{ "review_id": "review-a", "reviewer_identity": { "agent": "visual_review_a", "assessment_type": "subscribed agent visual assessment", "human_review": false, "actual_model_id": "unavailable", "identity_limit": "The exact backend model identifier is not independently exposed to this reviewer; no specific model variant is claimed.", "external_paid_api_used": false }, "independence": { "blind_key_read": false, "other_reviews_read": false, "provider_names_or_cost_data_read": false, "original_provider_source_files_read": false, "generation_performed": false, "external_writes_or_publication": false, "only_created_file": "[assessment]/private/review-a.json" }, "source_truth": "One upright matte dark forest-green KINGY FIELD BOTTLE, 500 mL, ochre dot above KINGY, flat black cap, rounded shoulders, silver base band. Preserve every letter, color, proportion and the entire bottle. Cream background and stable contact shadow. No additional objects, people, claims, watermarks or invented text.", "criterion_definitions": { "framing": "Whether the entire cap, body, and base are inside each cited sampled frame.", "product_identity_geometry": "Visible shape, rounded shoulders, cap and base geometry, and one bottle without extra objects. Lighting changes alone are not asserted to be a geometry change.", "product_label": "Exact visible KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE, 500 mL wording and an ochre dot. Hidden or inadequately resolved detail is uncertain, not invented corruption.", "added_overlay_copy": "Visible overlay wording matches the applicable brief segment. Overlap that prevents confident letter-by-letter confirmation is uncertain; it is not evidence that a different string was generated.", "sampled_consistency": "Visible identity and label consistency among cited sampled stills. This does not certify smooth motion, unseen intermediate frames, or seamless edits. Intentional framing/light changes and 5-second segment cuts are recorded, not automatically treated as identity corruption." }, "scope": { "sampling": "15 retained still samples per alias; 135 samples viewed through nine contact sheets.", "generated_workflow_section": "0.0000s through 9.9583s: 12 samples per alias.", "static_end_card_section": "10.0000s, 12.0000s, 14.9583s: 3 samples per alias.", "extra_full_resolution_frames_viewed": 32, "verdict_scope": "Every verdict is limited to cited inspected samples and the visible detail available there. The static end card does not repair or prove the preceding section. Label passes are specifically supported at the listed full-resolution times, not a guarantee of every tiny character elsewhere." }, "reviewed_paths": { "packet": "[assessment]/private/reviewer-packet.json", "source_image": "[workspace]/outputs/kingy-ai-launch-sprint-20260927/agent-cohort-v1/public/fixtures/kingy-field-bottle.jpg", "contact_sheets": [ "frames/A01/contact-sheet.jpg", "frames/A02/contact-sheet.jpg", "frames/A03/contact-sheet.jpg", "frames/A04/contact-sheet.jpg", "frames/A05/contact-sheet.jpg", "frames/A06/contact-sheet.jpg", "frames/A07/contact-sheet.jpg", "frames/A08/contact-sheet.jpg", "frames/A09/contact-sheet.jpg" ], "additional_full_resolution_frames": [ "frames/A01/sample-006.png", "frames/A01/sample-007.png", "frames/A01/sample-012.png", "frames/A01/sample-013.png", "frames/A02/sample-006.png", "frames/A02/sample-009.png", "frames/A02/sample-010.png", "frames/A02/sample-013.png", "frames/A03/sample-006.png", "frames/A03/sample-012.png", "frames/A03/sample-013.png", "frames/A04/sample-006.png", "frames/A04/sample-007.png", "frames/A04/sample-009.png", "frames/A04/sample-013.png", "frames/A05/sample-006.png", "frames/A05/sample-012.png", "frames/A05/sample-013.png", "frames/A06/sample-006.png", "frames/A06/sample-012.png", "frames/A06/sample-013.png", "frames/A07/sample-006.png", "frames/A07/sample-012.png", "frames/A07/sample-013.png", "frames/A08/sample-005.png", "frames/A08/sample-006.png", "frames/A08/sample-007.png", "frames/A08/sample-012.png", "frames/A08/sample-013.png", "frames/A09/sample-006.png", "frames/A09/sample-012.png", "frames/A09/sample-013.png" ] }, "limitations": [ "This is an agent visual assessment, not human review, human acceptance, or a blinded human panel.", "No video playback, audio review, all-frame review, render verification, or motion smoothness assessment was performed.", "Contact sheets were viewed at their supplied original size. Selected PNG frames were additionally viewed at original resolution. The smallest label type in unexpanded contact-sheet cells cannot support a strict character-by-character guarantee.", "The source image and packet are the sole reference. No blind key, provider identity, other review, generation metadata, or costs were consulted.", "A pass means the cited visible evidence supports that criterion. It does not mean the whole film, every intermediate frame, every dimension of creative direction, or customer acceptance passed.", "Lighting can alter the apparent finish and label-dot color. Where those images cannot distinguish illumination from an actual color change, the report preserves uncertainty.", "No universal ranking, model/provider ranking, cost comparison, or effectiveness claim is made." ], "entries": [ { "alias": "A01", "brief_id": "retarget", "coverage": { "sample_count": 15, "contact_sheet_path": "frames/A01/contact-sheet.jpg", "sample_times": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s", "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "full_resolution_frames": [ { "timecode": "04.9583s", "path": "frames/A01/sample-006.png" }, { "timecode": "05.0000s", "path": "frames/A01/sample-007.png" }, { "timecode": "09.9583s", "path": "frames/A01/sample-012.png" }, { "timecode": "10.0000s", "path": "frames/A01/sample-013.png" } ] }, "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "All 12 generated/workflow samples show the full cap, body and base inside the frame with background remaining above and below the product. This verdict concerns crop only. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "In the 12 inspected contact-sheet samples for 0-10s, one upright bottle retains the recognizable cylindrical body, rounded shoulders, attached flat cap and silver base band. No extra product, person or prop is visible. This is a visible geometry assessment, not a pixel-exact match. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The expanded generated/workflow frames at 04.9583s, 05.0000s, 09.9583s show KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE, 500 mL and the ochre dot above the brand. No contradictory wording is visible elsewhere on the contact sheet; exact fine print outside these expanded times remains below the strict verification scope. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled 0-5s frames show \"Still thinking it over?\" and the sampled 5-10s frames show \"Meet your next bottle\". The visible wording and segment assignment match the packet; no extra claim or substituted overlay is visible. