{
  "schemaVersion": "kingy-independent-public-projection-review/1.0.0",
  "studyId": "document-comparison-v24-20261018.1",
  "reviewedAtUtc": "2026-10-18T18:26:38.863968+00:00",
  "approved": true,
  "independentReview": true,
  "reviewedAfterAllModelsStopped": true,
  "allScientificFieldsUnchanged": true,
  "privateMaterialExcluded": true,
  "negativeControlsPassed": true,
  "analysisCompletionSha256": "aaadd02fde4486dc2720f43034bc95913a2f69e9fcfc8eedc3609cb549fb8e7d",
  "workflowLineageSha256": "5054e64ae9fcf052410a119978ee6cf496e55c3a06ff6a5152a637627749f0c0",
  "projectionToolSha256": "dae0770270ae4e9baea7f838e440ddcd0201b9d2a7afe44fda71c7ce0fdc41f3",
  "privacyCoreSha256": "33eed171d8996e744eb319e77a2e096edd66e3bea8e0ac33045dd8609bbe3f84",
  "projectionLineageSha256": "428f337c40ec5fae63f95de48ae87e5194cf5045f457d0d9ec92989e17c2586f",
  "reportInputMetadataSha256": "92deb670d9d46b310c3c5e5e5c8feb61edd5f0678ca58716d37c8d326d92a261",
  "reportArtifactCount": 41,
  "artifactBindings": [
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/paired-results.json",
      "originalSha256": "d15d9b827c7e0b0d0440afc6dd549168236c835549e2ad0111c13ba4cb89c3e1",
      "publicSha256": "d15d9b827c7e0b0d0440afc6dd549168236c835549e2ad0111c13ba4cb89c3e1"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/summaries.json",
      "originalSha256": "af00e7c04884afbe97be021361d49d506c87e070259a7ebdb2d75010d98c6713",
      "publicSha256": "6b19b267330e5b546c9b9949d6b3cc1830a3e34ad7978bf9ae82e60de365ae0d"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/session-provenance.json",
      "originalSha256": "1cb76480dd3aad18603cbe872412e631078b105c6724b02d4db698c7377b349c",
      "publicSha256": "50b47c705bbdc2f2e9e273fea7f0e7ec2bd9c78345f98434ec67fa1cd71cd83a"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/kingy-raw.jsonl",
      "originalSha256": "cf85176126d315b58160d3cbb60d57f868afb6ed9e84b87cd85df86f5917b065",
      "publicSha256": "ae1491ac449b06cb2c1731208b9fb6d0b397694eb005864a6cc456e020c9dfc2"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/native-raw.jsonl",
      "originalSha256": "f2e2baa5187b9a4cea5b8c3810381e0780e95bdb253558cb5f423ca3c5bc8424",
      "publicSha256": "dce672a746eee02927bf2a61e7aedf06029fae8df6cde4a0bce6da30f1aa1b5f"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/analysis-completion.json",
      "originalSha256": "aaadd02fde4486dc2720f43034bc95913a2f69e9fcfc8eedc3609cb549fb8e7d",
      "publicSha256": "aaadd02fde4486dc2720f43034bc95913a2f69e9fcfc8eedc3609cb549fb8e7d"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/protocol.md",
      "originalSha256": "d7b8c8a8559ed76925cd0257b023f59d152d6c29bec0d9e49229ddbed5bae0bc",
      "publicSha256": "d7b8c8a8559ed76925cd0257b023f59d152d6c29bec0d9e49229ddbed5bae0bc"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/scoring.md",
      "originalSha256": "2d0b2201a894bb663f5f71a6c2464bcf7d53138b84b83de153ed9bf18f553259",
      "publicSha256": "2d0b2201a894bb663f5f71a6c2464bcf7d53138b84b83de153ed9bf18f553259"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/freeze.json",
      "originalSha256": "f968a685190b843d121167b1031130e79a8daaf5a86da13effef37cb7af45936",
      "publicSha256": "74b9864d7e01ebcd5775b5ec0fadc6a3bb4283428513d2991fc47ff5ea275c7f"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/method-freeze.json",
      "originalSha256": "c3cfa47c1e7a30832d0fdad78774ff5543a1851f5d679389b9ce097540d51709",
      "publicSha256": "b182ad917d590521c622e93e447de296481d9f6db98261ccccf7d6f8303580b2"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/measurement-integrity.json",
      "originalSha256": "55c6073e5e88de4fefd694d2dc91ea9b2d2e0f6ffd8fad90d654cca6546cbf00",
      "publicSha256": "30205ab52d00ed8564dc789e750082c959894b9f3408acfcf924b6fe869f7c5d"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/qualification-decision.json",
