{ "schemaVersion": "kingy-v20-independent-operational-metadata-review/1.0.0", "reviewedAt": "2026-10-18T04:02:15.494217+00:00", "scope": "Pre-final B1/B2 operational metadata, frozen source hashes and actual backing-file hashes only, while B3 runs. No question, reference, answer, native-chat JSON or graded-output values parsed.", "freshGradingKeyOpened": false, "freshOutputsOpened": false, "nativeConversationContentParsed": false, "modelCalls": 0, "nativeUiActions": 0, "sourceFilesModified": false, "allMetadataChecksPass": true, "checks": [ { "label": "all37 frozen method/candidate sources unchanged", "passed": true }, { "label": "exact reviewed input-integrity receipt bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "preservation manifest binds reviewed input receipt", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/1 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/1 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/2 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/2 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/3 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/3 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/4 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/4 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/5 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/5 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/6 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/6 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/7 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/7 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/8 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/8 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/9 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/9 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/10 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/10 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/11 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/11 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/12 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/12 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/13 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/13 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/14 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/14 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/15 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/15 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/16 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/16 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/17 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/17 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/18 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/18 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/19 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/19 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/20 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/20 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/21 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/21 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/22 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/22 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/23 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/23 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/24 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/24 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/25 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/25 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/26 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/26 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/27 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/27 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/28 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/28 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/29 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/29 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/30 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/30 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/31 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/31 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/32 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/32 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/33 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/33 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/34 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/34 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/35 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/35 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/36 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/36 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/37 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/37 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/38 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/38 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/39 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/39 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/40 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B1/40 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/1 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/1 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/2 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/2 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/3 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/3 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/4 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/4 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/5 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/5 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/6 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/6 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/7 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/7 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/8 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/8 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/9 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/9 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/10 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/10 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/11 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/11 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/12 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/12 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/13 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/13 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/14 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/14 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/15 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/15 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/16 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/16 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/17 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/17 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/18 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/18 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/19 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/19 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/20 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/20 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/21 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/21 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/22 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/22 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/23 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/23 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/24 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/24 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/25 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/25 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/26 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/26 