{
  "schemaVersion": "kingy-v20-independent-B3-identical-rename-menu-failure-prospective-addendum/1.0.0",
  "study": "comparison-v20",
  "prospectivePatternAuthority": true,
  "conditionallyPermissible": true,
  "scope": "B3 original15 and later still-unsubmitted scheduled originals only when the first frozen Rename invocation has provably failed at the exact focused-More-menu acknowledgment guard after its popup but before any Rename AXPress, value edit or Return commit. This does not authorize another Duplicate or recovery from a later uncertain Rename action.",
  "freshGradingKeyOpened": false,
  "freshOutputsOpened": false,
  "nativeConversationContentParsedByReviewer": false,
  "reviewerModelCalls": 0,
  "reviewerNativeUiActions": 0,
  "sourceOrProtocolChangePermitted": false,
  "finalCompletionEligibilityGranted": false,
  "launchQualificationGranted": false,
  "classification": "Disclosed partial-action transport recovery: existing exact clone menu, new owned foreground preparation prefix, then the complete verbatim frozen Rename menu loop and Rename/input/value/Return tail. Not an unchanged full invocation of the original popup-and-Rename helper.",
  "reviewedWrapper": {
    "path": "sessions/B3/original15-existing-menu-rename-continuation.applescript",
    "sha256": "7485ed68be54c51ebe526c9fdae02134695e023fc51c9e0a6603600ab9259f10",
    "frozenRenameSourceSha256": "1b271b307c49b92a085cfb38cb2f5a3cf9ac7fb75d5aae02371b72e99fcb07a6",
    "frozenFunctionsVerbatimVerified": true,
    "frozenFunctionsSha256": "3b03a92bf2d4ce79131ac326568842d19c49e67bca7112944c0beb986123b76d",
    "entireFrozenEightSecondLoopAndRenameTailVerbatimVerified": true,
    "entireFrozenEightSecondLoopAndRenameTailSha256": "f87a5ae939786921c2baaf804da254d0e0dd6069aa16bbd746012f5b570615a4",
    "positionSpecificLiteralPresent": false,
    "newPrefix": "Checks owned PID, exact old/new owned-name arguments, fresh at-most60-second action deadline, unique unminimized LM Studio window and observed AXRaise; normal owned Raise/foreground assignment followed by current NSWorkspace ownership. Then the unchanged frozen fragment executes.",
    "retainedGuards": [
      "Complete bounded native inventory, no second menu, sole More options menu identical to AXFocusedUIElement",
      "Exactly one direct Rename and one direct Duplicate, both enabled",
      "Unchanged focused menu, Rename AXPress availability, current owned foreground and action deadline before Rename",
      "After Rename, exactly focused AXTextField with its actual value equal to expectedName",
      "Current owned foreground and unchanged focused input before one value edit and foreground Return"
    ],
    "popupStatements": 0,
    "duplicateStatements": 0,
    "renameAXPressStatements": 1,
    "renameValueEditStatements": 1,
    "renameReturnCommitStatements": 1,
    "questionPromptSendOrModelStatements": 0,
    "maximumContinuationInvocationsPerScheduledPosition": 1,
    "modifiedCopiesOrWeakerGuardsPermitted": false,
    "copiedFailureMessageIsNotAnActualPopupActionCount": true
  },
  "reviewedCurrentOriginal15Evidence": {
    "proposalPath": "sessions/B3/original15-rename-continuation-proposal.json",
    "proposalSha256": "44154f1c21722cce301e983949dda09980e751608a68c4c13c9b323d172177cb",
    "recordedAt": "2026-10-18T04:26:38.542360+00:00",
    "firstRenameResultPath": "sessions/B3/original15-first-rename-result.json",
    "privateFailureTextSha256": "78545401a21ac20d2f4eaebf51fb80f4198682af7c2962af11f90b739cd43fcc",
    "nullCountersInInitialFailureReceiptNotTreatedAsZeroProof": true,
    "positiveBoundaryProof": "The later safe proposal explicitly binds the literal first frozen Rename failure to its menu acknowledgment guard before direct Rename AXPress; it records zero prior Rename actions, value edits and commits. The frozen source places that guard before all three statements.",
    "actualPriorRenameActions": 0,
    "actualPriorRenameValueEdits": 0,
    "actualPriorRenameCommits": 0,
    "actualPhysicalDuplicateActions": 1,
    "actualQuestion15Submissions": 0,
    "soleNewBlankSha256": "79600caa65832b9936bcf8472d9397ee77a9169c4452467bf10d2822e9d1e021",
    "blankMessages": 0,
    "blankInputLength": 0,
    "fiveFrozenBackingHashesAndNineConfigurationKeysMatch": true,
    "uniqueOriginal15NameAbsent": true,
    "priorRetained": 14,
    "pending": null,
    "modelIoEvents": 30,
    "modelIoSha256": "1e742ef0ef1d1c4c0cddad80eb439218973a546fdb6080081d3855d83c66a448",
    "currentObservedMoreRenameDuplicateCounts": [
      1,
      1,
      1
    ],
    "currentMenuProvenance": "The first frozen Rename helper checked the newest clone row/current generic Copy identity before opening this existing menu; no subsequent UI action is reported.",
    "workerStopped": true,
    "liveReadinessStillMustBeRecheckedBeforeAction": true,
    "firstRenameResultSha256": "7cb32279d4c246c2262aecdb7bef9f7e44df42947042a592483d2c4931f9db64"
  },
  "mandatoryPatternAndPrechecksBeforeEachUse": [
    "Preserve the failed original Rename request/result/private diagnostic hashes. Positively establish the exact pre-Rename menu acknowledgment failure boundary. Missing/null counters, a generic failure status or unchanged title alone do not establish zero prior Rename action.",