      "originalSha256": "0be7f29e838cb0ec9c75744d2b25d2765bb2db4e650a8c6baed72cc161570e69",
      "publicSha256": "0be7f29e838cb0ec9c75744d2b25d2765bb2db4e650a8c6baed72cc161570e69"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/fresh-failures.json",
      "originalSha256": "58a04b49f62702527f2139d88f4107617cc200a0a98aedb7e433f04033da8fbd",
      "publicSha256": "58a04b49f62702527f2139d88f4107617cc200a0a98aedb7e433f04033da8fbd"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/final-audit.json",
      "originalSha256": "f9d6f762dd963af631c2146a59457d7231554828520e8b1b89de3decde6a1b00",
      "publicSha256": "07798964c26d6b9126a2fa7134e9d680ab76a6b8ca3f64d332943d59bf94e468"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/final-audit-notes.md",
      "originalSha256": "6ce3f17a5d2e6342cc41d1b8910e34764508a1438a2e1db359de911a8513bbc0",
      "publicSha256": "6ce3f17a5d2e6342cc41d1b8910e34764508a1438a2e1db359de911a8513bbc0"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/completion-eligibility.json",
      "originalSha256": "6af7ef7f761ebd31edc268b61231385d1ba9758325f380ea7d1fe4481107f5c1",
      "publicSha256": "9e2f90f98029af814a6848c9f5fe791ae91eb67b03fd31684c7e066d74f074fb"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/installation.json",
      "originalSha256": "b56fd88145a9930020da961d8dfa129067323b93e51619776d4cfe3a4809080f",
      "publicSha256": "9f40b29e451739967c274b108282c41eead19fc96079f01e3e5b9a1162c36133"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/selftest-raw.jsonl",
      "originalSha256": "42710fd8d31110dd9846cdc83fe64bc5680443375ae4af5b36f8c52692225670",
      "publicSha256": "f632028c6eaadf63e8fad8bee89a998d3be12c9d154c4aee0c5c8a5bf6c36663"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/selftest-summary.json",
      "originalSha256": "4022ddb4e18b2bbd5ec5e2cee5174eaf371b76428d7ed8c21ebd6638cba542fa",
      "publicSha256": "4022ddb4e18b2bbd5ec5e2cee5174eaf371b76428d7ed8c21ebd6638cba542fa"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/network-checks.json",
      "originalSha256": "77f7a86eb014d334417ba7d0525d0b676a5a0af3359faf3c2fcb31f7b8714560",
      "publicSha256": "77f7a86eb014d334417ba7d0525d0b676a5a0af3359faf3c2fcb31f7b8714560"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/report-narrative.json",
      "originalSha256": "c9167107f3da61ef5b156e8a77997dde330cd4bcc0ed28f8646f57e091197a95",
      "publicSha256": "c9167107f3da61ef5b156e8a77997dde330cd4bcc0ed28f8646f57e091197a95"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/candidate-changes.json",
      "originalSha256": "9824855623ea294fd9d6bb2feeaf900f3d7ffe1b42ff0de99ec58056e49a8989",
      "publicSha256": "9824855623ea294fd9d6bb2feeaf900f3d7ffe1b42ff0de99ec58056e49a8989"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/history-preservation.json",
      "originalSha256": "ad82a8122acc46f4e0e0d693a98ac215331b492349eb8f76ae87230490ea51dc",
      "publicSha256": "506f2326a6f3e9eb76e4f9eeec7ebf88a658052d5cb2ad9f7f5878f456d54f55"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/kingy-settings.json",
      "originalSha256": "00f086449f790bea02b4e829ddafad49ffed4c0ce891375c9b85c9d085153a97",
      "publicSha256": "00f086449f790bea02b4e829ddafad49ffed4c0ce891375c9b85c9d085153a97"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/native-settings.json",
      "originalSha256": "59271fba82e95ad0ad55e082673da4112cbccd86596ef926259f0bbc0ab5f188",
      "publicSha256": "59271fba82e95ad0ad55e082673da4112cbccd86596ef926259f0bbc0ab5f188"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/native-runtime.json",
      "originalSha256": "a3cc8b82ce1135e9daf17e17d4d4fcf061edd0ab3827946a580e701102eb17a3",
      "publicSha256": "a3cc8b82ce1135e9daf17e17d4d4fcf061edd0ab3827946a580e701102eb17a3"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/native-rag.json",