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled bottle remains front-facing, with the same cap, shoulders, silver band and label arrangement. Modest scale drift within each section is visible, and the scale resets at 5.0000s; these stills do not establish smoothness across that edit. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." } }, "sections": { "generated_workflow_0_10s": { "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "All 12 generated/workflow samples show the full cap, body and base inside the frame with background remaining above and below the product. This verdict concerns crop only." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "In the 12 inspected contact-sheet samples for 0-10s, one upright bottle retains the recognizable cylindrical body, rounded shoulders, attached flat cap and silver base band. No extra product, person or prop is visible. This is a visible geometry assessment, not a pixel-exact match." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The expanded generated/workflow frames at 04.9583s, 05.0000s, 09.9583s show KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE, 500 mL and the ochre dot above the brand. No contradictory wording is visible elsewhere on the contact sheet; exact fine print outside these expanded times remains below the strict verification scope." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled 0-5s frames show \"Still thinking it over?\" and the sampled 5-10s frames show \"Meet your next bottle\". The visible wording and segment assignment match the packet; no extra claim or substituted overlay is visible." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled bottle remains front-facing, with the same cap, shoulders, silver band and label arrangement. Modest scale drift within each section is visible, and the scale resets at 5.0000s; these stills do not establish smoothness across that edit." } } }, "static_end_card_10_15s": { "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three inspected end-card samples show the entire bottle cap, body and base." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three inspected end-card samples show one bottle with the reference silhouette, flat black cap, rounded shoulders and silver base band; no extra object is visible." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s" ], "reason": "The expanded 10.0000s end-card frame has the exact KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL wording and ochre dot. The 12.0000s and 14.9583s contact-sheet views show no visible change; this detailed pass is anchored to 10.0000s." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The end-card samples visibly show the requested CTA: \"Take another look\"." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three end-card samples appear visually consistent in product geometry, label arrangement, cream background and rightward contact shadow. This supports only the static end-card samples." } } } }, "observations": [ "A modest size change is visible across the 4.9583s to 5.0000s segment boundary. No identity substitution is apparent in the inspected stills." ] }, { "alias": "A02", "brief_id": "detail", "coverage": { "sample_count": 15, "contact_sheet_path": "frames/A02/contact-sheet.jpg", "sample_times": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s", "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "full_resolution_frames": [ { "timecode": "04.9583s", "path": "frames/A02/sample-006.png" }, { "timecode": "07.0000s", "path": "frames/A02/sample-009.png" }, { "timecode": "08.0000s", "path": "frames/A02/sample-010.png" }, { "timecode": "10.0000s", "path": "frames/A02/sample-013.png" } ] }, "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "All 12 generated/workflow samples show the full cap, body and base inside the frame with background remaining above and below the product. This verdict concerns crop only. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "In the 12 inspected contact-sheet samples for 0-10s, one upright bottle retains the recognizable cylindrical body, rounded shoulders, attached flat cap and silver base band. No extra product, person or prop is visible. This is a visible geometry assessment, not a pixel-exact match. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "uncertain", "evidence": [ "04.9583s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s" ], "reason": "KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL are readable in the expanded 4.9583s, 7.0000s and 8.0000s frames. The dot is ochre at 4.9583s but pale yellow under the strong highlight at 7.0000s and 8.0000s. The location/shape persists; exact ochre-color preservation is uncertain because illumination changes. No wrong word is asserted. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled 0-5s frames show \"A closer look\" and the sampled 5-10s frames show \"Field Bottle \u2022 500 mL\". The visible wording and segment assignment match the packet; no extra claim or substituted overlay is visible. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "uncertain", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "At 7.0000s and 8.0000s the left body/cap has a strong bright highlight and the dot appears pale yellow, compared with the dark finish and ochre dot at 4.9583s. The brief allows a change of light, so the stills do not establish whether the surface or paint changed. Geometry stays recognizable, but strict color/finish consistency is uncertain. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." } }, "sections": { "generated_workflow_0_10s": { "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "All 12 generated/workflow samples show the full cap, body and base inside the frame with background remaining above and below the product. This verdict concerns crop only." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "In the 12 inspected contact-sheet samples for 0-10s, one upright bottle retains the recognizable cylindrical body, rounded shoulders, attached flat cap and silver base band. No extra product, person or prop is visible. This is a visible geometry assessment, not a pixel-exact match." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "uncertain", "evidence": [ "04.9583s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s" ], "reason": "KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL are readable in the expanded 4.9583s, 7.0000s and 8.0000s frames. The dot is ochre at 4.9583s but pale yellow under the strong highlight at 7.0000s and 8.0000s. The location/shape persists; exact ochre-color preservation is uncertain because illumination changes. No wrong word is asserted." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled 0-5s frames show \"A closer look\" and the sampled 5-10s frames show \"Field Bottle \u2022 500 mL\". The visible wording and segment assignment match the packet; no extra claim or substituted overlay is visible." