{
  "schemaVersion": "kingy-v20-B3-unrenamed-publication-code-review/1.0.0",
  "reviewedAt": "2026-10-18T04:46:56.185307+00:00",
  "study": "comparison-v20",
  "scope": "Code and explicitly named operational metadata only while B3 continues. No native conversation/first user message parsed by this publication reviewer; exact prompt identity statements are retained operational metadata plus frozen-function guard evidence, subject to final independent original-content audit.",
  "preservedBeforeDirectory": "release/comparison-v20/preparation-history/b3-unrenamed-disclosure-20261018T044405411829Z",
  "preservedBeforeSha256": {
    "prepare-report-input.py": "89a06cf9e4efe37b21a0b75e5e906288f919d8a926046504324fab732bfc4e82",
    "build-report.mjs": "4bf4d6caa47e561bf713e4c36e45af025c5122d7d866e7b8776381c06fac29a9",
    "test-report.mjs": "9415d383adc902e1c012045f1e261e7de4141a3df198e1c9ebb0418509a93e00",
    "test-report-input-selection.py": "61b1996992d05a22babc4cc84c53956f6899103c3b25f0304f2dd75bcb4c8cd6"
  },
  "reviewedToolSha256": {
    "prepare-report-input.py": "dc312d8708c9f3a4bd6fec9bb55937a12052cfb192444cd150546efe9dc20adc",
    "build-report.mjs": "9cfc9076b82de4400b17143dd57b2e28e891f7bcea8f341c871b577fde7b72f6",
    "test-report.mjs": "bfc8a922e3de5a631c7c8abc354f59d23fc4d9363bd35d535bcf5c6365fcee5b",
    "test-report-input-selection.py": "dbacb47143a38cabf96283df576f87c31df15ff25605c6a57cfbd4ec9a42de14"
  },
  "explicitSafeOperationalMetadataHashVerified": {
    "independent-validation/B3-identical-menu-failure-prospective-addendum.json": "4a5a022986a319580326af7f5a98e3dd08156b6d590f2e41fee7a14c408a5874",
    "independent-validation/B3-identical-rename-menu-failure-prospective-addendum.json": "2a85b8612e32619be28ab985f52afd6a0a6bdf91f207775dddb7b2ba735fdfa5",
    "independent-validation/B3-original15-additional-stock-name-preparation-review.json": "d740caa12b8b0d5b66103ac4e2f2e7f28a831f89693880fd20b8336f66b9a0d9",
    "sessions/B3/original15-rename-continuation-actual-result.json": "5ab41a7eba644806cd1f7d2baaf92dd3a67e46a06e101a4ddc648204c1967e3e",
    "sessions/B3/original15-stock-name-from-row-result.json": "bf3e4725946762677586fd088a88532b4d8e224e6e5735a23844a9f5a46aafbb",
    "sessions/B3/original15-unrenamed-operational-recovery.json": "923b52fad301bb8fbc3a3410a43118bfb04a772980b939aa628ca919607a90c9",
    "sessions/B3/original15-unrenamed-recovery-completion.json": "c7ed16aa11377a00da8bd5d1ab20cd8713bdfad795379460054ca0dad1b985f5",
    "sessions/B3/original15-frozen-model-binding.json": "afeae4cfe606dc2458eead7809f495a7aa24687bbc56a54cf9ba7baf5625d327",
    "sessions/B3/original15-first-rename-result.json": "7cb32279d4c246c2262aecdb7bef9f7e44df42947042a592483d2c4931f9db64",
    "sessions/B3/original15-continuation-before.json": "0cb122ac326dcb44c6d383536d44a45ff69d09424df3795134365e4d6924920b",
    "sessions/B3/original15-preaction-menu-hold.json": "0f754f3acb5a6ef7630991e88366b478fa26530ac2ae2a0464e4eafe5038787d",
    "sessions/B3/original15-rename-continuation-before.json": "1161f124a0f435ead7a19b5b4220621054fa5811548280f4df5c7e4699c8ef03",
    "sessions/B3/original15-stock-native-name-operation-result.json": "eba8e0b3a282d380239563f83dccc9a5b1206781ba4b28a0c69a92313045a3e3",