      "originalSha256": "879a81063ac8a97ab8200fd1105b86997bcb0580610ec40cf31df3a05b9be62b",
      "publicSha256": "879a81063ac8a97ab8200fd1105b86997bcb0580610ec40cf31df3a05b9be62b"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/control-provenance.json",
      "originalSha256": "2dc6b1bfd6318c305732912d9c991530b69b74e95ff562795826e3705a154986",
      "publicSha256": "2dc6b1bfd6318c305732912d9c991530b69b74e95ff562795826e3705a154986"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/method-approval.json",
      "originalSha256": "975b8f91179494e6420d50e116b9011b795aef4a7e863fff006d5c72f537107c",
      "publicSha256": "51736a986d11bf5cb49d83dd38317a2844759f93e6d666ff2a3ebbabdb3cec03"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/scorer-validation.json",
      "originalSha256": "0ce1522d447de753efef208ad3a5160f78e0b1000134cf2c6838c4c59f174f79",
      "publicSha256": "0ce1522d447de753efef208ad3a5160f78e0b1000134cf2c6838c4c59f174f79"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/corpus-freeze.json",
      "originalSha256": "9f71a39abecdfe1990fd1d130a408767265341362d72c96a51d5448d351f6867",
      "publicSha256": "e9edf878c8a1392cc50c4b09f2575f4a5583b30c5264dbc7bbccf2dde79d7164"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/corpus-review.json",
      "originalSha256": "0b6e285a595f6003470e0f21e812733dd70e31c2cbe0d81eb9f35f9a9d4aa017",
      "publicSha256": "6e5da968f07e168e903b04226975b20a878a17b70d6ba6e85c2c13716761fd98"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/history-manifest.json",
      "originalSha256": "fc28d7f64e75a37768586ded40807195f55aac7d1337d27ecf7a700fbd63a4e6",
      "publicSha256": "fc28d7f64e75a37768586ded40807195f55aac7d1337d27ecf7a700fbd63a4e6"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/v15-history-manifest.json",
      "originalSha256": "f62295ede008d7312b9dc967d7c7394fd552a3736558b04286f69b075827ed5e",
      "publicSha256": "f62295ede008d7312b9dc967d7c7394fd552a3736558b04286f69b075827ed5e"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/v19-history-manifest.json",
      "originalSha256": "2c9bc99ccffb4fa0d68053a0a0c8766808efc9e92901aeb36effba824d3357fd",
      "publicSha256": "2c9bc99ccffb4fa0d68053a0a0c8766808efc9e92901aeb36effba824d3357fd"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/v20-history-manifest.json",
      "originalSha256": "295bafdb79648533f3cfade9aa23380dfedf633bfb8640c02a30bbc90abf8b62",
      "publicSha256": "295bafdb79648533f3cfade9aa23380dfedf633bfb8640c02a30bbc90abf8b62"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/v21-history-manifest.json",
      "originalSha256": "dca7d395feadfc268ad8afca66ffc25407f1dde5c23a85ac9786c00be5ad977d",
      "publicSha256": "dca7d395feadfc268ad8afca66ffc25407f1dde5c23a85ac9786c00be5ad977d"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/v22-history-manifest.json",
      "originalSha256": "159912e9acb016fcc4ccb8073258250c5864155c804e5c9794310577b44c3b94",
      "publicSha256": "159912e9acb016fcc4ccb8073258250c5864155c804e5c9794310577b44c3b94"
    },
    {
      "publicFile": "evidence/v23-history-manifest.json",
      "originalSha256": "5d8b38c4e3c50d3dadc6cbd59200790bfd5fbd21d8b57d2e80a1cfcfb5b776bc",
      "publicSha256": "5d8b38c4e3c50d3dadc6cbd59200790bfd5fbd21d8b57d2e80a1cfcfb5b776bc"
    }
  ],
  "workflowArtifactCount": 13,
  "workflowPublicArtifactSha256": {
    "evidence.json": "81e3cc723325a65e81c565cbcaec10c2ad29e524c09f3aed4eb1a2693dc39abd",
    "summary.json": "6b19b267330e5b546c9b9949d6b3cc1830a3e34ad7978bf9ae82e60de365ae0d",
    "installation.json": "9f40b29e451739967c274b108282c41eead19fc96079f01e3e5b9a1162c36133",
    "raw-evaluation.jsonl": "ae1491ac449b06cb2c1731208b9fb6d0b397694eb005864a6cc456e020c9dfc2",
    "known-limitations.md": "3f9784e4f496b3362361e72cb94ba53c6d8fee30e4a3d536796a7b657a1d3b28",
    "selftest-summary.json": "4022ddb4e18b2bbd5ec5e2cee5174eaf371b76428d7ed8c21ebd6638cba542fa",