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "uncertain", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "At 7.0000s and 8.0000s the left body/cap has a strong bright highlight and the dot appears pale yellow, compared with the dark finish and ochre dot at 4.9583s. The brief allows a change of light, so the stills do not establish whether the surface or paint changed. Geometry stays recognizable, but strict color/finish consistency is uncertain." } } }, "static_end_card_10_15s": { "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three inspected end-card samples show the entire bottle cap, body and base." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three inspected end-card samples show one bottle with the reference silhouette, flat black cap, rounded shoulders and silver base band; no extra object is visible." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s" ], "reason": "The expanded 10.0000s end-card frame has the exact KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL wording and ochre dot. The 12.0000s and 14.9583s contact-sheet views show no visible change; this detailed pass is anchored to 10.0000s." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The end-card samples visibly show the requested CTA: \"See the details\"." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three end-card samples appear visually consistent in product geometry, label arrangement, cream background and rightward contact shadow. This supports only the static end-card samples." } } } }, "observations": [ "At 7.0000s and 8.0000s the lighting is visibly much harsher than the earlier samples: a broad bright body highlight, very bright cap reflection, pale dot and harder rightward shadow. This is observed appearance, not proof that a different material was generated." ] }, { "alias": "A03", "brief_id": "detail", "coverage": { "sample_count": 15, "contact_sheet_path": "frames/A03/contact-sheet.jpg", "sample_times": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s", "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "full_resolution_frames": [ { "timecode": "04.9583s", "path": "frames/A03/sample-006.png" }, { "timecode": "09.9583s", "path": "frames/A03/sample-012.png" }, { "timecode": "10.0000s", "path": "frames/A03/sample-013.png" } ] }, "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "All 12 generated/workflow samples show the full cap, body and base inside the frame with background remaining above and below the product. This verdict concerns crop only. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "In the 12 inspected contact-sheet samples for 0-10s, one upright bottle retains the recognizable cylindrical body, rounded shoulders, attached flat cap and silver base band. No extra product, person or prop is visible. This is a visible geometry assessment, not a pixel-exact match. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "04.9583s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The expanded generated/workflow frames at 04.9583s, 09.9583s show KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE, 500 mL and the ochre dot above the brand. No contradictory wording is visible elsewhere on the contact sheet; exact fine print outside these expanded times remains below the strict verification scope. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled 0-5s frames show \"A closer look\" and the sampled 5-10s frames show \"Field Bottle \u2022 500 mL\". The visible wording and segment assignment match the packet; no extra claim or substituted overlay is visible. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled front-facing silhouette, cap, base, dot and text arrangement remain recognizable and coherent. Diagonal light bands move across the cream background, and the scale resets at 5.0000s. Those planned visual changes are not evidence of identity corruption. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." } }, "sections": { "generated_workflow_0_10s": { "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "All 12 generated/workflow samples show the full cap, body and base inside the frame with background remaining above and below the product. This verdict concerns crop only." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "In the 12 inspected contact-sheet samples for 0-10s, one upright bottle retains the recognizable cylindrical body, rounded shoulders, attached flat cap and silver base band. No extra product, person or prop is visible. This is a visible geometry assessment, not a pixel-exact match." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "04.9583s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The expanded generated/workflow frames at 04.9583s, 09.9583s show KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE, 500 mL and the ochre dot above the brand. No contradictory wording is visible elsewhere on the contact sheet; exact fine print outside these expanded times remains below the strict verification scope." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled 0-5s frames show \"A closer look\" and the sampled 5-10s frames show \"Field Bottle \u2022 500 mL\". The visible wording and segment assignment match the packet; no extra claim or substituted overlay is visible." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled front-facing silhouette, cap, base, dot and text arrangement remain recognizable and coherent. Diagonal light bands move across the cream background, and the scale resets at 5.0000s. Those planned visual changes are not evidence of identity corruption." } } }, "static_end_card_10_15s": { "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three inspected end-card samples show the entire bottle cap, body and base." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three inspected end-card samples show one bottle with the reference silhouette, flat black cap, rounded shoulders and silver base band; no extra object is visible." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s" ], "reason": "The expanded 10.0000s end-card frame has the exact KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL wording and ochre dot. The 12.0000s and 14.9583s contact-sheet views show no visible change; this detailed pass is anchored to 10.0000s." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The end-card samples visibly show the requested CTA: \"See the details\"." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three end-card samples appear visually consistent in product geometry, label arrangement, cream background and rightward contact shadow. This supports only the static end-card samples." } } } }, "observations": [ "The 0-5s samples show increasingly pronounced diagonal bright background bands. No claim is made about the smoothness of this light change between samples." ] }, { "alias": "A04", "brief_id": "retarget", "coverage": { "sample_count": 15, "contact_sheet_path": "frames/A04/contact-sheet.jpg", "sample_times": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s", "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "full_resolution_frames": [ { "timecode": "04.9583s", "path": "frames/A04/sample-006.png" }, { "timecode": "05.0000s", "path": "frames/A04/sample-007.png" }, { "timecode": "07.0000s", "path": "frames/A04/sample-009.png" }, { "timecode": "10.0000s", "path": "frames/A04/sample-013.png" } ] }, "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "All 12 generated/workflow samples show the full cap, body and base inside the frame with background remaining above and below the product. This verdict concerns crop only. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "In the 12 inspected contact-sheet samples for 0-10s, one upright bottle retains the recognizable cylindrical body, rounded shoulders, attached flat cap and silver base band. No extra product, person or prop is visible. This is a visible geometry assessment, not a pixel-exact match. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "uncertain", "evidence": [ "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "07.0000s" ], "reason": "At 4.9583s, confirmed in the expanded frame, the bottle turns the right ends of KINGY and FIELD BOTTLE around its right contour; they cannot be read in full. The contact sheet shows the same visibility problem at 2.0000s, 3.0000s and 4.0000s. Expanded 5.0000s and 7.0000s frames have the exact full wording and ochre dot. The hidden letters remain unknown rather than being called corrupted or passed from the later views. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled 0-5s frames show \"Still thinking it over?\" and the sampled 5-10s frames show \"Meet your next bottle\". The visible wording and segment assignment match the packet; no extra claim or substituted overlay is visible. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "uncertain", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The label rotates toward the bottle right edge between 1.0000s and 4.9583s, leaving the end letters unseen, then returns to a full front-facing label at 5.0000s. The silhouette remains plausible, but hidden lettering cannot establish label consistency through the rotation. A warm left reflection is visible at 7.0000s onward. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." } }, "sections": { "generated_workflow_0_10s": { "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "All 12 generated/workflow samples show the full cap, body and base inside the frame with background remaining above and below the product. This verdict concerns crop only." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "In the 12 inspected contact-sheet samples for 0-10s, one upright bottle retains the recognizable cylindrical body, rounded shoulders, attached flat cap and silver base band. No extra product, person or prop is visible. This is a visible geometry assessment, not a pixel-exact match." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "uncertain", "evidence": [ "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "07.0000s" ], "reason": "At 4.9583s, confirmed in the expanded frame, the bottle turns the right ends of KINGY and FIELD BOTTLE around its right contour; they cannot be read in full. The contact sheet shows the same visibility problem at 2.0000s, 3.0000s and 4.0000s. Expanded 5.0000s and 7.0000s frames have the exact full wording and ochre dot. The hidden letters remain unknown rather than being called corrupted or passed from the later views." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled 0-5s frames show \"Still thinking it over?\" and the sampled 5-10s frames show \"Meet your next bottle\". The visible wording and segment assignment match the packet; no extra claim or substituted overlay is visible." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "uncertain", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The label rotates toward the bottle right edge between 1.0000s and 4.9583s, leaving the end letters unseen, then returns to a full front-facing label at 5.0000s. The silhouette remains plausible, but hidden lettering cannot establish label consistency through the rotation. A warm left reflection is visible at 7.0000s onward." } } }, "static_end_card_10_15s": { "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three inspected end-card samples show the entire bottle cap, body and base." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three inspected end-card samples show one bottle with the reference silhouette, flat black cap, rounded shoulders and silver base band; no extra object is visible." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s" ], "reason": "The expanded 10.0000s end-card frame has the exact KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL wording and ochre dot. The 12.0000s and 14.9583s contact-sheet views show no visible change; this detailed pass is anchored to 10.0000s." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The end-card samples visibly show the requested CTA: \"Take another look\"." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three end-card samples appear visually consistent in product geometry, label arrangement, cream background and rightward contact shadow. This supports only the static end-card samples." } } } }, "observations": [ "At 4.9583s the label is visibly wrapped toward the right contour: the end of KINGY and FIELD BOTTLE is hidden. This is an occlusion/visibility limit, not a demonstrated misspelling.", "A direct orientation and size reset is visible at the 4.9583s to 5.0000s segment boundary. The report does not assume the brief forbids a cut.", "The later samples show a strong warm/orange highlight on the left side, rather than merely a small camera drift." ] }, { "alias": "A05", "brief_id": "launch", "coverage": { "sample_count": 15, "contact_sheet_path": "frames/A05/contact-sheet.jpg", "sample_times": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s", "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "full_resolution_frames": [ { "timecode": "04.9583s", "path": "frames/A05/sample-006.png" }, { "timecode": "09.9583s", "path": "frames/A05/sample-012.png" }, { "timecode": "10.0000s", "path": "frames/A05/sample-013.png" } ] }, "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "All 12 generated/workflow samples show the full cap, body and base inside the frame with background remaining above and below the product. This verdict concerns crop only. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "In the 12 inspected contact-sheet samples for 0-10s, one upright bottle retains the recognizable cylindrical body, rounded shoulders, attached flat cap and silver base band. No extra product, person or prop is visible. This is a visible geometry assessment, not a pixel-exact match. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "04.9583s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The expanded generated/workflow frames at 04.9583s, 09.9583s show KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE, 500 mL and the ochre dot above the brand. No contradictory wording is visible elsewhere on the contact sheet; exact fine print outside these expanded times remains below the strict verification scope. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled 0-5s frames show \"Meet the Field Bottle\" and the sampled 5-10s frames show \"KINGY \u2022 500 mL\". The visible wording and segment assignment match the packet; no extra claim or substituted overlay is visible. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled bottle and background are very similar throughout the first two sections: same recognizable cap/body/base geometry, front-facing text and dot. This supports sampled identity consistency, not a claim about camera motion or animation quality. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." } }, "sections": { "generated_workflow_0_10s": { "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "All 12 generated/workflow samples show the full cap, body and base inside the frame with background remaining above and below the product. This verdict concerns crop only." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "In the 12 inspected contact-sheet samples for 0-10s, one upright bottle retains the recognizable cylindrical body, rounded shoulders, attached flat cap and silver base band. No extra product, person or prop is visible. This is a visible geometry assessment, not a pixel-exact match." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "04.9583s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The expanded generated/workflow frames at 04.9583s, 09.9583s show KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE, 500 mL and the ochre dot above the brand. No contradictory wording is visible elsewhere on the contact sheet; exact fine print outside these expanded times remains below the strict verification scope." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled 0-5s frames show \"Meet the Field Bottle\" and the sampled 5-10s frames show \"KINGY \u2022 500 mL\". The visible wording and segment assignment match the packet; no extra claim or substituted overlay is visible." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled bottle and background are very similar throughout the first two sections: same recognizable cap/body/base geometry, front-facing text and dot. This supports sampled identity consistency, not a claim about camera motion or animation quality." } } }, "static_end_card_10_15s": { "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three inspected end-card samples show the entire bottle cap, body and base." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three inspected end-card samples show one bottle with the reference silhouette, flat black cap, rounded shoulders and silver base band; no extra object is visible." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s" ], "reason": "The expanded 10.0000s end-card frame has the exact KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL wording and ochre dot. The 12.0000s and 14.9583s contact-sheet views show no visible change; this detailed pass is anchored to 10.0000s." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The end-card samples visibly show the requested CTA: \"Explore the collection\"." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three end-card samples appear visually consistent in product geometry, label arrangement, cream background and rightward contact shadow. This supports only the static end-card samples." } } } }, "observations": [ "The first 10 seconds appear near-static at the retained sample times. Stills alone do not establish whether the requested subtle motion exists between them." ] }, { "alias": "A06", "brief_id": "detail", "coverage": { "sample_count": 15, "contact_sheet_path": "frames/A06/contact-sheet.jpg", "sample_times": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s", "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "full_resolution_frames": [ { "timecode": "04.9583s", "path": "frames/A06/sample-006.png" }, { "timecode": "09.9583s", "path": "frames/A06/sample-012.png" }, { "timecode": "10.0000s", "path": "frames/A06/sample-013.png" } ] }, "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "All 12 generated/workflow samples show the full cap, body and base inside the frame with background remaining above and below the product. This verdict concerns crop only. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "In the 12 inspected contact-sheet samples for 0-10s, one upright bottle retains the recognizable cylindrical body, rounded shoulders, attached flat cap and silver base band. No extra product, person or prop is visible. This is a visible geometry assessment, not a pixel-exact match. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "04.9583s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The expanded generated/workflow frames at 04.9583s, 09.9583s show KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE, 500 mL and the ochre dot above the brand. No contradictory wording is visible elsewhere on the contact sheet; exact fine print outside these expanded times remains below the strict verification scope. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled 0-5s frames show \"A closer look\" and the sampled 5-10s frames show \"Field Bottle \u2022 500 mL\". The visible wording and segment assignment match the packet; no extra claim or substituted overlay is visible. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled bottle remains front-facing with the same recognizable geometry, dot and text arrangement. The first two sections appear near-static at the retained sample times; absence of between-sample change cannot be established. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." } }, "sections": { "generated_workflow_0_10s": { "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "All 12 generated/workflow samples show the full cap, body and base inside the frame with background remaining above and below the product. This verdict concerns crop only." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "In the 12 inspected contact-sheet samples for 0-10s, one upright bottle retains the recognizable cylindrical body, rounded shoulders, attached flat cap and silver base band. No extra product, person or prop is visible. This is a visible geometry assessment, not a pixel-exact match." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "04.9583s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The expanded generated/workflow frames at 04.9583s, 09.9583s show KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE, 500 mL and the ochre dot above the brand. No contradictory wording is visible elsewhere on the contact sheet; exact fine print outside these expanded times remains below the strict verification scope." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled 0-5s frames show \"A closer look\" and the sampled 5-10s frames show \"Field Bottle \u2022 500 mL\". The visible wording and segment assignment match the packet; no extra claim or substituted overlay is visible." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled bottle remains front-facing with the same recognizable geometry, dot and text arrangement. The first two sections appear near-static at the retained sample times; absence of between-sample change cannot be established." } } }, "static_end_card_10_15s": { "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three inspected end-card samples show the entire bottle cap, body and base." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three inspected end-card samples show one bottle with the reference silhouette, flat black cap, rounded shoulders and silver base band; no extra object is visible." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s" ], "reason": "The expanded 10.0000s end-card frame has the exact KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL wording and ochre dot. The 12.0000s and 14.9583s contact-sheet views show no visible change; this detailed pass is anchored to 10.0000s." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The end-card samples visibly show the requested CTA: \"See the details\"." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three end-card samples appear visually consistent in product geometry, label arrangement, cream background and rightward contact shadow. This supports only the static end-card samples." } } } }, "observations": [ "These samples show little visible change of light. That is recorded separately from the five identity/copy criteria; no full-playback creative-direction verdict is made." ] }, { "alias": "A07", "brief_id": "launch", "coverage": { "sample_count": 15, "contact_sheet_path": "frames/A07/contact-sheet.jpg", "sample_times": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s", "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "full_resolution_frames": [ { "timecode": "04.9583s", "path": "frames/A07/sample-006.png" }, { "timecode": "09.9583s", "path": "frames/A07/sample-012.png" }, { "timecode": "10.0000s", "path": "frames/A07/sample-013.png" } ] }, "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "All 12 generated/workflow samples show the full cap, body and base inside the frame with background remaining above and below the product. This verdict concerns crop only. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "In the 12 inspected contact-sheet samples for 0-10s, one upright bottle retains the recognizable cylindrical body, rounded shoulders, attached flat cap and silver base band. No extra product, person or prop is visible. This is a visible geometry assessment, not a pixel-exact match. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "04.9583s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The expanded generated/workflow frames at 04.9583s, 09.9583s show KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE, 500 mL and the ochre dot above the brand. No contradictory wording is visible elsewhere on the contact sheet; exact fine print outside these expanded times remains below the strict verification scope. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled 0-5s frames show \"Meet the Field Bottle\" and the sampled 5-10s frames show \"KINGY \u2022 500 mL\". The visible wording and segment assignment match the packet; no extra claim or substituted overlay is visible. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The bottle enlarges within each of the first two five-second sections, retaining its front-facing label and recognizable cap/shoulder/base geometry. A size reset is visible at 5.0000s. No lettering substitution is apparent at the full-resolution checks, but smooth motion is untested. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." } }, "sections": { "generated_workflow_0_10s": { "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "All 12 generated/workflow samples show the full cap, body and base inside the frame with background remaining above and below the product. This verdict concerns crop only." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "In the 12 inspected contact-sheet samples for 0-10s, one upright bottle retains the recognizable cylindrical body, rounded shoulders, attached flat cap and silver base band. No extra product, person or prop is visible. This is a visible geometry assessment, not a pixel-exact match." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "04.9583s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The expanded generated/workflow frames at 04.9583s, 09.9583s show KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE, 500 mL and the ochre dot above the brand. No contradictory wording is visible elsewhere on the contact sheet; exact fine print outside these expanded times remains below the strict verification scope." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled 0-5s frames show \"Meet the Field Bottle\" and the sampled 5-10s frames show \"KINGY \u2022 500 mL\". The visible wording and segment assignment match the packet; no extra claim or substituted overlay is visible." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The bottle enlarges within each of the first two five-second sections, retaining its front-facing label and recognizable cap/shoulder/base geometry. A size reset is visible at 5.0000s. No lettering substitution is apparent at the full-resolution checks, but smooth motion is untested." } } }, "static_end_card_10_15s": { "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three inspected end-card samples show the entire bottle cap, body and base." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three inspected end-card samples show one bottle with the reference silhouette, flat black cap, rounded shoulders and silver base band; no extra object is visible." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s" ], "reason": "The expanded 10.0000s end-card frame has the exact KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL wording and ochre dot. The 12.0000s and 14.9583s contact-sheet views show no visible change; this detailed pass is anchored to 10.0000s." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The end-card samples visibly show the requested CTA: \"Explore the collection\"." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three end-card samples appear visually consistent in product geometry, label arrangement, cream background and rightward contact shadow. This supports only the static end-card samples." } } } }, "observations": [ "The bottle scale resets between 4.9583s and 5.0000s and again at the 10.0000s end card. Full cap and base remain visible in the retained samples." ] }, { "alias": "A08", "brief_id": "launch", "coverage": { "sample_count": 15, "contact_sheet_path": "frames/A08/contact-sheet.jpg", "sample_times": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s", "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "full_resolution_frames": [ { "timecode": "04.0000s", "path": "frames/A08/sample-005.png" }, { "timecode": "04.9583s", "path": "frames/A08/sample-006.png" }, { "timecode": "05.0000s", "path": "frames/A08/sample-007.png" }, { "timecode": "09.9583s", "path": "frames/A08/sample-012.png" }, { "timecode": "10.0000s", "path": "frames/A08/sample-013.png" } ] }, "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "All 12 generated/workflow samples show the full cap, body and base inside the frame with background remaining above and below the product. This verdict concerns crop only. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "In the 12 inspected contact-sheet samples for 0-10s, one upright bottle retains the recognizable cylindrical body, rounded shoulders, attached flat cap and silver base band. No extra product, person or prop is visible. This is a visible geometry assessment, not a pixel-exact match. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The expanded generated/workflow frames at 04.0000s, 04.9583s, 05.0000s, 09.9583s show KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE, 500 mL and the ochre dot above the brand. No contradictory wording is visible elsewhere on the contact sheet; exact fine print outside these expanded times remains below the strict verification scope. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "uncertain", "evidence": [ "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The early samples show Meet the Field Bottle, and the second section shows KINGY \u2022 500 mL. At 4.0000s and 4.9583s the cap runs into the first headline and darkens/obscures lower letter portions in the expanded frames. The intended phrase remains recognizable, but a strict wholly visible letter-by-letter match at those times is uncertain. No alternative or invented wording is observed. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The enlarging bottle retains recognizable shape, cap, base, dot and product-label text in the inspected samples. Its scale resets at 5.0000s. The first-segment enlargement visibly brings the cap into the overlay line at 4.0000s and 4.9583s; this is a layout/readability issue, not a demonstrated identity substitution. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." } }, "sections": { "generated_workflow_0_10s": { "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "All 12 generated/workflow samples show the full cap, body and base inside the frame with background remaining above and below the product. This verdict concerns crop only." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "In the 12 inspected contact-sheet samples for 0-10s, one upright bottle retains the recognizable cylindrical body, rounded shoulders, attached flat cap and silver base band. No extra product, person or prop is visible. This is a visible geometry assessment, not a pixel-exact match." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The expanded generated/workflow frames at 04.0000s, 04.9583s, 05.0000s, 09.9583s show KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE, 500 mL and the ochre dot above the brand. No contradictory wording is visible elsewhere on the contact sheet; exact fine print outside these expanded times remains below the strict verification scope." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "uncertain", "evidence": [ "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The early samples show Meet the Field Bottle, and the second section shows KINGY \u2022 500 mL. At 4.0000s and 4.9583s the cap runs into the first headline and darkens/obscures lower letter portions in the expanded frames. The intended phrase remains recognizable, but a strict wholly visible letter-by-letter match at those times is uncertain. No alternative or invented wording is observed." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The enlarging bottle retains recognizable shape, cap, base, dot and product-label text in the inspected samples. Its scale resets at 5.0000s. The first-segment enlargement visibly brings the cap into the overlay line at 4.0000s and 4.9583s; this is a layout/readability issue, not a demonstrated identity substitution." } } }, "static_end_card_10_15s": { "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three inspected end-card samples show the entire bottle cap, body and base." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three inspected end-card samples show one bottle with the reference silhouette, flat black cap, rounded shoulders and silver base band; no extra object is visible." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s" ], "reason": "The expanded 10.0000s end-card frame has the exact KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL wording and ochre dot. The 12.0000s and 14.9583s contact-sheet views show no visible change; this detailed pass is anchored to 10.0000s." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The end-card samples visibly show the requested CTA: \"Explore the collection\"." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three end-card samples appear visually consistent in product geometry, label arrangement, cream background and rightward contact shadow. This supports only the static end-card samples." } } } }, "observations": [ "At 4.0000s and 4.9583s the black cap overlaps the dark headline line. The lower portions of several headline letters lose contrast against the cap.", "The whole bottle remains in frame at those times; copy overlap is distinct from cap cropping.", "The bottle size resets substantially between 4.9583s and 5.0000s. The later end card cannot resolve the earlier headline visibility issue." ] }, { "alias": "A09", "brief_id": "retarget", "coverage": { "sample_count": 15, "contact_sheet_path": "frames/A09/contact-sheet.jpg", "sample_times": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s", "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "full_resolution_frames": [ { "timecode": "04.9583s", "path": "frames/A09/sample-006.png" }, { "timecode": "09.9583s", "path": "frames/A09/sample-012.png" }, { "timecode": "10.0000s", "path": "frames/A09/sample-013.png" } ] }, "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "All 12 generated/workflow samples show the full cap, body and base inside the frame with background remaining above and below the product. This verdict concerns crop only. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "In the 12 inspected contact-sheet samples for 0-10s, one upright bottle retains the recognizable cylindrical body, rounded shoulders, attached flat cap and silver base band. No extra product, person or prop is visible. This is a visible geometry assessment, not a pixel-exact match. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "04.9583s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The expanded generated/workflow frames at 04.9583s, 09.9583s show KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE, 500 mL and the ochre dot above the brand. No contradictory wording is visible elsewhere on the contact sheet; exact fine print outside these expanded times remains below the strict verification scope. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled 0-5s frames show \"Still thinking it over?\" and the sampled 5-10s frames show \"Meet your next bottle\". The visible wording and segment assignment match the packet; no extra claim or substituted overlay is visible. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled bottle remains front-facing with matching visible shape, cap, base, dot and text arrangement across the first two sections. The samples appear near-static; this supports sampled identity consistency but does not establish requested camera motion. The separately assessed 10-15s static end card passes on its cited samples and is not used to upgrade this 0-10s verdict." } }, "sections": { "generated_workflow_0_10s": { "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "All 12 generated/workflow samples show the full cap, body and base inside the frame with background remaining above and below the product. This verdict concerns crop only." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "In the 12 inspected contact-sheet samples for 0-10s, one upright bottle retains the recognizable cylindrical body, rounded shoulders, attached flat cap and silver base band. No extra product, person or prop is visible. This is a visible geometry assessment, not a pixel-exact match." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "04.9583s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The expanded generated/workflow frames at 04.9583s, 09.9583s show KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE, 500 mL and the ochre dot above the brand. No contradictory wording is visible elsewhere on the contact sheet; exact fine print outside these expanded times remains below the strict verification scope." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled 0-5s frames show \"Still thinking it over?\" and the sampled 5-10s frames show \"Meet your next bottle\". The visible wording and segment assignment match the packet; no extra claim or substituted overlay is visible." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "00.0000s", "01.0000s", "02.0000s", "03.0000s", "04.0000s", "04.9583s", "05.0000s", "06.0000s", "07.0000s", "08.0000s", "09.0000s", "09.9583s" ], "reason": "The sampled bottle remains front-facing with matching visible shape, cap, base, dot and text arrangement across the first two sections. The samples appear near-static; this supports sampled identity consistency but does not establish requested camera motion." } } }, "static_end_card_10_15s": { "criteria": { "framing": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three inspected end-card samples show the entire bottle cap, body and base." }, "product_identity_geometry": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three inspected end-card samples show one bottle with the reference silhouette, flat black cap, rounded shoulders and silver base band; no extra object is visible." }, "product_label": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s" ], "reason": "The expanded 10.0000s end-card frame has the exact KINGY, FIELD BOTTLE and 500 mL wording and ochre dot. The 12.0000s and 14.9583s contact-sheet views show no visible change; this detailed pass is anchored to 10.0000s." }, "added_overlay_copy": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The end-card samples visibly show the requested CTA: \"Take another look\"." }, "sampled_consistency": { "verdict": "pass", "evidence": [ "10.0000s", "12.0000s", "14.9583s" ], "reason": "The three end-card samples appear visually consistent in product geometry, label arrangement, cream background and rightward contact shadow. This supports only the static end-card samples." } } } }, "observations": [ "The first 10 seconds appear near-static at the retained samples. Smooth camera drift or the absence of motion between these samples was not tested." ] } ], "summary": { "all_aliases_framing": "pass on the inspected samples", "all_aliases_geometry": "pass on the inspected visible geometry", "uncertain_items": [ "A02: label-dot color and strict color/finish consistency under strong lighting at 7.0000s and 8.0000s.", "A04: hidden ends of label text during the 2.0000s-4.9583s rotation; corresponding label consistency remains uncertain.", "A08: headline/cap overlap limits a strict unobstructed overlay-copy confirmation at 4.0000s and 4.9583s." ], "directly_demonstrated_wrong_word_or_cropped_bottle": false, "fail_verdict_count": 0, "interpretation": "No failure is invented from hidden detail, lighting ambiguity, intended shot changes, or near-static samples. The reported uncertainties and visible layout issue are not acceptance. Static-card passes do not certify generated/workflow segments." }, "provenance": { "initial_assignment_prompt_exact": "Perform an independent visual assessment, not human review, of nine anonymized retained product-ad frame sets. Workspace [workspace]. Read ONLY implementation/2026-10-19/kingy-original-testing/assessment-v1/private/reviewer-packet.json and its source truth/image + alias sheets/frames. DO NOT read blind-key.json, original source files with provider names, other reviews, or cost data. Inspect source image and all9contact sheets with view_image, then full-resolution frames where label/details need it. Criterion definitions: framing fullcap/body/base, product identity geometry (same shape, cap/base, one product/no extra objects), product label exact KINGY / FIELD BOTTLE / 500 mL and ochre dot (uncertain if illegible), added overlay copy matches brief per5sec segment, sampled consistency (only visible sampled frames). Separate generated/workflow section 0-10s from static end card10-15s; do not give credit to entire film based on endcard. Each pass limited to inspected frames, fail requires alias/timecode/directly visible contradiction; uncertain for unavailable detail. Coverage15samples perfinal, not full playback, no universal ranking or human acceptance. Report actual model identity only if known, otherwise unavailable; this is subscribed agent assessment with no external paid API. Save full structured review and reasoning to assessment-v1/private/review-a.json with peralias5criteria each {verdict:pass|fail|uncertain,evidence:[timecode strings],reason}, plus reviewed paths, added full frames inspected, limitations, reviewer identity. Do not view another review. No originals modifications/no generation/no external writes/publish. You may create only review-a.json under this scope. Return concise findings when complete.", "followup_prompt_exact": "Please include the exact initial review task/prompt in saved provenance or a separate review-a-prompt.txt, plus model/version if exposed else unavailable. Finish and return soon so I can reconcile/publish. If source cap is obscured by overlay rather than out of frame, distinguish that from literal cropping.", "actual_model_id": "unavailable", "model_version": "unavailable", "tools_used": [ "exec_command for packet parsing and writing this review", "view_image for direct visual inspection" ], "review_paths_are_alias_paths": true }, "public_export_note": "Private local paths replaced with portable labels; verdicts and prompt wording otherwise preserved. The human_acceptance field is normalized to null (not measured), not a failed human decision.", "private_original_record_sha256": "2d267047336fdcf390f6a00e2477c0aaaea959031d9f238b9cd9d541e98b14a2" }