{
  "schemaVersion": "kingy-v20-independent-B3-original06-prospective-operational-review/1.0.0",
  "study": "comparison-v20",
  "system": "B",
  "repetition": 3,
  "scheduledPosition": 6,
  "reviewScope": "Prospective transport recovery only. Reviewed frozen control/protocol code and safe operational metadata before any physical Duplicate or question submission for original06. No fresh question, answer, reference, grading key or native conversation content was parsed.",
  "freshGradingKeyOpened": false,
  "freshOutputsOpened": false,
  "nativeConversationContentParsed": false,
  "reviewerModelCalls": 0,
  "reviewerNativeUiActions": 0,
  "frozenSourcesModified": false,
  "conditionallyPermissible": true,
  "currentLiveReadinessGrantedByReviewer": false,
  "finalCompletionEligibilityGranted": false,
  "launchQualificationGranted": false,
  "classification": "Disclosed partial-action transport recovery using the already open canonical More menu; a new guarded wrapper precedes the verbatim frozen Duplicate tail. This is not a complete unchanged invocation of the original two-action helper.",
  "observedMetadata": {
    "retainedB3Originals": 5,
    "pending": null,
    "qwenModelIoEvents": 12,
    "qwenModelIoBytes": 90580,
    "qwenModelIoSha256": "19780d9d9d4e12a3ac407e14ae585b4bdad0ff48f917325707f29e68e7826af6",
    "actualPriorPopupActionsForOriginal06": 2,
    "actualPriorDuplicateActionsForOriginal06": 0,
    "actualPriorQuestionSubmissionsForOriginal06": 0,
    "newNativeConversationsAfterFailedRequests": 0,
    "failedRequestIds": [
      "a7c8e16a-98c2-4a80-9882-e3bb063a8bca",
      "b44e9478-8525-4a81-aa4a-b85be275ca6a"
    ],
    "failureBoundary": "Each failed frozen invocation issued its canonical More-popup AXPress, then failed the exact focused-menu acknowledgment guard before the sole Duplicate AXPress statement.",
    "firstMenuCorrection": "Observed Cancel actions did not dismiss the first menu; a foreground-guarded Escape did. Normal canonical row preparation then preceded the latest popup invocation.",
    "currentMenuProvenanceReportedByNativeOwner": "The latest exact canonical-row popup. No subsequent native action occurred except stopping the worker; intervening work was read-only metadata/source preparation.",
    "metadataIsNotAReplacementForFreshPreActionChecks": true
  },
  "reviewedScript": {
    "path": "sessions/B3/original06-existing-menu-continuation.applescript",
    "sha256": "7d5064931f30ab4ec9ce62b00e80c0dbb3411cefb54af61958ec21551ead8f30",
    "frozenSourceSha256": "15df26771ac91a43ed44554affa5f358a0f39581d55ca2e6b4921b8ceef4ed6f",
    "frozenFunctionsVerbatimVerified": true,
    "frozenFunctionsSha256": "fc1be313e55af1a410a001ad5f4ac0ff2fe1ef55a5bce54cc06b59a116869aa4",
    "finalDuplicateTailVerbatimVerified": true,
    "finalDuplicateTailSha256": "981840a35a60f8c2420134b814404a9a97fcd1123e63648a537189b4f8b8919c",
    "newPrefix": "Requires owned PID, fresh at-most60-second deadline, unique LM Studio window, unminimized state and observed AXRaise; performs normal owned-window raise/foreground assignment, then requires current NSWorkspace ownership, complete bounded inventory, exactly one AXMenu named More options identical to AXFocusedUIElement, one direct Duplicate and one direct Rename, both enabled.",
    "verbatimTailGuards": [
      "AXFocusedUIElement still equals that sole menu",
      "Duplicate exposes AXPress",
      "NSWorkspace frontmost PID still equals the owned process",
      "Fresh action deadline has not expired",
      "Exactly one physical Duplicate AXPress statement"
    ],
    "additionalPopupPressStatements": 0,
    "physicalDuplicateStatements": 1,
    "renamePromptSendModelStatements": 0,
    "copiedHeaderCommentIsNotAnActualActionCount": true
  },
  "requiredSequence": [
    "Stop the ordinary worker/coordinator for original06 and ensure no concurrent GUI control, external input, model load, warmup or next() is running. Reverify the owned PID/executable and exact frozen source/config hashes.",
    "Before this one call, reverify canonical template SHA5f9f4eddafb1e6717f3f38528cb46fbc9ff87623f4b336dc4360ecebfd581aa0, its exact current canonical name/selected source row, configuration9 and all five distinct frozen backing PDF hashes. Verify that the existing observed More menu is the latest canonical-row popup, not a different chat or source menu. If its provenance cannot be established, stop; do not weaken the menu guards.",
    "Reverify retained5 original hashes, pendingnull, the exact unchanged12-event Qwen log prefix, absence of the unique original06 name and absence of any new native conversation since original05. Preserve both failed request/jobs/ACKs/private diagnostics and the prior corrective action counts. Do not overwrite an old failed ACK or create a fabricated successful worker ACK.",
    "Write an actual pre-action recovery receipt with genuine current time, the reviewed script hash, current precondition results, both failed request lineages, zero prior Duplicate/Send, intended one Duplicate and zero popup/Rename/prompt/Send/model actions for this call.",
    "Execute the exact reviewed script once with a fresh bounded deadline. Its existing focus/menu/foreground/deadline guards must all succeed in that same call before one Duplicate AXPress. No further popup action is permitted by this continuation. If any guard fails or acknowledgment is uncertain, preserve the result and perform read-only reconciliation; do not automatically rerun this call or issue another Duplicate.",