    "sessions/B3/original15-continuation-actual-action-result.json": "a78c2f1f61202668dfdc6e5b3ad9b7f1220563b838cea6aa6842b2d67405345f",
    "independent-publication-review/public-safe-operational-reviews/B3-existing-path-persistence-route-review.public.json": "87d1bba4a91dd27ba64aa0cd7802eb642b05a0cb48ecd5761dda1e4c5e402449"
  },
  "boundedMetadataPrivacyFieldIssues": [],
  "publicReviewDerivative": {
    "schemaVersion": "kingy-public-operational-review-derivative/1.0.0",
    "preparedAt": "2026-10-18T04:44:05.414998+00:00",
    "originalFile": "independent-validation/B3-existing-path-persistence-route-review.json",
    "originalSha256": "ef3a9d97b05e9c97f39629e3c46ec14d98118a42babe9d6b23653635d35c225b",
    "originalReviewPreservedUnchanged": true,
    "removedJsonPointer": "/knownOriginal15State/sameNativePath",
    "replacementJsonPointer": "/knownOriginal15State/sameNativeCID",
    "replacementValue": "1792297506398.conversation.json",
    "transformation": "Only the local native directory/path was replaced by its existing native CID basename. All review judgments, conditions, counts, source hashes and eligibility limits are otherwise unchanged. This is a public privacy derivative, not the original review bytes."
  },
  "publicDerivativeReversibleToOriginalExceptDeclaredPrivacyTransformation": true,
  "excludedOriginalMetadata": {
    "independent-validation/B3-existing-path-persistence-route-review.json": {
      "sha256": "ef3a9d97b05e9c97f39629e3c46ec14d98118a42babe9d6b23653635d35c225b",
      "reason": "Original local native path preserved privately; only clearly labeled CID-basename privacy derivative included."
    },
    "sessions/B3/original15-continued-blank-verification.json": {
      "sha256": "f94a2ad7a1429b4b487dc20685980fcab963a96a0e941fe830d33d0dbdddc83d",
      "reason": "newBlankPath contains native user directory."
    },
    "sessions/B3/original15-rename-continuation-proposal.json": {
      "sha256": "44154f1c21722cce301e983949dda09980e751608a68c4c13c9b323d172177cb",
      "reason": "soleNewBlankPath contains native user directory."
    },
    "sessions/B3/original15-stock-naming-reconciled-before.json": {
      "sha256": "6989d7cf77fac0817b9667d28390c8bdc4727d6ecdbb5d4b1dd7f559e49cb575",
      "reason": "sameBlankPath contains native user directory."
    }
  },
  "disclosure": {
    "removedFalseUniversalUniqueHumanNameClaim": true,
    "nativeIdentityBasis": "fresh distinct actual native CID/path and exact first user message",
    "actualOriginal15CID": "1792297506398.conversation.json",
    "uniqueHumanDisplayLabelAchieved": false,
    "actualPreparationDuplicateActions": 1,
    "originalQuestionSubmissions": 1,
    "originalQuestionGenerations": 1,
    "reviewedExistingMenuRenameAXPressDispatched": 1,
    "everyStockAndNativeNamingAttemptRemainsInExactCompletionReceipt": true,
    "allNameValueEdits": 0,
    "allNameReturnCommits": 0,
    "extraDuplicateAfterNamingFailures": 0,
    "exactUnchangedUiSubmitInvokedOnce": true,
    "samePathExactPromptPersistenceGuardEnforcedByFrozenFunction": true,
    "separatePreSendSnapshotRetainedOrClaimed": false,
    "successfulFunctionAndRetainedExactFirstMessageAreGuardEvidence": true,
    "noSyntheticSuccessAcknowledgments": true,
    "extraModelLoadOrWarmup": 0,
    "laterUnrenamedPositionsInferred": false,