    "document-workflow-v156.zip": "3be3b7da503894be99829496b6aa8ce38bb635a5a5c86916f694ec7e4eeea396",
    "public-projection-lineage.json": "5054e64ae9fcf052410a119978ee6cf496e55c3a06ff6a5152a637627749f0c0",
    "evaluation-freeze.json": "74b9864d7e01ebcd5775b5ec0fadc6a3bb4283428513d2991fc47ff5ea275c7f",
    "README.md": "012a3030b1c295f5df5654293831dc866f66b6f566321591f6cdfa7252792791",
    "selftest.jsonl": "f632028c6eaadf63e8fad8bee89a998d3be12c9d154c4aee0c5c8a5bf6c36663",
    "network-checks.json": "77f7a86eb014d334417ba7d0525d0b676a5a0af3359faf3c2fcb31f7b8714560",
    "SCORING.md": "2d0b2201a894bb663f5f71a6c2464bcf7d53138b84b83de153ed9bf18f553259"
  },
  "workflowEvidenceSha256": "81e3cc723325a65e81c565cbcaec10c2ad29e524c09f3aed4eb1a2693dc39abd",
  "testedRecipeZipSha256": "3be3b7da503894be99829496b6aa8ce38bb635a5a5c86916f694ec7e4eeea396",
  "bundleChecks": {
    "sourceAndMethodFiles": 52,
    "originalCorpusInputs": 7,
    "totalArchiveMembersIncludingReadme": 60,
    "allFrozenOriginalPinsVerified": true,
    "sourceDerivativesContainOnlyDeclaredLocalRootLiteralChanges": true,
    "sourceDerivativesWereNotExecuted": true,
    "questionsReferencesAndFivePdfsByteExact": true
  },
  "scientificChecks": {
    "originalAttempts": 240,
    "allQuestionAnswerCitationGradeTimingAndUncertaintyValuesStructurallyExact": true,
    "originalKingyCommonSha256": "cf85176126d315b58160d3cbb60d57f868afb6ed9e84b87cd85df86f5917b065",
    "originalNativeCommonSha256": "f2e2baa5187b9a4cea5b8c3810381e0780e95bdb253558cb5f423ca3c5bc8424",
    "noAliasSourceOrFrozenResultChanges": true
  },
  "metadataAndNarrativeChecks": {
    "allCurrentSettingsAndControlMetadataReviewed": true,
    "copiedWorkflowConfigurationMatchesCurrentMeasuredPins": true,
    "actualNativeSettingsRowsVerified": 120,
    "actualKingyModelRequestsVerified": 267,
    "finiteRecognitionAndCitationSupportCaveatsPreserved": true,
    "visibleSingleDocumentScopeCorrectionVerified": true,
    "fiveAdjacentPageCasesAndNoCrossDocumentSynthesisClaimed": true,
    "testedZipAndFrozenReadmeUnchanged": true,
    "noWinnerPrivacyOrSpeedSuperiorityClaimAdded": true
  },
  "privacyChecks": {
    "topLevelCandidateFiles": 55,
    "filesAndArchiveMembersChecked": 140,
    "decodedKeysAndValuesChecked": true,
    "credentialNeedlesChecked": 13,
    "retainedConversationIdentitiesChecked": 120,
    "retainedActionIdentitiesChecked": 843,
    "wholePrivateOriginalHashesChecked": 3576,
    "rawBackingControlConfigurationAndLogMaterialExcluded": true,
    "noBroadAllowanceGranted": true
  },
  "negativeControls": {
    "independentCases": 62,
    "allPassed": true,
    "escapedJsonAndJsonlKeysAndValues": true,
    "nestedArchives": true,
    "credentialsAndExactDraftsNotWaivable": true,
    "relativeControlAndExplicitBackingIdentitiesNotWaivable": true,
    "protectedScientificLeakFailsClosed": true,
    "safePublicDigestProtocolReceiptAndInertSourceCasesRemainAllowed": true
  },
  "reviewEvidenceSha256": {
    "exactRegeneratedPayload": "521ce442fbf09fcad07d277b4d72f26d5549c3de9fa856cd6d6bc2a39dec5162",
    "independentNegativeControls": "2fa17e311ec660d161ba6bb74623baa91bb7b7eed46f732eabfa0814e3d584d2",
    "allArtifactSourceAndInputComparison": "22045d2845ae7732c2a338066235c7be3f0a24dcac5915ee826b01258f870cd0"
  },
  "scope": "Approval binds only these exact public candidate projections and workflow artifacts after the complete stopped study. Original and public hashes are distinct; path-sanitized source derivatives are inert audit text and were never executed. Private diagnostics are retained separately and excluded here. Final rendered report, proposed exact privacy allowlist, final app payload, deployment and anonymous public readback remain separate required checks; this receipt does not authorize or claim publication."
}