{
  "schemaVersion": "kingy-v20-independent-original09-operational-recovery-review/1.0.0",
  "reviewedAt": "2026-10-18T03:03:44.959546+00:00",
  "study": "comparison-v20",
  "system": "B",
  "repetition": 2,
  "scheduledPosition": 9,
  "freshCorpusQuestionsAnswersReferencesOrKeyRead": false,
  "rawAxRead": false,
  "modelCalls": 0,
  "nativeUiActions": 0,
  "productionWrites": 0,
  "nativeOrFrozenSourceFilesEdited": false,
  "launchQualificationGranted": false,
  "currentLiveReadinessAssessed": false,
  "sourcePinsVerifiedUnchanged": {
    "native-ui.mjs": "de41f85c2cf490e682c21c9bce7b8ee87406be5b81b4551cf4425cf083e138a5",
    "native-study.mjs": "c2eb99fa6dbb92ac9459b8ff1eebc13ac4f2145563df1ab24a49684fb1ba0f36",
    "native-control.py": "dd552d5bca14227be3833dcd63687ac9154aafd29a40f4813b929229682cfc4a",
    "COMPARISON-PROTOCOL.md": "d7a2ecc9f65770cb1fe05c5d6c936f0c5c8a7603ad8d77259e55bb357c8b5474"
  },
  "safeOperationalInputSha256": {
    "original09-native-clone-acknowledgment-hold.json": "8c84f239436cba8f2af7f13ba31a4058ecfdc26bba6c10492f376b853c08fa3c",
    "original09-readonly-readiness.json": "cabe61cdb888d1912e2f30038edb6280ed2ee355d58af8a053d4f8788d14d515"
  },
  "observedSafeMetadata": {
    "retainedOriginals": 8,
    "modelLogEvents": 18,
    "pending": null,
    "historicalDuplicateAcknowledged": true,
    "historicalRenameAcknowledged": true,
    "failedOriginalAckRetained": true,
    "soleVerifiedBlankCloneFileName": "1792292319440.conversation.json",
    "blankCloneSha256": "5d78741eda905be2cdcd1014b3ecb6e0f475d1f9e11a2c6fb4f1f69fcdd568a4",
    "noOriginal09ModelRequests": true,
    "readinessIsPriorSnapshotNotFreshLiveProof": true
  },
  "recommendedRoute": "Read-only reconciliation, exact existing frozen already-loaded-model selector branch if needed while blank, then exact exported frozen ui.submit once on that same original09; unchanged coordinator resumes capture using its truthful pending record.",
  "rejectedRoute": {
    "proposal": "Create a fresh clone request and return a successful Duplicate ACK for the older action.",
    "reason": "Frozen clone requires this fresh requestId and duplicateActions===1. The recovery has zero new Duplicate actions. A truthful0 fails the check; reporting1 from historical lineage silently changes the per-request acknowledgment scope. Do not manufacture or replace a success ACK to satisfy that check. Preserve the failed original ACK."
  },
  "requiredSequence": [
    "Native owner stops the normal duplicate worker and ensures no concurrent study.next/clone call is running for09. Preserve failed original request/job/ACK, exact blank clone and prior pending-null bytes. Do not issue a new duplicate request.",
    "Reconcile the unique current clone identity/name/path against original request9b7cd68b-3aff-4cd9-aedd-a9af167cd059 and the actual acknowledged Duplicate+Rename results. Exactly one original09 exists; no second original09, no completed native09 snapshot, eight retained originals and a null pending record remain.",
    "Before any prompt/pending mutation, verify same owned GUI/model process, frozen method/control config pins, empty backing messages and input, exact five distinct native attachment byte hashes and nine configuration keys, selected original09, five visible previews/removes and no Stop control. Verify recorded18-event model-log prefix unchanged and no new question/model request.",
    "If buttonqwen3-4b is absent, use only the exact existing frozen clone branch selecting the uniquely listed Currently Loaded qwen3-4b. Do not load another model, change settings, generate a neutral response or create a chat. Keep prompt empty. Record actual UI binding actions separately from Duplicate/Send/model inference.",
    "After model binding and before pending or setValue, repeat selected-title, buttonqwen3-4b, five-preview/five-remove, no-Stop, zero-message/empty-input, five-byte-hash/config9 and unique-clone checks. Model log remains the same18-event prefix with no extra inference. Record pre/post native hashes and any actual binding bookkeeping differences; never rewrite native backing JSON.",
    "The native owner derives the scheduled09 question and prompt from exact frozen question-only/schedule/template inputs using the unchanged coordinator expressions; root remains blind. Record hashes/provenance without exposing question text to this reviewer. Preserve a pre-action recovery receipt explicitly stating zero new Duplicate actions, one historical acknowledged Duplicate, one historical Rename, failed ACK unchanged, exact frozen selector/submit source pins and intended one submission.",
    "Write a truthful pending submission-prepared record for this same clone using the original coordinator fields/position/repetition/prompt and genuine current preparation time. This is administrative state, not a synthetic native conversation or success ACK. Add an explicit preparationRecovery provenance reference.",
    "Call the exact exported createNativeUi(...).submit(existingClone, exactFrozenPrompt) once. Retain its actual returned submittedBefore boundary. Mirror frozen submission error handling: persist submission-uncertain and stop/reconcile if any call is uncertain; never blindly repeat Send.",
    "Persist the actual returned submitted pending record. Reinstantiate the unmodified coordinator forB2; its constructor must recognize eight originals and the same scheduled pending09. Its next() now only completes/captures that submitted original. Do not call a fresh clone or resubmit. Continue original10 only after09 is retained through unchanged capture.",
    "Publish this operational recovery and exact affected boundary after measurement. Preserve all prior originals, failed ACKs, helpers, pending-state history, native snapshots and model log events. Final audit independently checks first-message-only prompt/settings, unique complete final-answer timing, no retries and all240-completion eligibility. Do not imply an uninterrupted session or competitor reliability defect."
  ],
  "exactFrozenLoadedModelSelectorFragmentSha256": "6f218a10c720052d97ae5761a6facea8fddd8c743dbd9a4d1689109f164ce203",
  "stopConditions": [
    "Any additional or nonempty original09, changed field/question/template/config/PDF/source pins, selected-chat ambiguity, missing loaded Qwen, unexpected model work, uncertain Send, or source mismatch requires a hold and read-only reconciliation.",
    "If the existing loaded model cannot be selected by the exact frozen branch while the chat remains blank, do not type a prompt.",
    "This review approves only the conditional operational route; it does not assert current live readiness or waive any final validity/completion/quality/public gate."
  ],
  "protocolBasis": "The frozen completion/interruption section expressly requires read-only reconciliation of uncertain duplicate/send actions and prohibits blind repetition. The real original09 blank chat already exists. No candidate, prompt, settings, scoring rule or frozen source change is needed for its first and only submission."
}