    "remainingActualB3PositionsRequireClosureInventory": true,
    "additionalPreparationImportEmbeddingSetupOverhead": "unknown",
    "noCompletionLaunchOrCompetitorReliabilityWaiver": true
  },
  "tests": [
    {
      "name": "metadata-selection",
      "command": [
        "/Users/curtispyke/Documents/ChatGPT/kingy Wiki/implementation/2026-10-13/local-ai-guide/release/comparison-v20/clean-environment/bin/python",
        "/Users/curtispyke/Documents/ChatGPT/kingy Wiki/implementation/2026-10-13/local-ai-guide/release/comparison-v20/test-report-input-selection.py"
      ],
      "exitCode": 0,
      "passedControls": 8,
      "log": "independent-publication-review/b3-unrenamed-disclosure-controls/metadata-selection.txt",
      "sha256": "bcb8168048943122e37c54e84ca5cf049afd07ae19b8077ba0c3f63e0351d792"
    },
    {
      "name": "report-schema",
      "command": [
        "node",
        "--test",
        "/Users/curtispyke/Documents/ChatGPT/kingy Wiki/implementation/2026-10-13/local-ai-guide/release/comparison-v20/test-report.mjs"
      ],
      "exitCode": 0,
      "passedControls": 93,
      "log": "independent-publication-review/b3-unrenamed-disclosure-controls/report-schema.txt",
      "sha256": "7a7e2e77e23a71cf30f7fed0a9526b6b8d634853932098c88371c403a88fc70d"
    },
    {
      "name": "packaging-private-synthetic",
      "command": [
        "/Users/curtispyke/Documents/ChatGPT/kingy Wiki/implementation/2026-10-13/local-ai-guide/release/comparison-v20/clean-environment/bin/python",
        "/Users/curtispyke/Documents/ChatGPT/kingy Wiki/implementation/2026-10-13/local-ai-guide/release/comparison-v20/test-publication-tools.py"
      ],
      "exitCode": 0,
      "passedControls": 9,
      "log": "independent-publication-review/b3-unrenamed-disclosure-controls/packaging-private-synthetic.txt",
      "sha256": "6d2145ca9dcd419cddf80a017196081db699bc55008cd3bf2edc35caf5f5a9bc"
    }
  ],
  "passedSyntheticControls": 110,
  "frozenMethodAndCandidateSourcePinsVerifiedUnchanged": {
    "method/COMPARISON-PROTOCOL.md": "d7a2ecc9f65770cb1fe05c5d6c936f0c5c8a7603ad8d77259e55bb357c8b5474",
    "method/PAIRED-ANALYSIS.md": "cc09572414393b465dc5cc3388272c2027a2c423d0ab1b729e6f9fa255f32282",
    "method/SCORING.md": "2d0b2201a894bb663f5f71a6c2464bcf7d53138b84b83de153ed9bf18f553259",
    "method/common_grade.py": "e9b95ce6b5a821c0ab703c60de388f7604d919d62cfe13ac544cfbcb95c14c5f",
    "method/consumed-v14-controls.json": "2d7971b4f92c22712b837ac60ca8b702a56ff41c0748f70188d53df1bb10e9af",
    "method/engineering-review-followup.json": "e85921ff15eda64b052df7d331844719295616ad36a43b5ebb47e757ec6782d3",
    "method/engineering-review.json": "1563d64d3f8a757d19c9029af15cb749dc44d7f245994289916cee91998b63eb",
    "method/native-control.py": "dd552d5bca14227be3833dcd63687ac9154aafd29a40f4813b929229682cfc4a",
    "method/native-duplicate.applescript": "15df26771ac91a43ed44554affa5f358a0f39581d55ca2e6b4921b8ceef4ed6f",
    "method/native-rename-clone.applescript": "1b271b307c49b92a085cfb38cb2f5a3cf9ac7fb75d5aae02371b72e99fcb07a6",
    "method/native-study.mjs": "c2eb99fa6dbb92ac9459b8ff1eebc13ac4f2145563df1ab24a49684fb1ba0f36",
    "method/native-ui.mjs": "de41f85c2cf490e682c21c9bce7b8ee87406be5b81b4551cf4425cf083e138a5",
