" }, { "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A07/sample-013.png" }, { "time_seconds": 12.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 288, "path": "frames/A07/sample-014.png" }, { "time_seconds": 14.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 359, "path": "frames/A07/sample-015.png" } ], "additional_full_frames_inspected": [ { "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "path": "frames/A07/sample-006.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "path": "frames/A07/sample-012.png" }, { "time_seconds": 10.0, "path": "frames/A07/sample-013.png" } ], "criteria": { "product_framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A07/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The full cap, shoulders, body and base have visible surrounding background." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A07/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The complete bottle remains in frame at 9.958s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A07/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 10.000s, the original-image endcard visibly shows the complete source-matching bottle on cream, with the expected CTA above it." } ], "reason": "All 12 examined 0-10s contact-sheet samples retain the cap, complete body and complete silver base within the image. No sampled product edge is cropped. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "All 12 examined 0-10s contact-sheet samples retain the cap, complete body and complete silver base within the image. No sampled product edge is cropped." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "All three endcard samples (10.000, 12.000 and 14.958s) retain the entire bottle." } }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A07/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "One bottle with source-compatible cap, shoulders and base; no additional objects." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A07/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The same one-bottle structure remains visible at the last content sample." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A07/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 10.000s, the original-image endcard visibly shows the complete source-matching bottle on cream, with the expected CTA above it." } ], "reason": "The sampled content retains one upright green cylindrical bottle, rounded shoulders, a flat black cap and silver base band in source-compatible proportions. No second product, people or extra physical objects are visible. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The sampled content retains one upright green cylindrical bottle, rounded shoulders, a flat black cap and silver base band in source-compatible proportions. No second product, people or extra physical objects are visible." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The endcard has the source shape, colors, cap and base, with one product and no added physical objects." } }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A07/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL and the ochre dot are readable." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A07/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The exact three label lines and ochre dot remain readable." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A07/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The source label is clearly readable on the original-image endcard." } ], "reason": "The inspected full frames visibly read KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL, with an ochre dot above KINGY. The remaining sampled thumbnails show no apparent contradictory lettering; this is a sampled visual judgment, not OCR or an all-frame lettering certification. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The inspected full frames visibly read KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL, with an ochre dot above KINGY. The remaining sampled thumbnails show no apparent contradictory lettering; this is a sampled visual judgment, not OCR or an all-frame lettering certification." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "At 10.000s full resolution, KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL and the ochre dot match the source; the 12.000 and 14.958s thumbnails show the same label." } }, "added_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A07/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected hook is readable: Meet the Field Bottle" }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 5.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 120, "path": "frames/A07/sample-007.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "At the 5.000s boundary the overlay changes to the expected detail: KINGY \u2022 500 mL" }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A07/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected detail remains readable: KINGY \u2022 500 mL" }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A07/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected CTA is readable: Explore the collection" } ], "reason": "The examined samples show the expected hook in 0-5s and the expected detail in 5-10s, with correct spelling, no extra claims and no sampled overlap that prevents reading. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The examined samples show the expected hook in 0-5s and the expected detail in 5-10s, with correct spelling, no extra claims and no sampled overlap that prevents reading." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The 10.000, 12.000 and 14.958s samples show the exact expected CTA without overlap." } }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A07/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Bottle retains cap/body/base, front label and ground contact." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A07/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The same visible product features and ground contact remain at 9.958s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A07/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The source-image composition starts at 10.000s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 14.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 359, "path": "frames/A07/sample-015.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "The source-image composition and CTA remain visually stable at 14.958s." } ], "reason": "Across the examined 0-10s stills, one bottle stays intact and grounded, with no visible object duplication or clear product morphing. Scale and lighting differences are limited to the recorded samples; continuous motion smoothness was not inspected. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "Across the examined 0-10s stills, one bottle stays intact and grounded, with no visible object duplication or clear product morphing. Scale and lighting differences are limited to the recorded samples; continuous motion smoothness was not inspected." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The three endcard thumbnails show a visually stable source-image composition with its CTA." } } }, "notes": [ "A size/position reset is visible between the 4.958s hook sample and the 5.000s detail sample. It is recorded as a segment change, not by itself classified as product morphing; full-speed transition quality was not examined.", "The enlarged 4.958s and 9.958s frames keep the overlay above the cap with visible separation; the label remains readable in both full frames." ] }, { "alias": "A06", "brief_id": "detail", "expected_copy": { "hook_0_5": "A closer look", "detail_5_10": "Field Bottle \u2022 500 mL", "cta_10_15": "See the details" }, "contact_sheet_reviewed": "frames/A06/contact-sheet.jpg", "samples_reviewed_via_contact_sheet": [ { "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A06/sample-001.png" }, { "time_seconds": 1.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 24, "path": "frames/A06/sample-002.png" }, { "time_seconds": 2.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 48, "path": "frames/A06/sample-003.png" }, { "time_seconds": 3.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 72, "path": "frames/A06/sample-004.png" }, { "time_seconds": 4.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 96, "path": "frames/A06/sample-005.png" }, { "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A06/sample-006.png" }, { "time_seconds": 5.