    "Record the real call result and raw-diagnostic hashes separately as partial-action recovery evidence. Its literal frozen tail return does not justify manufacturing a full original worker acknowledgment or claiming that this call issued a popup. The failed original acknowledgments remain failed.",
    "Before any Rename or question, reconcile exactly one new native blank, correct generic Copy title, zero messages/empty draft, five distinct native identifiers containing exactly the frozen five PDF byte hashes, configuration9 unchanged, canonical unchanged, and no new Qwen request. On extra/missing/ambiguous state, stop without repeating Duplicate.",
    "Perform the first unique original06 Rename using the exact frozen rename helper/current observed new row identity, retaining its real acknowledgment and one-value/one-commit action counts. Never repeat an uncertain Rename blindly. Bind only the already owned loaded Qwen using the exact frozen selector branch if necessary while the draft remains blank; no new model session, load, warmup or prediction-setting change.",
    "Reverify selected unique original06 title, loaded Qwen, five visible previews/five removal controls, no Stop, zero messages/empty input, five exact PDF hashes/config9, unchanged previous originals/log prefix and pendingnull before deriving the scheduled question-only prompt from exact frozen inputs. Root and this reviewer keep the grading key closed.",
    "Use a truthful submission-prepared pending record with the original coordinator fields and explicit transport-recovery provenance, then call the exact exported frozen ui.submit once. Retain its actual returned submission boundary. If submission is uncertain, persist that uncertainty and capture/reconcile the same original only; never resubmit.",
    "Persist the real submitted pending state and instantiate the unchanged coordinator for capture only of this same original. Validate first-message-only, one original generation, all five actual effective setting groups, EOS and the unique final-answer event within90seconds before continuing original07. Final independent audit must repeat the original-content/timing/source checks after all measurement ends.",
    "Publish the actual prior two popup attempts, neutral corrective actions, one conditional Duplicate continuation, first Rename/binding, sole submission and exact evidence lineage. Mark this as a transport/preparation intervention. No product reliability, uninterrupted-session timing, setup-time or general speed advantage follows. Extra embedding/import/cache work is not excluded merely by a Qwen log prefix."
  ],
  "protocolJudgment": "The frozen protocol prohibits blind repetition of uncertain Duplicate/Send actions and explicitly requires reconciliation. The two original helper failures have been localized before any Duplicate, with no added chat or original06 submission. Continuing a known existing canonical menu through the same substantive focus/foreground/deadline guards can complete the first physical Duplicate without a question retry, altered input, model session, setting, prompt or scorer. This is a transparent transport deviation rather than an edited frozen source or a substitute answer attempt. Conditional permission for this narrow recovery does not waive any final completion or qualification gate.",
  "stopConditions": [
    "Any mismatch in frozen source/config/canonical/PDF bytes, owned PID/current menu provenance, retained original/log prefix, pending state or absent unique original06 blocks the action.",
    "Any failure of exact sole focused menu, direct enabled actions, current foreground, action availability or fresh deadline blocks Duplicate. No weaker focus/coordinate path is approved.",
    "Uncertain Duplicate/Rename/Send acknowledgment requires read-only reconciliation of the same existing native state, never an automatic repeated action or synthetic success record.",
    "Any substantive configuration change, extra question generation or replacement model session fails the declared single-original method; preserve it and hold rather than revise the protocol."
  ],
  "sourceSha256": {
    "method/native-duplicate.applescript": "15df26771ac91a43ed44554affa5f358a0f39581d55ca2e6b4921b8ceef4ed6f",
    "method/native-rename-clone.applescript": "1b271b307c49b92a085cfb38cb2f5a3cf9ac7fb75d5aae02371b72e99fcb07a6",
    "method/native-control.py": "dd552d5bca14227be3833dcd63687ac9154aafd29a40f4813b929229682cfc4a",
    "method/native-ui.mjs": "de41f85c2cf490e682c21c9bce7b8ee87406be5b81b4551cf4425cf083e138a5",
    "method/native-study.mjs": "c2eb99fa6dbb92ac9459b8ff1eebc13ac4f2145563df1ab24a49684fb1ba0f36",
    "method/COMPARISON-PROTOCOL.md": "d7a2ecc9f65770cb1fe05c5d6c936f0c5c8a7603ad8d77259e55bb357c8b5474",
    "sessions/B3/original06-preaction-menu-recovery.json": "40ed34da19885b1ff77f00f648c8ea1397e990a202b2d9a5a36e0668c15a9239",
    "sessions/B3/original06-second-menu-acknowledgment-hold.json": "f65fd7abcfca8286c491bf46caba085d6586159f77c024396f5db6e4466186cc",
    "sessions/B3/original06-continuation-proposal.json": "4d01a4b4798d1268f2cd0c0272c930977a77b4f80b68ff851ad0221fedaddcf8",
    "sessions/B3/original06-existing-menu-continuation.applescript": "7d5064931f30ab4ec9ce62b00e80c0dbb3411cefb54af61958ec21551ead8f30"
  }
}