{
  "reviewer": "independent_v19",
  "completed_at_utc": "2026-10-15T20:25:06.156470+00:00",
  "runner_sha256": "911298ba21797fe0704874ed85c8f306193de2a69d130ea7ebb32b18bb9064f7",
  "previous_runner_sha256": "9b35ea2c71862e90755147054e35f1e0c0222f82ef2239908fb0442a32b0d632",
  "verdict": "PASS engineering acceptance for fresh comparison freeze; no launch qualification",
  "change_review": "Only token normalization triggers/triggered/triggering to trigger differs from independently reviewed r6; no values or references added.",
  "static_controls": {
    "passed": 24,
    "failed": 0
  },
  "source_support_audit": {
    "answerable_questions": 30,
    "all_required_support_available": true,
    "unknown_cases_not_evaluated_by_support_audit": 10
  },
  "targeted_r7_model_run": {
    "questions": 9,
    "passed": 9,
    "exact_grounded_citations": 18,
    "model_requests": 36,
    "source_stable": true,
    "all_below_90_seconds": true,
    "question_ids": [
      "Q02",
      "Q03",
      "Q07",
      "Q11",
      "Q13",
      "Q14",
      "Q19",
      "Q27",
      "Q35"
    ]
  },
  "preserved_r6_full_run": {
    "questions": 40,
    "passed": 39,
    "only_failure": "Q13",
    "all_original_seven_passed": true
  },
  "earlier_independent_base_validation": {
    "runner_sha256": "9b35ea2c71862e90755147054e35f1e0c0222f82ef2239908fb0442a32b0d632",
    "visible_semantic_controls_passed": 7,
    "positive_cross_field_controls_passed": 2,
    "unchanged_except_trigger_family": true
  },
  "scorer_byte_identical_to_r4": true,
  "qualification_claim": false,
  "full_r7_40_question_inference_claim": false,
  "limitations": [
    "The40-question source-support audit checks retrieval availability, not model accuracy or abstention.",
    "The full40-question model run used r6; r7 has a separate targeted9-question run. These must not be combined into a claimed r7full40 run.",
    "Finite role witnesses and inferred document scope retain the documented limitations from the earlier independent review.",
    "Fresh240-attempt comparison and final audit remain required before any launch conclusion."
  ],
  "reviewer_model_calls": 0,
  "future_fresh_corpus_access": false,
  "evidence_sha256": {
    "independent-validation/candidate-controls-r7.json": "9236581fb4106d0b5b8519550e8cb07f7c5f462f3e9e27e50394d330e3165e14",
    "independent-validation/consumed-all-support-r7.json": "108cc317583004c743b045bf2ceced4af5af85603fce4916c989a5891053ef6b",
    "development-targeted-r7.jsonl": "172e325f1667851d3f139bc13ce944a32c7a369a8c9c6dc5227eeccc7bca4588",
    "development-targeted-r7.summary.json": "5215564f6a0e04cef39144ee7a7f5b1e3ac79e0632b5b56be0f2941b70176664",
    "development-v18-r6.jsonl": "780787428d56d04af01d8df6f4d278f5e679c7e33e517e15bd55b64548589369",
    "../../workflow-v15-r5/runner.py": "911298ba21797fe0704874ed85c8f306193de2a69d130ea7ebb32b18bb9064f7"
  }
}