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 120, "path": "frames/A06/sample-007.png" }, { "time_seconds": 6.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 144, "path": "frames/A06/sample-008.png" }, { "time_seconds": 7.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 168, "path": "frames/A06/sample-009.png" }, { "time_seconds": 8.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 192, "path": "frames/A06/sample-010.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 216, "path": "frames/A06/sample-011.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A06/sample-012.png" }, { "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A06/sample-013.png" }, { "time_seconds": 12.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 288, "path": "frames/A06/sample-014.png" }, { "time_seconds": 14.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 359, "path": "frames/A06/sample-015.png" } ], "additional_full_frames_inspected": [ { "time_seconds": 0.0, "path": "frames/A06/sample-001.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "path": "frames/A06/sample-012.png" }, { "time_seconds": 10.0, "path": "frames/A06/sample-013.png" } ], "criteria": { "product_framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A06/sample-001.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The full cap, shoulders, body and base have visible surrounding background." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A06/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The complete bottle remains in frame at 9.958s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A06/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 10.000s, the original-image endcard visibly shows the complete source-matching bottle on cream, with the expected CTA above it." } ], "reason": "All 12 examined 0-10s contact-sheet samples retain the cap, complete body and complete silver base within the image. No sampled product edge is cropped. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "All 12 examined 0-10s contact-sheet samples retain the cap, complete body and complete silver base within the image. No sampled product edge is cropped." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "All three endcard samples (10.000, 12.000 and 14.958s) retain the entire bottle." } }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A06/sample-001.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "One bottle with source-compatible cap, shoulders and base; no additional objects." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A06/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The same one-bottle structure remains visible at the last content sample." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A06/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 10.000s, the original-image endcard visibly shows the complete source-matching bottle on cream, with the expected CTA above it." } ], "reason": "The sampled content retains one upright green cylindrical bottle, rounded shoulders, a flat black cap and silver base band in source-compatible proportions. No second product, people or extra physical objects are visible. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The sampled content retains one upright green cylindrical bottle, rounded shoulders, a flat black cap and silver base band in source-compatible proportions. No second product, people or extra physical objects are visible." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The endcard has the source shape, colors, cap and base, with one product and no added physical objects." } }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A06/sample-001.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL and the ochre dot are readable." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A06/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The exact three label lines and ochre dot remain readable." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A06/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The source label is clearly readable on the original-image endcard." } ], "reason": "The inspected full frames visibly read KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL, with an ochre dot above KINGY. The remaining sampled thumbnails show no apparent contradictory lettering; this is a sampled visual judgment, not OCR or an all-frame lettering certification. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The inspected full frames visibly read KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL, with an ochre dot above KINGY. The remaining sampled thumbnails show no apparent contradictory lettering; this is a sampled visual judgment, not OCR or an all-frame lettering certification." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "At 10.000s full resolution, KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL and the ochre dot match the source; the 12.000 and 14.958s thumbnails show the same label." } }, "added_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A06/sample-001.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected hook is readable: A closer look" }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 5.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 120, "path": "frames/A06/sample-007.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "At the 5.000s boundary the overlay changes to the expected detail: Field Bottle \u2022 500 mL" }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A06/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected detail remains readable: Field Bottle \u2022 500 mL" }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A06/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected CTA is readable: See the details" } ], "reason": "The examined samples show the expected hook in 0-5s and the expected detail in 5-10s, with correct spelling, no extra claims and no sampled overlap that prevents reading. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The examined samples show the expected hook in 0-5s and the expected detail in 5-10s, with correct spelling, no extra claims and no sampled overlap that prevents reading." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The 10.000, 12.000 and 14.958s samples show the exact expected CTA without overlap." } }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A06/sample-001.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Bottle retains cap/body/base, front label and ground contact." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A06/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The same visible product features and ground contact remain at 9.958s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A06/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The source-image composition starts at 10.000s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 14.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 359, "path": "frames/A06/sample-015.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "The source-image composition and CTA remain visually stable at 14.958s." } ], "reason": "The 0-10s sampled bottle composition is visually near-static, retaining its label, cap, base and soft rightward shadow. The endcard is separately stable; sampled stability does not establish motion quality or continuous fidelity.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The 12 content thumbnails are visually near-static and retain the same complete bottle, label and soft rightward contact shadow." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The three endcard thumbnails show a visually stable source-image composition with its CTA." } } }, "notes": [ "The content samples appear near-static. These stills cannot establish whether the requested camera movement or light change occurs between samples." ] }, { "alias": "A05", "brief_id": "launch", "expected_copy": { "hook_0_5": "Meet the Field Bottle", "detail_5_10": "KINGY \u2022 500 mL", "cta_10_15": "Explore the collection" }, "contact_sheet_reviewed": "frames/A05/contact-sheet.jpg", "samples_reviewed_via_contact_sheet": [ { "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A05/sample-001.png" }, { "time_seconds": 1.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 24, "path": "frames/A05/sample-002.png" }, { "time_seconds": 2.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 48, "path": "frames/A05/sample-003.png" }, { "time_seconds": 3.