    "Exactly one physical Duplicate has produced one known newly created clone for this scheduled original. It remains generic Copy, zero messages/empty draft, exact configuration9 and exactly five distinct frozen PDF byte hashes. Its native path/row lineage is preserved. No second Duplicate is authorized, even if Rename recovery fails.",
    "The existing observed single More menu belongs to that clone's first frozen Rename popup, not the canonical template or another same-named generic copy. Tie it to the original helper's verified current row and sole new native path; do not infer ownership from a generic Copy title alone.",
    "Verify exact frozen source/wrapper/config/canonical hashes, same owned GUI process and model session, all prior original hashes/log prefix unchanged, planned next position, pendingnull, no current question generation, absent unique target name and no native additions except the sole verified clone. Confirm no external or concurrent GUI/control work.",
    "The old-name argument equals the actual clone name. The new-name argument is exactly the scheduled unique Kingy v20 B3 original NN name and is absent elsewhere. The caller records these name checks without inserting a question draft.",
    "Write a new case-specific fresh pre-action receipt binding this addendum hash, exact wrapper hash, failed result/error boundary, zero prior Rename/value/commit, one prior Duplicate, clone/config/PDF/blank/menu provenance, old/new names, prior originals/log prefix and intended one Rename continuation. Stop the normal worker/coordinator before action."
  ],
  "authorizedNarrowSequence": [
    "Execute the exact reviewed existing wrapper once with a fresh bounded deadline and truthful owned old/new names. It issues no popup or Duplicate. Every original menu, focus, action, foreground, deadline and exact old-name input guard must pass before its corresponding action. No caller may weaken a guard or substitute coordinates/typing for this path.",
    "Preserve the real wrapper return/error privately and hash it into a separate actual partial-action receipt. Do not manufacture a full original helper success ACK, overwrite a failed result or attribute a popup to this continuation. A literal successful Rename-tail return is evidence only of its real actions, not a rerun of the original helper.",
    "On any failure or uncertain acknowledgment, stop and read-only reconcile the existing clone/input/name. This authority permits no second continuation call, repeated Rename/value edit/Return, new popup or another Duplicate for that case. A failure after Rename AXPress is outside this typed recovery pattern.",
    "After success, verify the same clone has exactly the intended unique persisted name, still zero messages/empty draft, exact five PDF hashes/config9, canonical unchanged, prior originals/log prefix unchanged and pendingnull. Bind only the already loaded frozen Qwen via the exact existing selector branch if needed; no load, warmup or setting change.",
    "Repeat full actual selected-title/model/visible five-preview-and-remove/no-Stop/blank/input readiness, derive the scheduled prompt only from frozen question-only/template inputs, and write truthful coordinator-compatible pending with recovery provenance. Exact exported frozen ui.submit runs once. On submission uncertainty capture/reconcile that same original, never resubmit.",
    "Use a new unchanged coordinator for capture only of that existing original. Check first-message-only, one original generation, exact prompt/PDF bytes, actual five effective setting groups, EOS and unique final-answer timing within90seconds. Retain all evidence and actual popup/Rename/value/Return/Send counts per affected position for the final independent audit."
  ],
  "notAuthorized": [
    "Any new physical Duplicate or new model session, load, warmup, setting, prompt, source, scorer, reference alias, schedule or gate change.",
    "Generic recovery after an uncertain Rename AXPress, input edit, Return or question Send; those require read-only reconciliation and are excluded here.",
    "Automatic wrapper retries, fabricated helper ACKs, direct native conversation/user-file/vendor-code edits, hidden failed evidence or any other error pattern."
  ],
  "protocolJudgment": "The frozen single-original contract concerns the first and sole submitted question with exact inputs/settings. An already created blank whose first Rename never crossed the pre-action guard can complete that first Rename through the same full original guards without duplicating a question or modifying frozen sources. Position-independent typed reuse avoids repeated review of identical code, while every case still requires fresh evidence and one invocation maximum. This remains a disclosed transport intervention; final actual source/settings/timing/completion and score-validity gates are unchanged.",
  "requiredDisclosure": "For each affected position, publish actual failed popup count, pre-Rename boundary, one continuation Rename/value edit/Return if issued, loaded-model binding, sole question Send/generation and evidence hashes. Preserve unsuccessful helper results and case-specific prechecks. Do not claim uninterrupted preparation, product unreliability, setup-time/general speed superiority or zero extra embedding/cache work from these controls.",
  "actualFinalAll240EligibilityStillRequiresIndependentAudit": true,
  "reviewedAt": "2026-10-18T04:27:48.162256+00:00"
}