{ "schemaVersion": "kingy-document-independent-final-audit/1.0.0", "checkedAt": "2026-10-17T23:25:31.584595+00:00", "scoreValidityPassed": false, "attemptsCovered": 240, "uniqueBundlesReviewed": 82, "originalFrozenResultsChanged": false, "humanValidation": false, "summary": "All240 retained originals are covered by82 distinct answer/grade/citation bundles. Original output/source mapping and raw native text are preserved, with no identified parser loss or confirmed false pass. Semantic score validity does not pass: native contextual concise answers Q12/Q15 are definitively false-failed in all three repetitions. Many unresolved native paraphrases are semantically complete and must not be presented as wrong. Preserve every frozen score; issue no replacement leaderboard. Kingy has six repeated answerable declines and one conservative citation unresolved, and neither system establishes an overall winner. Workflow1.5 remains held independently for Kingy qualification and incomplete native original23.", "scoreValidityScope": "Unblinded AI-assisted independent source/answer review on one shared Mac, one synthetic corpus, one model weight set with two runtime/RAG pipelines. This judgment concerns semantic interpretation of frozen mechanical grades, not tampering or reproduction arithmetic. No regrading, alias repair, model calls, or numeric replacement accuracy was performed. Conservative unresolved cases remain unresolved in the published frozen record.", "inputSha256": { "kingy-common.jsonl": "821f2bc055e6462eb0d303e6e37b2d28f14e5502455fd9ecde9426dcb2ce5b54", "lmstudio-common.jsonl": "9de8b48cc63896a1d91b0d029818b1874920326dccd06809bfa31e8b01c6c3f2" }, "integrity": { "candidateOriginalRowsMatched": 120, "nativeOriginalRawTextRowsMatched": 120, "documentedNativeAnswers": 119, "unverifiedNativeOriginals": 1, "pdfsReextracted": 10, "pagesExactlyMatchedFrozenText": 30, "referenceCharSpansVerified": 60, "returnedSourceQuoteOccurrencesVerifiedUnique": 188, "noConfirmedParserLoss": true, "noConfirmedFalsePassAmongReviewedBundles": true, "sourceCheckReceiptSha256": { "final-source-text-check.json": "21535e8d82125695836164a9ad753e6202b7d3d761443e36d09acde4e044e5b0", "final-native-raw-parser-check.json": "74498f37745d4e1eddd0035b55db5fe1006d4df4205580da611480d2ebafadb3", "measurement-completion-eligibility-review.json": "1543fe3733a6683228cdb1d1edbbfc554a47277e168be344c4db5cef6a49b04a" } }, "scoringFindings": { "definiteConciseFalseFails": [ { "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q12", "repetitions": [ 1, 2, 3 ], "frozenStatus": "fail", "issue": "sample_interval:45seconds is a complete contextual interval answer with source citation. Frozen fail incorrectly treats this concise value as an incomplete alias substring, even though field/question provide interval scope. Definite concise-value false fail; do not alter original grade." }, { "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q15", "repetitions": [ 1, 2, 3 ], "frozenStatus": "fail", "issue": "account_bicycle_cap:2 is contextually sufficient for the explicitly named simultaneous-bicycle cap; valid source states at most2bicycles. Frozen fail rejects an adequate concise count. Definite false fail; no replacement grade is issued." } ], "possibleContextualFalseFail": [ { "questionId": "V19-Q11", "system": "B", "assessment": "Bare required plausibly means supervision still required in supervision_status, and citation contains the exact policy; it does not explicitly say no waiver. Treat as contextual/underspecified concise answer and possible false fail, not a proven wrong waiver policy or a clean semantic winner." } ], "completeNativeParaphrasesNotWrong": [ "V19-Q01", "V19-Q03", "V19-Q04", "V19-Q05", "V19-Q10", "V19-Q14", "V19-Q16", "V19-Q22", "V19-Q26", "V19-Q27" ], "conservativeCitationSpanUnresolved": [ { "questionId": "V19-Q11", "system": "A", "assessment": "Answer is the genuine D04 p2 sentence saying supervision remains required for red-band handling, an accepted policy meaning. Frozen fact check passes but citation stays unresolved because its preregistered evidence span includes the preceding no-waiver sentence too. This is conservative span uncertainty, not a demonstrated fabricated citation." } ], "noReplacementGradesOrAccuracyPercentages": true }, "freshKingyFailureReview": [ { "questionId": "V19-Q01", "originalsCovered": 3, "frozenStatus": "fail", "assessment": "Declines an answerable current storage rule. Selected D01 p2 unrelated closure/inspection context; its12 permitted passages omit the current4°C/±1°C/36-hour facts. This is a real task failure." }, { "questionId": "V19-Q11", "originalsCovered": 3, "frozenStatus": "unresolved", "assessment": "Answer is the genuine D04 p2 sentence saying supervision remains required for red-band handling, an accepted policy meaning. Frozen fact check passes but citation stays unresolved because its preregistered evidence span includes the preceding no-waiver sentence too. This is conservative span uncertainty, not a demonstrated fabricated citation." }, { "questionId": "V19-Q12", "originalsCovered": 3, "frozenStatus": "fail", "assessment": "Declines answerable45-second sampling interval. Recorded focused question drops the preceding Pell Grove/ordinary-logging sentence and retains only Give sample_interval; permitted candidates omit the actual interval. Native gives the correct