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 72, "path": "frames/A05/sample-004.png" }, { "time_seconds": 4.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 96, "path": "frames/A05/sample-005.png" }, { "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A05/sample-006.png" }, { "time_seconds": 5.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 120, "path": "frames/A05/sample-007.png" }, { "time_seconds": 6.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 144, "path": "frames/A05/sample-008.png" }, { "time_seconds": 7.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 168, "path": "frames/A05/sample-009.png" }, { "time_seconds": 8.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 192, "path": "frames/A05/sample-010.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 216, "path": "frames/A05/sample-011.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A05/sample-012.png" }, { "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A05/sample-013.png" }, { "time_seconds": 12.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 288, "path": "frames/A05/sample-014.png" }, { "time_seconds": 14.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 359, "path": "frames/A05/sample-015.png" } ], "additional_full_frames_inspected": [ { "time_seconds": 0.0, "path": "frames/A05/sample-001.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "path": "frames/A05/sample-012.png" }, { "time_seconds": 10.0, "path": "frames/A05/sample-013.png" } ], "criteria": { "product_framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A05/sample-001.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The full cap, shoulders, body and base have visible surrounding background." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A05/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The complete bottle remains in frame at 9.958s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A05/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 10.000s, the original-image endcard visibly shows the complete source-matching bottle on cream, with the expected CTA above it." } ], "reason": "All 12 examined 0-10s contact-sheet samples retain the cap, complete body and complete silver base within the image. No sampled product edge is cropped. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "All 12 examined 0-10s contact-sheet samples retain the cap, complete body and complete silver base within the image. No sampled product edge is cropped." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "All three endcard samples (10.000, 12.000 and 14.958s) retain the entire bottle." } }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A05/sample-001.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "One bottle with source-compatible cap, shoulders and base; no additional objects." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A05/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The same one-bottle structure remains visible at the last content sample." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A05/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 10.000s, the original-image endcard visibly shows the complete source-matching bottle on cream, with the expected CTA above it." } ], "reason": "The sampled content retains one upright green cylindrical bottle, rounded shoulders, a flat black cap and silver base band in source-compatible proportions. No second product, people or extra physical objects are visible. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The sampled content retains one upright green cylindrical bottle, rounded shoulders, a flat black cap and silver base band in source-compatible proportions. No second product, people or extra physical objects are visible." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The endcard has the source shape, colors, cap and base, with one product and no added physical objects." } }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A05/sample-001.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL and the ochre dot are readable." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A05/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The exact three label lines and ochre dot remain readable." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A05/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The source label is clearly readable on the original-image endcard." } ], "reason": "The inspected full frames visibly read KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL, with an ochre dot above KINGY. The remaining sampled thumbnails show no apparent contradictory lettering; this is a sampled visual judgment, not OCR or an all-frame lettering certification. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The inspected full frames visibly read KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL, with an ochre dot above KINGY. The remaining sampled thumbnails show no apparent contradictory lettering; this is a sampled visual judgment, not OCR or an all-frame lettering certification." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "At 10.000s full resolution, KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL and the ochre dot match the source; the 12.000 and 14.958s thumbnails show the same label." } }, "added_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A05/sample-001.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected hook is readable: Meet the Field Bottle" }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 5.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 120, "path": "frames/A05/sample-007.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "At the 5.000s boundary the overlay changes to the expected detail: KINGY \u2022 500 mL" }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A05/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected detail remains readable: KINGY \u2022 500 mL" }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A05/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected CTA is readable: Explore the collection" } ], "reason": "The examined samples show the expected hook in 0-5s and the expected detail in 5-10s, with correct spelling, no extra claims and no sampled overlap that prevents reading. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The examined samples show the expected hook in 0-5s and the expected detail in 5-10s, with correct spelling, no extra claims and no sampled overlap that prevents reading." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The 10.000, 12.000 and 14.958s samples show the exact expected CTA without overlap." } }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A05/sample-001.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Bottle retains cap/body/base, front label and ground contact." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A05/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The same visible product features and ground contact remain at 9.958s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A05/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The source-image composition starts at 10.000s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 14.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 359, "path": "frames/A05/sample-015.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "The source-image composition and CTA remain visually stable at 14.958s." } ], "reason": "The 0-10s sampled bottle composition is visually near-static, retaining its label, cap, base and soft rightward shadow. The endcard is separately stable; sampled stability does not establish motion quality or continuous fidelity.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The 12 content thumbnails are visually near-static and retain the same complete bottle, label and soft rightward contact shadow." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The three endcard thumbnails show a visually stable source-image composition with its CTA." } } }, "notes": [ "The content samples appear near-static. These stills cannot establish whether the requested camera movement or light change occurs between samples." ] }, { "alias": "A04", "brief_id": "retarget", "expected_copy": { "hook_0_5": "Still thinking it over?", "detail_5_10": "Meet your next bottle", "cta_10_15": "Take another look" }, "contact_sheet_reviewed": "frames/A04/contact-sheet.jpg", "samples_reviewed_via_contact_sheet": [ { "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A04/sample-001.png" }, { "time_seconds": 1.