The independent audit covers all 240 retained v24 outputs through 80 exact semantic/source bundles, each mapped to three original attempts. Every unique raw answer, requested fact and role, emitted citation and actual source span was reviewed. This is an independent-context AI audit on the same Mac, not human adjudication or reproduction on separate hardware.

The frozen scores are valid as conservative bounds within the declared finite-recognition method. They remain unchanged: in each repetition, Kingy has 30/30 complete supported answers, 35/35 citations and 10/10 clean abstentions. Native has 27/30 complete supported answers with one unresolved, 31/35 citations with two unresolved, and 10/10 clean abstentions. Forty unique task clusters underlie the repeated attempts.

All requested factual values and role bindings in the native answers are semantically correct. Q11 and Q29 fail on supporting evidence: their emitted native citation chunks omit the requested facts. Kingy provides the relevant original page-3 and page-4 support for both tasks. These cases show a citation-support advantage on two unique questions; they are not native factual-answer errors.

Native Q23 is complete and source-supported. Its wording “22 minutes after the end of blotting” expresses the requested deadline trigger, and its claimed chunk contains both the rack and reweighing anchors. The frozen matcher leaves that paraphrase unresolved. This is a finite-recognition limitation, not a demonstrated answer error; it stays unresolved in the original results and no alias was added after output.

Native has a concise-answer advantage on Q09, Q13, Q15, Q19 and Q23. It gives the requested role-bound values or current date directly, while Kingy copies additional genuine preparation, inspection, archived-rule or procedure context. Both answers remain factually correct. This observation concerns the actual answer text, not speed, privacy or general usability.

Both workflows cleanly decline all ten wholly absent requests. Every emitted quote is genuine: 50 distinct spans were independently located with original token boundaries in the unchanged PDFs. Genuine quotation alone does not establish task support, which is why the native Q11/Q29 chunks remain deficient.

No original answer, score, alias, question, source or timing field was changed. This audit establishes no broad winner and does not replace installation, security, method-adherence or publication gates. Detailed private per-bundle assessments and the complete 240-attempt mapping are hash-bound in the JSON receipt.