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/27 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/27 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/28 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/28 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/29 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/29 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/30 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/30 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/31 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/31 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/32 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/32 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/33 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/33 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/34 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/34 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/35 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/35 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/36 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/36 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/37 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/37 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/38 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/38 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/39 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/39 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/40 exact retained original bytes", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2/40 five distinct identifiers and frozen hashes", "passed": true }, { "label": "all80 B1/B2 positions exactly once", "passed": true }, { "label": "all400 real and copied PDF backing files agree", "passed": true }, { "label": "all34 named operational metadata receipt hashes match", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2 summary retains40 and no pending/capture/deadline flags", "passed": true }, { "label": "09 recovery metadata proves intended single original and no synthetic ACK", "passed": true }, { "label": "28 records two preparation Duplicates and one original submission", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2 full actual host sample before", "passed": true }, { "label": "B2 full actual host sample complete after", "passed": true }, { "label": "original restricted after sample retained honestly", "passed": true } ], "frozenMethodAndSourceChecks": { "COMPARISON-PROTOCOL.md": true, "PAIRED-ANALYSIS.md": true, "SCORING.md": true, "common_grade.py": true, "consumed-v14-controls.json": true, "engineering-review-followup.json": true, "engineering-review.json": true, "native-control.py": true, "native-duplicate.applescript": true, "native-rename-clone.applescript": true, "native-study.mjs": true, "native-ui.mjs": true, "native-user-template.txt": true, "native_capture.py": true, "paired_analysis.py": true, "postmeasurement.py": true, "prepare_comparison.py": true, "run_kingy_session.py": true, "seal_measurement.py": true, "test_common_grade.py": true, "test_cross_page_repair.py": true, "test_exact_source_repair.py": true, "test_measurement_infrastructure.py": true, "test_native_capture.py": true, "test_native_control.py": true, "test_paired_analysis.py": true, "test_v15_grade.py": true, "workflow-v15-r6/runner.py": true, "workflow-v15-r6/start_server.py": true, "workflow-v15-r6/prepare_model.py": true, "workflow-v15-r6/evaluate.py": true, "workflow-v15-r6/offline.sb": true, "workflow-v15-r6/requirements.txt": true, "workflow-v15-r6/SCORING.md": true, "workflow-v15-r6/README.md": true, "workflow-v15-r6/LICENSE.txt": true, "workflow-v15-r6/common_grade.py": true }, "inputBackingProof": { "originalsHashVerified": 80, "backingFilesHashVerified": 400, "allActualAndPreservedBytesMatch": true, "inputFailures": [], "sourceReceiptSha256": "58f9978e3591c60bd2a460bc6e29b22d7c51344c4820bf21170d3ee2ba26fce2", "originalHashChecks": [ { "session": "B1", "position": 1, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 2, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 3, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 4, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 5, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 6, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 7, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 8, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 9, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 10, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 11, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 12, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 13, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 14, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 15, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 16, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 17, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 18, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 19, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 20, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 21, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 22, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 23, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 24, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 25, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 26, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 27, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 28, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 29, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 30, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 31, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 32, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 33, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 34, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 35, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 36, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 37, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 38, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 39, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B1", "position": 40, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 1, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 2, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 3, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 4, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 5, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 6, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 7, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 8, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 9, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 10, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 11, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 12, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 13, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 14, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 15, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 16, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 17, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 18, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 19, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 20, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 21, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 22, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 23, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 24, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 25, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 26, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 27, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 28, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 29, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 30, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 31, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 32, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 33, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 34, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 35, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 36, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 37, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 38, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 39, "unchanged": true }, { "session": "B2", "position": 40, "unchanged": true } ], "pdfContentParsed": false }, "safeCandidateHashes": { "sessions/B2/original28-native-clone-attachment-hold.json": true, "sessions/B2/original28-readonly-settled-recheck.json": true, "sessions/B2/original28-additional-preparation-before.json": true, "sessions/B2/original28-first-remove-unacknowledged.json": true, "sessions/B2/original28-second-remove-readonly-reconciliation.json": true, "sessions/B2/original28-observed-coordinate-remove.json": true, "sessions/B2/original28-intact-removal-actions.json": true, "sessions/B2/original28-sole-remove-axpress.json": true, "sessions/B2/original28-orphan-removal-hold.json": true, "sessions/B2/original28-additional-duplicate-prechecks.json": true, "sessions/B2/original28-second-preparation-acknowledgment-hold.json": true, "sessions/B2/original28-foreground-diagnosis.json": true, "sessions/B2/original28-neutral-foreground-preflight-failed.json": true, "sessions/B2/original28-neutral-axraise-foreground-preflight.json": true, "sessions/B2/preparation-additional-28.json": true, "sessions/B2/preparation-after-foreground-28.json": true, "sessions/B2/original28-additional-preparation-completion.json": true, "sessions/B2/original09-native-clone-acknowledgment-hold.json": true, "sessions/B2/original09-readonly-readiness.json": true, "sessions/B2/original09-before-model-binding.json": true, "sessions/B2/original09-model-binding-actions.json": true, "sessions/B2/original09-operational-recovery.json": true, "sessions/B2/original09-operational-recovery-completion.json": true, "sessions/B2/input-backing-integrity-all-native-originals.json": true, "sessions/B2/effective-settings-all-originals.json": true, "sessions/B2/timing-all-originals.json": true, "sessions/B2/frozen-source-integrity-after.json": true, "sessions/B2/host-before.json": true, "sessions/B2/host-after.json": true, "sessions/B2/host-after-complete.json": true, "sessions/B2/model-control-cleanup.json": true, "sessions/B2/before.json": true, "sessions/B2/after.json": true, "sessions/B2/session-summary.json": true }, "sourceSha256": { "method-freeze.json": "17a4f68181a07ec77cfb01d583913b66e97c7c6cbac48957addc8d96e2ede556", "comparison-freeze.json": "87fcd2d85a9505f48b0e916ccec56b530816ee23d392ab17e5fa1a4731d14ab3", "sessions/B2/session-summary.json": "21e2e0fe78e7abb2afe45d4067395579366894ed2c2033e4e3bdd424dd6844c7", "sessions/B2/public-safe-receipt-candidates.json": "bd6f1c96e974172e48842c8d695278b4492a09fa2a6011c45e980aaf18fbb2c0", "sessions/B2/original09-operational-recovery.json": "c3deb7c145571c5597a4a19025610227f3fbe022e4438b2e3ebb843fa7c541ee", "sessions/B2/original09-operational-recovery-completion.json": "05bd91856b8d0a3fcdf6f7cf6d6165218cd6f26cf8b64da72fa2922e2172bdcb", "sessions/B2/original28-additional-preparation-completion.json": "47d1e4c8aad958dc8668bf7368623cfb8507cf589cd4d7f13cf5f951a5415e98", "sessions/B2/host-before.json": "6ca4dc7f5601796e0d6e387cec3d294595d1201e9f9e6c00b171acaabadf5631", "sessions/B2/host-after.json": "cc449d8c0f020aba87650a2b01c2a0146cfd03aa6f48c99d78c3795554946897", "sessions/B2/host-after-complete.json": "e3d1ee4783305aeea14eea550ca77b15f971b7c5b0f00895ff36a6edd3084646", "sessions/B2/input-backing-integrity-all-native-originals.json": "58f9978e3591c60bd2a460bc6e29b22d7c51344c4820bf21170d3ee2ba26fce2", "native-input-preservation/manifest.json": "d5be1bd9c2190f73a1daee7683cc20b1eda3086869d12d5bda1563abe4362833", "independent-publication-review/original09-operational-recovery-review.json": "74c891632b933634ca5426d0f74ba917f6ed40cba30de3fd2572b02b936c139d", "independent-publication-review/original28-operational-preparation-review.json": "c3a9606558513932e504238f7634caf55d913a3ae5efec7225f88d1184f2166e", "independent-publication-review/original28-additional-preparation-review.json": "ed68db3b1c3dcdd291c593e8140d47327f868e4e689c3be0014efd1b0713c896", "independent-validation/host-metadata-review.json": "1e6dfedfed11f9c4820695c99a47bf8997984867ba45256d5638342a6be79ea6" }, "operationalJudgments": [ { "issue": "B2 original09 failed acknowledgment after a real successful Duplicate and Rename", "judgment": "Metadata supports protocol-compatible reconciliation of the same existing blank, exact frozen loaded-model binding, one frozen submit and unchanged capture. The failed ACK and real actions remain separately recorded; no new Duplicate or synthetic success ACK was used. Administrative truthful pending state is not an edited native conversation.", "substantiveInputOrAttemptRuleChanged": false, "laterOriginalContentAndTimingVerificationRequired": true }, { "issue": "B2 original28 malformed unsent attachment copy, unsuccessful supported removals, one deliberately new preparation Duplicate", "judgment": "A disclosed additional preparation deviation, compatible in principle with the frozen first-message/five-input/one-original rules. The prior bad draft was fully reconciled to zero messages and no submission before a prospectively reviewed new preparation request. Two actual preparation Duplicate actions and one zero-action foreground failure must remain distinct from one question Send. The successful new request used the complete unchanged coordinator/worker route, five exact PDF byte hashes and all five effective settings groups. No frozen rule expressly limits known unused preparation drafts to one; the prohibition is blind repetition or another question attempt. This does not authorize replacement sessions or a hidden retry.", "purelyReadOnlyIntervention": false, "additionalPreparationDeviation": true, "substantiveInputOrAttemptRuleChanged": false, "laterOriginalContentAndTimingVerificationRequired": true }, { "issue": "B2 restricted first post-session host sample", "judgment": "The restricted sample remains preserved with actual sysctl/thermal errors. A separate truthful full sample was obtained22seconds later, still after original40 and before owned Qwen unload. The protocol does not demand that the first attempted host command succeeds; the later actual after-session sample supplies all required variables without repeating any question. Do not relabel the partial capture as complete.", "actualLaterCompleteAfterSampleAvailable": true }, { "issue": "B1 dedicated before-host capture missing", "judgment": "Prior independent host-metadata-review.json remains applicable: the linked actual A1 after-session sample is the pre-B1 host record with age/phase limitations. No newly measured B1 before sample is claimed." } ], "prospectiveOperationalGateIssues": [], "deferredUntilAllSixFinished": [ "Independently inspect every final native original for one first user message, one original assistant generation, exact frozen question/fields and five PDF byte identities.", "Independently match each original final-answer event uniquely, verify EOS and the90-second boundary, actual model identity and all five effective configuration groups.", "Check every retained output/score/source bundle and all40questions/41claims/30source pages, with no edits to fixed grades or references.", "Check B3 complete host and cleanup receipts and actual session order; no final all240 completion or launch eligibility is granted by this pre-final metadata review." ], "requiredLimitations": [ "Preparation/control interruptions and the B1 host-source reuse are disclosed; this was not an uninterrupted comparison execution.", "Additional import/parse/embedding/cache/preparation work and its exact duration are not fully measured. Qwen output-event logs alone do not prove zero embedding work.", "These control problems do not establish LM Studio product unreliability or a Kingy setup-time, general speed, energy, cost or comparative privacy advantage.", "All host records are point samples on one shared Mac. No continuous thermal or resource stability, human validation, separate-machine reproduction or population performance is established." ], "finalMeasurementCompletionEligibilityAssessed": false, "launchQualificationGranted": false }