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 24, "path": "frames/A04/sample-002.png" }, { "time_seconds": 2.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 48, "path": "frames/A04/sample-003.png" }, { "time_seconds": 3.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 72, "path": "frames/A04/sample-004.png" }, { "time_seconds": 4.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 96, "path": "frames/A04/sample-005.png" }, { "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A04/sample-006.png" }, { "time_seconds": 5.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 120, "path": "frames/A04/sample-007.png" }, { "time_seconds": 6.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 144, "path": "frames/A04/sample-008.png" }, { "time_seconds": 7.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 168, "path": "frames/A04/sample-009.png" }, { "time_seconds": 8.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 192, "path": "frames/A04/sample-010.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 216, "path": "frames/A04/sample-011.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A04/sample-012.png" }, { "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A04/sample-013.png" }, { "time_seconds": 12.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 288, "path": "frames/A04/sample-014.png" }, { "time_seconds": 14.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 359, "path": "frames/A04/sample-015.png" } ], "additional_full_frames_inspected": [ { "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "path": "frames/A04/sample-006.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "path": "frames/A04/sample-012.png" }, { "time_seconds": 10.0, "path": "frames/A04/sample-013.png" } ], "criteria": { "product_framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A04/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The full cap, shoulders, body and base have visible surrounding background." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A04/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The complete bottle remains in frame at 9.958s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A04/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 10.000s, the original-image endcard visibly shows the complete source-matching bottle on cream, with the expected CTA above it." } ], "reason": "All 12 examined 0-10s contact-sheet samples retain the cap, complete body and complete silver base within the image. No sampled product edge is cropped. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "All 12 examined 0-10s contact-sheet samples retain the cap, complete body and complete silver base within the image. No sampled product edge is cropped." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "All three endcard samples (10.000, 12.000 and 14.958s) retain the entire bottle." } }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A04/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "One bottle with source-compatible cap, shoulders and base; no additional objects." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A04/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The same one-bottle structure remains visible at the last content sample." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A04/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 10.000s, the original-image endcard visibly shows the complete source-matching bottle on cream, with the expected CTA above it." } ], "reason": "The sampled content retains one upright green cylindrical bottle, rounded shoulders, a flat black cap and silver base band in source-compatible proportions. No second product, people or extra physical objects are visible. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The sampled content retains one upright green cylindrical bottle, rounded shoulders, a flat black cap and silver base band in source-compatible proportions. No second product, people or extra physical objects are visible." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The endcard has the source shape, colors, cap and base, with one product and no added physical objects." } }, "product_label": { "verdict": "uncertain", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 2.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 48, "path": "frames/A04/sample-003.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "At 2.000s, the label is already shifted toward the right contour in the thumbnail." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A04/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 4.958s, only KING\u2026 and FIELD BOTT\u2026 are fully exposed; the rest wraps out of view. 500 mL is visible." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A04/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 9.958s, all three exact label lines and the ochre dot are readable." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A04/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL and the ochre dot match the source." } ], "reason": "The first segment rotates the label toward the right-hand contour. At 4.958s, the right end of KINGY and FIELD BOTTLE is hidden around the bottle edge, so exact full lettering cannot be verified. The 9.958s full frame reads KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL and shows the dot. No misspelling is inferred from the hidden letters. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "uncertain", "reason": "The first segment rotates the label toward the right-hand contour. At 4.958s, the right end of KINGY and FIELD BOTTLE is hidden around the bottle edge, so exact full lettering cannot be verified. The 9.958s full frame reads KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL and shows the dot. No misspelling is inferred from the hidden letters." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "All exact source label lines and ochre dot are visible on the original-image endcard." } }, "added_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A04/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected hook is readable: Still thinking it over?" }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 5.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 120, "path": "frames/A04/sample-007.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "At the 5.000s boundary the overlay changes to the expected detail: Meet your next bottle" }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A04/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected detail remains readable: Meet your next bottle" }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A04/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected CTA is readable: Take another look" } ], "reason": "The examined samples show the expected hook in 0-5s and the expected detail in 5-10s, with correct spelling, no extra claims and no sampled overlap that prevents reading. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The examined samples show the expected hook in 0-5s and the expected detail in 5-10s, with correct spelling, no extra claims and no sampled overlap that prevents reading." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The 10.000, 12.000 and 14.958s samples show the exact expected CTA without overlap." } }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "fail", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A04/sample-001.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "At 0.000s, the bottle has a soft rightward shadow and neutral black/green appearance." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 8.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 192, "path": "frames/A04/sample-010.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "At 8.000s, the thumbnail shows a pronounced warm rim and a much sharper diagonal ground shadow." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A04/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 9.958s, a bright gold vertical rim runs down the cap/body and the rightward ground shadow has a hard diagonal edge." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A04/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 10.000s, the original source image restores the soft shadow and source coloring." } ], "reason": "The required stable contact-shadow appearance is not maintained in the examined content: the soft source-style rightward shadow changes to a long, hard-edged diagonal shadow by 8-9.958s, accompanied by a strong gold rim on the cap and body. This is a visible lighting/shadow consistency issue, not a claim of a product-letter mutation. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "fail", "reason": "The required stable contact-shadow appearance is not maintained in the examined content: the soft source-style rightward shadow changes to a long, hard-edged diagonal shadow by 8-9.958s, accompanied by a strong gold rim on the cap and body. This is a visible lighting/shadow consistency issue, not a claim of a product-letter mutation." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The separate original-image endcard returns to the stable soft source shadow and neutral source appearance." } } }, "notes": [ "The source-compatible round bottle geometry survives the rotation, but its full front label is not continuously exposed in the reviewed first-segment samples.", "Bright highlights are described as apparent lighting/color changes. No intrinsic material substitution is inferred. The sampled-consistency failure concerns the visibly changed contact-shadow character; color/material fidelity uncertainty remains uncertain where scored." ] }, { "alias": "A03", "brief_id": "detail", "expected_copy": { "hook_0_5": "A closer look", "detail_5_10": "Field Bottle \u2022 500 mL", "cta_10_15": "See the details" }, "contact_sheet_reviewed": "frames/A03/contact-sheet.jpg", "samples_reviewed_via_contact_sheet": [ { "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A03/sample-001.png" }, { "time_seconds": 1.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 24, "path": "frames/A03/sample-002.png" }, { "time_seconds": 2.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 48, "path": "frames/A03/sample-003.png" }, { "time_seconds": 3.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 72, "path": "frames/A03/sample-004.png" }, { "time_seconds": 4.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 96, "path": "frames/A03/sample-005.png" }, { "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A03/sample-006.png" }, { "time_seconds": 5.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 120, "path": "frames/A03/sample-007.png" }, { "time_seconds": 6.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 144, "path": "frames/A03/sample-008.png" }, { "time_seconds": 7.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 168, "path": "frames/A03/sample-009.png" }, { "time_seconds": 8.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 192, "path": "frames/A03/sample-010.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 216, "path": "frames/A03/sample-011.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A03/sample-012.png" }, { "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A03/sample-013.png" }, { "time_seconds": 12.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 288, "path": "frames/A03/sample-014.png" }, { "time_seconds": 14.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 359, "path": "frames/A03/sample-015.png" } ], "additional_full_frames_inspected": [ { "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "path": "frames/A03/sample-006.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "path": "frames/A03/sample-012.png" }, { "time_seconds": 10.0, "path": "frames/A03/sample-013.png" } ], "criteria": { "product_framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A03/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The full cap, shoulders, body and base have visible surrounding background." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A03/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The complete bottle remains in frame at 9.958s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A03/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 10.000s, the original-image endcard visibly shows the complete source-matching bottle on cream, with the expected CTA above it." } ], "reason": "All 12 examined 0-10s contact-sheet samples retain the cap, complete body and complete silver base within the image. No sampled product edge is cropped. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "All 12 examined 0-10s contact-sheet samples retain the cap, complete body and complete silver base within the image. No sampled product edge is cropped." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "All three endcard samples (10.000, 12.000 and 14.958s) retain the entire bottle." } }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A03/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "One bottle with source-compatible cap, shoulders and base; no additional objects." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A03/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The same one-bottle structure remains visible at the last content sample." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A03/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 10.000s, the original-image endcard visibly shows the complete source-matching bottle on cream, with the expected CTA above it." } ], "reason": "The sampled content retains one upright green cylindrical bottle, rounded shoulders, a flat black cap and silver base band in source-compatible proportions. No second product, people or extra physical objects are visible. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The sampled content retains one upright green cylindrical bottle, rounded shoulders, a flat black cap and silver base band in source-compatible proportions. No second product, people or extra physical objects are visible." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The endcard has the source shape, colors, cap and base, with one product and no added physical objects." } }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A03/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL and the ochre dot are readable." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A03/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The exact three label lines and ochre dot remain readable." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A03/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The source label is clearly readable on the original-image endcard." } ], "reason": "The inspected full frames visibly read KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL, with an ochre dot above KINGY. The remaining sampled thumbnails show no apparent contradictory lettering; this is a sampled visual judgment, not OCR or an all-frame lettering certification. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The inspected full frames visibly read KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL, with an ochre dot above KINGY. The remaining sampled thumbnails show no apparent contradictory lettering; this is a sampled visual judgment, not OCR or an all-frame lettering certification." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "At 10.000s full resolution, KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL and the ochre dot match the source; the 12.000 and 14.958s thumbnails show the same label." } }, "added_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A03/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected hook is readable: A closer look" }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 5.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 120, "path": "frames/A03/sample-007.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "At the 5.000s boundary the overlay changes to the expected detail: Field Bottle \u2022 500 mL" }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A03/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected detail remains readable: Field Bottle \u2022 500 mL" }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A03/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected CTA is readable: See the details" } ], "reason": "The examined samples show the expected hook in 0-5s and the expected detail in 5-10s, with correct spelling, no extra claims and no sampled overlap that prevents reading. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The examined samples show the expected hook in 0-5s and the expected detail in 5-10s, with correct spelling, no extra claims and no sampled overlap that prevents reading." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The 10.000, 12.000 and 14.958s samples show the exact expected CTA without overlap." } }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A03/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Bottle retains cap/body/base, front label and ground contact." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A03/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The same visible product features and ground contact remain at 9.958s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A03/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The source-image composition starts at 10.000s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 14.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 359, "path": "frames/A03/sample-015.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "The source-image composition and CTA remain visually stable at 14.958s." } ], "reason": "Across the examined 0-10s stills, one bottle stays intact and grounded, with no visible object duplication or clear product morphing. Scale and lighting differences are limited to the recorded samples; continuous motion smoothness was not inspected. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "Across the examined 0-10s stills, one bottle stays intact and grounded, with no visible object duplication or clear product morphing. Scale and lighting differences are limited to the recorded samples; continuous motion smoothness was not inspected." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The three endcard thumbnails show a visually stable source-image composition with its CTA." } } }, "notes": [ "A size/position reset is visible between the 4.958s hook sample and the 5.000s detail sample. It is recorded as a segment change, not by itself classified as product morphing; full-speed transition quality was not examined.", "Bright diagonal bands traverse the cream background in the 2-4.958s thumbnails and recur during 5-10s. They are lighting effects rather than additional physical objects. The bottle shape, text and soft ground contact remain visibly intact in the inspected full frames." ] }, { "alias": "A02", "brief_id": "detail", "expected_copy": { "hook_0_5": "A closer look", "detail_5_10": "Field Bottle \u2022 500 mL", "cta_10_15": "See the details" }, "contact_sheet_reviewed": "frames/A02/contact-sheet.jpg", "samples_reviewed_via_contact_sheet": [ { "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A02/sample-001.png" }, { "time_seconds": 1.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 24, "path": "frames/A02/sample-002.png" }, { "time_seconds": 2.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 48, "path": "frames/A02/sample-003.png" }, { "time_seconds": 3.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 72, "path": "frames/A02/sample-004.png" }, { "time_seconds": 4.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 96, "path": "frames/A02/sample-005.png" }, { "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A02/sample-006.png" }, { "time_seconds": 5.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 120, "path": "frames/A02/sample-007.png" }, { "time_seconds": 6.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 144, "path": "frames/A02/sample-008.png" }, { "time_seconds": 7.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 168, "path": "frames/A02/sample-009.png" }, { "time_seconds": 8.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 192, "path": "frames/A02/sample-010.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 216, "path": "frames/A02/sample-011.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A02/sample-012.png" }, { "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A02/sample-013.png" }, { "time_seconds": 12.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 288, "path": "frames/A02/sample-014.png" }, { "time_seconds": 14.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 359, "path": "frames/A02/sample-015.png" } ], "additional_full_frames_inspected": [ { "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "path": "frames/A02/sample-006.png" }, { "time_seconds": 7.0, "path": "frames/A02/sample-009.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "path": "frames/A02/sample-012.png" }, { "time_seconds": 10.0, "path": "frames/A02/sample-013.png" } ], "criteria": { "product_framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A02/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The full cap, shoulders, body and base have visible surrounding background." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A02/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The complete bottle remains in frame at 9.958s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A02/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 10.000s, the original-image endcard visibly shows the complete source-matching bottle on cream, with the expected CTA above it." } ], "reason": "All 12 examined 0-10s contact-sheet samples retain the cap, complete body and complete silver base within the image. No sampled product edge is cropped. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "All 12 examined 0-10s contact-sheet samples retain the cap, complete body and complete silver base within the image. No sampled product edge is cropped." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "All three endcard samples (10.000, 12.000 and 14.958s) retain the entire bottle." } }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "uncertain", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A02/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 4.958s, the dark green body and black cap have source-compatible geometry and appearance." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 7.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 168, "path": "frames/A02/sample-009.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 7.000s, a broad white highlight makes the cap look partly metallic and the body much brighter/glossier; the silhouette and one-product count are unchanged." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A02/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 9.958s, dark green/black appearance returns." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A02/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 10.000s, the original-image endcard visibly shows the complete source-matching bottle on cream, with the expected CTA above it." } ], "reason": "The bottle silhouette, cap shape, silver base and single-product count remain source-compatible, but the 7-8s lighting changes the perceived material/color substantially: the left cap looks silver-green and the green body has a broad near-white glossy strip. Exact preservation of the source matte dark-green/black appearance is uncertain from these samples. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "uncertain", "reason": "The bottle silhouette, cap shape, silver base and single-product count remain source-compatible, but the 7-8s lighting changes the perceived material/color substantially: the left cap looks silver-green and the green body has a broad near-white glossy strip. Exact preservation of the source matte dark-green/black appearance is uncertain from these samples." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The separate original-image endcard visibly matches source shape, color, cap and base." } }, "product_label": { "verdict": "uncertain", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A02/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 4.958s, all three label lines and ochre dot are readable." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 7.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 168, "path": "frames/A02/sample-009.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 7.000s, the three text lines can still be read, but the dot is pale yellow and a bright highlight crosses the left lettering." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A02/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 9.958s, the ochre dot and clear label appearance return." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A02/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The complete source label and ochre dot are readable." } ], "reason": "The text KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL is readable in the full frames, including 7.000s, with no demonstrated misspelling. However, the brand dot appears pale yellow at 7.000s instead of source ochre, and strong glare crosses the left label area. Exact label-color preservation across the content samples is uncertain rather than certified. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "uncertain", "reason": "The text KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL is readable in the full frames, including 7.000s, with no demonstrated misspelling. However, the brand dot appears pale yellow at 7.000s instead of source ochre, and strong glare crosses the left label area. Exact label-color preservation across the content samples is uncertain rather than certified." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The original endcard has all exact label lines and the source ochre dot." } }, "added_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A02/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected hook is readable: A closer look" }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 5.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 120, "path": "frames/A02/sample-007.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "At the 5.000s boundary the overlay changes to the expected detail: Field Bottle \u2022 500 mL" }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A02/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected detail remains readable: Field Bottle \u2022 500 mL" }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A02/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected CTA is readable: See the details" } ], "reason": "The examined samples show the expected hook in 0-5s and the expected detail in 5-10s, with correct spelling, no extra claims and no sampled overlap that prevents reading. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The examined samples show the expected hook in 0-5s and the expected detail in 5-10s, with correct spelling, no extra claims and no sampled overlap that prevents reading." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The 10.000, 12.000 and 14.958s samples show the exact expected CTA without overlap." } }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "fail", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 6.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 144, "path": "frames/A02/sample-008.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "At 6.000s, the thumbnail shows a dark matte body and a soft rightward shadow." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 7.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 168, "path": "frames/A02/sample-009.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 7.000s, a near-white vertical highlight covers much of the left bottle and the ground shadow becomes long and hard-edged." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A02/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "By 9.958s, the highlight has largely gone and source-like coloring returns." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A02/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The source lighting/shadow is restored in the 10.000s original-image endcard." } ], "reason": "The content does not maintain the requested gentle light/stable shadow appearance in the examined stills: the neutral 6.000s shot changes to a strong broad highlight and a hard-edged long ground shadow at 7-8s, then becomes neutral again by 9.958s. The sampled illumination excursion is clear; the intervening motion or flicker rate is unknown. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "fail", "reason": "The content does not maintain the requested gentle light/stable shadow appearance in the examined stills: the neutral 6.000s shot changes to a strong broad highlight and a hard-edged long ground shadow at 7-8s, then becomes neutral again by 9.958s. The sampled illumination excursion is clear; the intervening motion or flicker rate is unknown." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The original-image endcard is separately stable with the source lighting and soft shadow." } } }, "notes": [ "Bright highlights are described as apparent lighting/color changes. No intrinsic material substitution is inferred. The sampled-consistency failure concerns the visibly changed contact-shadow character; color/material fidelity uncertainty remains uncertain where scored." ] }, { "alias": "A01", "brief_id": "retarget", "expected_copy": { "hook_0_5": "Still thinking it over?", "detail_5_10": "Meet your next bottle", "cta_10_15": "Take another look" }, "contact_sheet_reviewed": "frames/A01/contact-sheet.jpg", "samples_reviewed_via_contact_sheet": [ { "time_seconds": 0.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 0, "path": "frames/A01/sample-001.png" }, { "time_seconds": 1.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 24, "path": "frames/A01/sample-002.png" }, { "time_seconds": 2.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 48, "path": "frames/A01/sample-003.png" }, { "time_seconds": 3.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 72, "path": "frames/A01/sample-004.png" }, { "time_seconds": 4.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 96, "path": "frames/A01/sample-005.png" }, { "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A01/sample-006.png" }, { "time_seconds": 5.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 120, "path": "frames/A01/sample-007.png" }, { "time_seconds": 6.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 144, "path": "frames/A01/sample-008.png" }, { "time_seconds": 7.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 168, "path": "frames/A01/sample-009.png" }, { "time_seconds": 8.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 192, "path": "frames/A01/sample-010.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 216, "path": "frames/A01/sample-011.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A01/sample-012.png" }, { "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A01/sample-013.png" }, { "time_seconds": 12.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 288, "path": "frames/A01/sample-014.png" }, { "time_seconds": 14.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 359, "path": "frames/A01/sample-015.png" } ], "additional_full_frames_inspected": [ { "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "path": "frames/A01/sample-006.png" }, { "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "path": "frames/A01/sample-012.png" }, { "time_seconds": 10.0, "path": "frames/A01/sample-013.png" } ], "criteria": { "product_framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A01/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The full cap, shoulders, body and base have visible surrounding background." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A01/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The complete bottle remains in frame at 9.958s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A01/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 10.000s, the original-image endcard visibly shows the complete source-matching bottle on cream, with the expected CTA above it." } ], "reason": "All 12 examined 0-10s contact-sheet samples retain the cap, complete body and complete silver base within the image. No sampled product edge is cropped. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "All 12 examined 0-10s contact-sheet samples retain the cap, complete body and complete silver base within the image. No sampled product edge is cropped." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "All three endcard samples (10.000, 12.000 and 14.958s) retain the entire bottle." } }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A01/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "One bottle with source-compatible cap, shoulders and base; no additional objects." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A01/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The same one-bottle structure remains visible at the last content sample." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A01/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "At 10.000s, the original-image endcard visibly shows the complete source-matching bottle on cream, with the expected CTA above it." } ], "reason": "The sampled content retains one upright green cylindrical bottle, rounded shoulders, a flat black cap and silver base band in source-compatible proportions. No second product, people or extra physical objects are visible. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The sampled content retains one upright green cylindrical bottle, rounded shoulders, a flat black cap and silver base band in source-compatible proportions. No second product, people or extra physical objects are visible." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The endcard has the source shape, colors, cap and base, with one product and no added physical objects." } }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A01/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL and the ochre dot are readable." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A01/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The exact three label lines and ochre dot remain readable." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A01/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The source label is clearly readable on the original-image endcard." } ], "reason": "The inspected full frames visibly read KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL, with an ochre dot above KINGY. The remaining sampled thumbnails show no apparent contradictory lettering; this is a sampled visual judgment, not OCR or an all-frame lettering certification. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The inspected full frames visibly read KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL, with an ochre dot above KINGY. The remaining sampled thumbnails show no apparent contradictory lettering; this is a sampled visual judgment, not OCR or an all-frame lettering certification." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "At 10.000s full resolution, KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL and the ochre dot match the source; the 12.000 and 14.958s thumbnails show the same label." } }, "added_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A01/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected hook is readable: Still thinking it over?" }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 5.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 120, "path": "frames/A01/sample-007.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "At the 5.000s boundary the overlay changes to the expected detail: Meet your next bottle" }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A01/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected detail remains readable: Meet your next bottle" }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A01/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Expected CTA is readable: Take another look" } ], "reason": "The examined samples show the expected hook in 0-5s and the expected detail in 5-10s, with correct spelling, no extra claims and no sampled overlap that prevents reading. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The examined samples show the expected hook in 0-5s and the expected detail in 5-10s, with correct spelling, no extra claims and no sampled overlap that prevents reading." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The 10.000, 12.000 and 14.958s samples show the exact expected CTA without overlap." } }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 4.958333333333333, "frame_index_zero_based": 119, "path": "frames/A01/sample-006.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "Bottle retains cap/body/base, front label and ground contact." }, { "segment": "content_0_10", "time_seconds": 9.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 239, "path": "frames/A01/sample-012.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The same visible product features and ground contact remain at 9.958s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 10.0, "frame_index_zero_based": 240, "path": "frames/A01/sample-013.png", "inspection": "full_frame", "observation": "The source-image composition starts at 10.000s." }, { "segment": "original_static_endcard_10_15", "time_seconds": 14.958333333333334, "frame_index_zero_based": 359, "path": "frames/A01/sample-015.png", "inspection": "contact_sheet", "observation": "The source-image composition and CTA remain visually stable at 14.958s." } ], "reason": "Across the examined 0-10s stills, one bottle stays intact and grounded, with no visible object duplication or clear product morphing. Scale and lighting differences are limited to the recorded samples; continuous motion smoothness was not inspected. The original-image endcard passes this criterion separately and does not resolve any earlier issue.", "content_0_10": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "Across the examined 0-10s stills, one bottle stays intact and grounded, with no visible object duplication or clear product morphing. Scale and lighting differences are limited to the recorded samples; continuous motion smoothness was not inspected." }, "original_static_endcard_10_15": { "verdict": "pass", "reason": "The three endcard thumbnails show a visually stable source-image composition with its CTA." } } }, "notes": [ "A size/position reset is visible between the 4.958s hook sample and the 5.000s detail sample. It is recorded as a segment change, not by itself classified as product morphing; full-speed transition quality was not examined." ] } ], "overall_limitations": [ "This is an AI visual assessment, not human acceptance.", "Only 15 extracted stills per final were reviewed through contact sheets; 28 of those frames were additionally inspected at full resolution. No full playback or all-frame inspection was performed.", "A pass applies only to the visible sampled evidence at the stated inspection resolution. Fine lettering in thumbnails is less reliable than in full frames.", "The original static 10-15s endcard is assessed separately. A clean endcard does not certify 0-10s generated content or the whole ad.", "No file-format, source-code, pipeline or provider check is used as visual-fidelity evidence.", "No performance, efficacy, motion smoothness, audio, delivery-platform rendering or unsampled-frame claim is made.", "The blind key, provider-named data and other reviews were not opened. No provider or universal model winner is identified.", "No source image, original output, packet or sampled frame was modified. Only review-b.json was written." ], "provenance": { "initial_review_task_exact": "Perform a fresh independent AI visual review of nine anonymized retained product-ad outputs. Workspace [workspace]. Read ONLY implementation/2026-10-19/kingy-original-testing/assessment-v1/private/reviewer-packet.json and the referenced source truth/image and alias contact sheets/frames. Never open blind-key.json, provider-named source data or another review. Inspect source image and all9sheets using view_image; inspect full frames where necessary. Review aliases in reverse order to packet to vary presentation. Five criteria: product_framing(fullcap/body/base), product_identity_geometry(source shape/cap/base and one-product/no additional objects), product_label(exact KINGY/FIELD BOTTLE/500 mL plus ochredot, uncertain if can't read), added_copy(expected hook0-5/detail5-10/CTA10-15 from packet), sampled_consistency(only examined frames, not full temporal guarantee). Evaluate0-10sec content separately from original static10-15endcard. Scores pass/fail/uncertain with directly visible timecoded evidence and clear reasons. Do not assume motion blur means incorrect lettering; uncertainty preferable if not readable. Passing fileformat, sourcecode or endcard does not certify whole ad. 15samples/final, no human acceptance, no universal model winner. Save assessment-v1/private/review-b.json with reviewed paths, order, actual reviewer model identity if known otherwise unavailable, criteria per alias {verdict,evidence,reason}, additional full frames inspected, overall limitations. You may write only review-b.json. No external APIs/generation/publishing/original mutations. Return concise outcome.", "followup_instruction_exact": "Please save exact initial review task/prompt as provenance or separate review-b-prompt.txt plus actual model/version if exposed else unavailable. Finish and return soon so I can reconcile/publish. Keep source color lighting ambiguity uncertain, not infer intrinsic material change solely from bright highlights.", "model_version": "unavailable", "independence_note": "Only the initial task, its follow-up, reviewer packet, source image and anonymized imagery were used; no other review or provider identity data was read." }, "public_export_note": "Private local paths replaced with portable labels; verdicts and prompt wording otherwise preserved. The human_acceptance field is normalized to null (not measured), not a failed human decision.", "private_original_record_sha256": "57f02d4e63911c85583406cd1a2b2322918055a0f904599aea034e0cd6b196a6" }