    "method/native-user-template.txt": "6445968866a12a80297f52f1c97afe07ce1b425d349544f648a2faf294943b5e",
    "method/native_capture.py": "5517b3dcf7dee4dc4fcf209e05961c967b68d1eba212a37fc7fac0fcca3a4556",
    "method/paired_analysis.py": "3f9d31a285e55d6c5c83b360b5e2d36e174733470e9ce2638e5ef3c444be6ca5",
    "method/postmeasurement.py": "a11a2dd93ff574bd55ccc39cc92bbcb15079028e73c169790496cff3b43e4e41",
    "method/prepare_comparison.py": "485c071e983d7707e767b5dd80d509e08a294f444296caab466086823f66a784",
    "method/run_kingy_session.py": "e21d7c97bc87407370f87ae3184d4d247998dc6d4cbee024d7ba225186a68909",
    "method/seal_measurement.py": "2c0e10682d92512f5405284c7141d6700a4ba7a716d3873f0b43760279de6144",
    "method/test_common_grade.py": "a2872ad08989bcd713b7e0f1cf31609b7415ccdb342e229290209b7b4c729102",
    "method/test_cross_page_repair.py": "2bd6d99cab35b4ef42412238a1a4e8ea0e7c59243e6b5dee4675c2864d262a50",
    "method/test_exact_source_repair.py": "7600bf0c9503438ab32ce290721af740584619eb69e71de2b393731e5bb758d8",
    "method/test_measurement_infrastructure.py": "f89e921117704375fa5e01c5c0bede2e986342e6576672de0bba3da9b5a49b49",
    "method/test_native_capture.py": "f0178f50d665e5e523c549f1b6247b003f45eb6773452ea90b731f7a52e4e490",
    "method/test_native_control.py": "f504e1f32f60e57b445f744d9a385bfb20472b26cbbb1abb5bb1d7b0b9f88354",
    "method/test_paired_analysis.py": "2a87d8a6627563a01321a9f56846f009ba7c8d6c3ac50413e7490ca14fd2825f",
    "method/test_v15_grade.py": "607b412a1f015cfd4ba4921ccc867663c97900632a2c0ab2acc328c1b3428bfb",
    "workflow-v15-r6/runner.py": "ac8d1ccb48ebe017f7e2794392598967695ef3186fcf4d3889dfd579e8479458",
    "workflow-v15-r6/start_server.py": "7f54900199a61c495bf5f6753a5caa13b529f86061d56ec2fca5a63be3844b2a",
    "workflow-v15-r6/prepare_model.py": "2a66acb34c1bf136b087179dbc2c5f676156bb31d971ed33b82b05e77c12f576",
    "workflow-v15-r6/evaluate.py": "8daa63c6ceb93111fd898683d40712a414ebda0fdf08b6a165638250871e4152",
    "workflow-v15-r6/offline.sb": "e5462ef1daae3785012cb8e4fa05b89105bf4ac4d98be9580a8c357365a4f54f",
    "workflow-v15-r6/requirements.txt": "3ec8922905dc4e3a10c3b46bd7fba023c37ffc309d51c6bed2a13ec3e98177fd",
    "workflow-v15-r6/SCORING.md": "2d0b2201a894bb663f5f71a6c2464bcf7d53138b84b83de153ed9bf18f553259",
    "workflow-v15-r6/README.md": "b6be0bf726188ef1a87ddfde1165a3bb929bf9b4b638e5b222dd94eb73d3f321",
    "workflow-v15-r6/LICENSE.txt": "7b5272ed8db5e81567ea2a9624ab25c04db44dc168db692c760a61f4d392100c",
    "workflow-v15-r6/common_grade.py": "e9b95ce6b5a821c0ab703c60de388f7604d919d62cfe13ac544cfbcb95c14c5f"
  },
  "launchGateRequirementSourceLineUnchanged": true,
  "frozenSourceOrNativeFilesEditedByReviewer": false,
  "freshQuestionAnswerReferenceOrGradingKeyRead": false,
  "nativeConversationOrRawAXRead": false,
  "broadStudyJsonScan": false,
  "fullPublicArtifactPrivacyCheckPerformed": false,
  "actualReportOrPackageBuilt": false,
  "modelCalls": 0,
  "nativeUiActions": 0,
  "productionWrites": 0,
  "finalStudyEligibilityConcluded": false,
  "launchQualificationGranted": false,
  "outstanding": "B3 final closure inventory and all240 independent original-content/EOS/unique90-second final-event, effective-setting/source/scoring/privacy/installation/launch checks."
}