# Agent visual observations · September 24, 2026

These are agent interpretations of still samples, not human acceptance decisions, a full playback review, or a quality ranking. Samples were chosen by time before inspection: 1, 6 and 11 seconds for each new conventional export; 1, 4 and 7 seconds for every retained raw clip. The original files are in the downloads so readers can inspect the whole sequence.

## New conventional exports

All three briefs show the same complete green fictional bottle and the expected three copy lines in the sampled frames. The renderer holds a still packshot and changes the copy between sections. It adds no generated motion. A real reviewer still needs to judge product fidelity, copy readability at phone size and whether this simple treatment meets the production brief. A mechanically valid export is not an accepted ad.

## Retained raw clips

| Attempt | Observation in the three samples | What still needs review |
|---|---|---|
| 001 · Kling v3 Pro · filter | Hands handle the cartridge in the first two samples; three indicators appear in the last. | The hands contradict the source prompt's no-people constraint. Full motion and final narration/copy remain unreviewed. |
| 002 · Kling O3 · kettle | A flat illustrated kettle remains consistent across the samples. | The prompt asked for realistic product photography; a clear off-state is not established by these samples. |
| 003 · Kling O3 · filter | A stylized filter panel opens to show the interior, with three indicator dots later. | Whether this communicates cartridge removal and reinsertion needs playback review. |
| 004 · Kling O3 · invoice | Blue illustrated application views change across the samples. | A generic document icon does not by itself establish a clear PDF export sequence. |
| 005 · Kling v3 Pro · invoice | A laptop application contains distorted pseudo-text and a malformed document icon. | Legibility and the intended three-shot story need review before use. |
| 006 · Kling v3 Pro · kettle | A realistic kettle close-up has visible indicators early and a darker state in the final sample. | These frames do not verify capacity or an unambiguous automatic shutoff story. |
| 007 · Kling O3 · filter | A stylized panel separates from the filter, with three indicators visible. | The floating panel may weaken the physical explanation; inspect the full movement. |
| 008 · Veo Fast · kettle | A blue indicator appears on, then off, then on in the three samples. | A single shutoff action is ambiguous in this sample sequence. |
| 009 · Kling v3 Pro · invoice | A laptop interface includes malformed text and figures. | A clearly recognizable recurring template is not established in the samples. |
| 010 · Kling O3 · invoice | A flat blue interface includes pseudo-words and figures. | The specific requested app actions and readable final overlays need separate review. |
| 011 · Veo Fast · invoice | A laptop remains in view while invoice/form/export-like states change. | Three distinct camera shots are not established by the sampled frames. |

All eleven raw clips still lack the prescribed final overlays; the filter brief also requires fixed narration. Their technical passes must not be counted as finished deliverables. Prompt fit, typography and narrative clarity can fail while a file decodes perfectly.

The billing observations are historical. No provider account was opened to reconcile them in this recheck. No new paid generation was performed, and human editing time remains unknown.