{
  "schemaVersion": "kingy-v20-independent-post-start-transport-amendment-assessment/1.0.0",
  "reviewedAt": "2026-10-18T04:58:10.711856+00:00",
  "scope": "Metadata/source-only assessment while B3 continues; no fresh questions, grading references, answers or native-chat content opened.",
  "freshGradingKeyOpened": false,
  "freshOutputsOpened": false,
  "modelCalls": 0,
  "nativeUiActions": 0,
  "reviewerFilesChanged": false,
  "postStartPreparationTransportAmendmentObserved": true,
  "executedPreparationTransportWhollyUnchanged": false,
  "frozenFileHashesAndExecutedControlPathAreDifferentQuestions": true,
  "knownActualExample": {
    "position": 19,
    "newStockControlSourceSha256": "56d3c4f66f12fa292198a5e6c5f93fce035bf5a22890b3888820fa4d35672175",
    "actualStockDuplicateClicks": 1,
    "returnCode": 0,
    "syntheticOldAckWritten": false,
    "questionSubmissionsInPreparationCall": 0
  },
  "plannedRemainingRouteReportedByRoot": "For remaining21-40, observed supported stock Duplicate once with fresh full canonical/PDF/config/owner/menu guards and sole new native CID proof, omit optional human Rename, then exact unchanged ui.submit/path persistence/pending/capture. Actual use/counts remain to be audited.",
  "substantiveInferenceEquivalenceAssessment": "Exact same five PDF bytes, same first-message factual prompt, frozen loaded model/runtime/RAG/prediction settings, one original Send per new CID, exact target-path prompt persistence and original capture can preserve scientific input and attempt equivalence. No actual inference/scorer/input/answer-retry violation is established by the preparation-route change alone. Actual per-generation/prompt/timing evidence is still required.",
  "frozenMethodAdherenceConcern": {
    "protocolFreezeLanguage": [
      "The method, scorer, source-selection rules, native controls and thresholds are independently reviewed and frozen before a separate agent creates the fresh corpus.",
      "After corpus consumption, code/prompts/settings/source selection/scorer/aliases/pass rules/order stay frozen."
    ],
    "observedDifference": "Additional wrappers and stock GUI preparation control paths were introduced after measurement began. Preserving37 frozen source files does not make these executed transport paths identical to the frozen original preparation.",
    "requiredFinalAdjudication": "The final independent measurement-eligibility review must explicitly adjudicate this operational preparation amendment against the prospective native-controls/code-freeze wording and pre-authorship measurement-integrity gate. Do not substitute all37 hashes pass, input equivalence or a successful automatic seal for that judgment.",
    "noAutomaticGateWaiver": true,
    "wholeProtocolUnchangedClaimPermitted": false
  },
  "finalGateDecisionDeferredUntilActualFullEvidence": true,
  "dataCollectionMayContinueWithoutAdministrativeReviewHold": true,
  "dataCollectionContinuationDoesNotGrantLaunch": true,
  "requiredPublicationDisclosure": "Record all actually affected positions, control source/action hashes, failed normal helper/wrapper actions, stock preparation actions, omitted human naming/shared actual display names, unique actual CIDs and path-persistence checks. Clearly label this as a post-start preparation transport amendment. Distinguish any valid retained inference outcomes from strict prospective method adherence and final release eligibility; if the adherence gate fails, publish evidence/limitations and hold1.5 under the original rules.",
  "sourceSha256": {
    "method/COMPARISON-PROTOCOL.md": "d7a2ecc9f65770cb1fe05c5d6c936f0c5c8a7603ad8d77259e55bb357c8b5474",
    "quality-gate-plan.json": "523fbfc94d7b00c920520e9b8ca07fa482e2c22ddeb7c32d3087fdc48d414408",
    "method-freeze.json": "17a4f68181a07ec77cfb01d583913b66e97c7c6cbac48957addc8d96e2ede556",
    "method/native-ui.mjs": "de41f85c2cf490e682c21c9bce7b8ee87406be5b81b4551cf4425cf083e138a5",
    "method/native-study.mjs": "c2eb99fa6dbb92ac9459b8ff1eebc13ac4f2145563df1ab24a49684fb1ba0f36",
    "sessions/B3/original19-stock-current-menu-duplicate.applescript": "56d3c4f66f12fa292198a5e6c5f93fce035bf5a22890b3888820fa4d35672175",
    "sessions/B3/original19-stock-duplicate-actual-result.json": "9d859474c11dcb1d2d97ce0094ddb4a41a990a96c98b656bbb12d2022e1e1051",
    "independent-validation/B3-existing-path-persistence-route-review.json": "ef3a9d97b05e9c97f39629e3c46ec14d98118a42babe9d6b23653635d35c225b"
  }
}