concise interval." }, { "questionId": "V19-Q19", "originalsCovered": 3, "frozenStatus": "fail", "assessment": "Declines answerable current custodian Rina Solberg. Focused question drops the preceding Quartzline/current/evening-custodian sentence; candidates contain no Rina and selected D07 p1 discusses duties without naming her. Native supplies the current name." }, { "questionId": "V19-Q24", "originalsCovered": 3, "frozenStatus": "fail", "assessment": "Declines answerable current6-hour revisit although a correct6-hour candidate exists. Selects archived R3 four-hour passage instead; sufficiency rejects it. Native returns that obsolete4hours, so neither completes the current task." }, { "questionId": "V19-Q27", "originalsCovered": 3, "frozenStatus": "fail", "assessment": "Global decline after first storm-report selection supplies heading/initial safety check rather than deadline;14hours/return-to-base start absent from candidate set. No outlet field attempt follows. Native gives useful complete deadline/event and5continuous below-rim hours in the requested field context." }, { "questionId": "V19-Q28", "originalsCovered": 3, "frozenStatus": "fail", "assessment": "Whole answer declined. Loan fee field individually obtains correct0-dollar source, but batch field selects cold-review text instead of discard threshold; global abstention suppresses the valid first field. Native supplies fee but fails to express strict discard comparisons, so neither completes whole task." } ], "measurementCompletionGateSatisfied": false, "launchEligibleFromThisStudy": false, "completionHoldScope": "B3scheduled original23/V19-Q09 has no documented final original generation after host gap. Administrative retention and successful integrity seal do not establish240 completed responses. Do not infer a wrong answer, absent model request, or product unreliability; no replay. B3original22/Q38 has correct UNKNOWN content but unique final-event latency92.536s, a real frozen90s protocol failure.", "claimLimits": [ "Do not equate frozen rule-based supported-success percentages with fully adjudicated semantic accuracy or an overall product ranking.", "Do not use unverified original23 as a comparative quality/reliability advantage; no semantic advantage is claimed from the isolated deadline event either.", "Both systems correctly abstain on the unanswerable bank, subject to the separate B3Q38time limit; this is not unique Kingy evidence.", "Observed warm-query latency excludes setup/import/coldload/warmup, differs by pipeline, includes failed/declined tasks, and shared-host battery/AC/memory/host-gap conditions limit causal speed claims.", "Native testing conditionally reused an already existing10-PDF blank; fresh sequential default-policy upload refused a sixth file. No fresh10-file setup or universal file-cap claim is established.", "Kingy exact page/quote metadata is a returned-artifact property; numbered native markers still resolve genuine source chunks and do not prove absent vendor citation features.", "No human validation, independent physical reproduction, universal hardware/model recommendation, or production1.5qualification is established." ], "honestCaseLevelDifferences": [ { "advantage": "Kingy retained explicitly requested conditions/second durations in these cases.", "examples": "Q07 includes after the first purge; native returns only1.8L/min. Q17 includes the15-second reference segment at the end of75-second cycle; native returns75seconds alone.", "questionIds": [ "V19-Q07", "V19-Q17" ], "exampleList": [ "Q07 includes after the first purge; native returns only1.8L/min.", "Q17 includes the15-second reference segment at the end of75-second cycle; native returns75seconds alone." ] }, { "advantage": "Kingy supplied correct current rules where native returned an obsolete/irrelevant rule or false absence.", "examples": "Q06 supplies44–48% humidity versus native UNKNOWN. Q18 gives queue-empty plus saved-log reset conditions versus historical timing paragraph. Q20 gives minimum18hours and shelf-arrival start versus archived12hours. Q23 gives40minutes after session ends versus native false unspecified claim.", "questionIds": [ "V19-Q06", "V19-Q18", "V19-Q20", "V19-Q23" ], "exampleList": [ "Q06 supplies44–48% humidity versus native UNKNOWN.", "Q18 gives queue-empty plus saved-log reset conditions versus historical timing paragraph.", "Q20 gives minimum18hours and shelf-arrival start versus archived12hours.", "Q23 gives40minutes after session ends versus native false unspecified claim." ] }, { "advantage": "Kingy structured exports directly include document/page/quote for returned fields.", "examples": "Q07/Q17/Q20 provide explicit source pages; native returned numbered citation markers whose retained chunks span multiple pages. This is an artifact-level observation, not a claim LM Studio lacks citation UI.", "questionIds": [ "V19-Q07", "V19-Q17", "V19-Q20" ], "exampleList": [ "Q07/Q17/Q20 provide explicit source pages; native returned numbered citation markers whose retained chunks span multiple pages. This is an artifact-level observation, not a claim LM Studio lacks citation UI." ] }, { "advantage": "LM Studio supplied useful current facts that Kingy declined.", "examples": "Q01 gives4°C/±1°C/36hours after receipt, with relevant source, while Kingy abstains. Q19 names current custodian Rina Solberg while Kingy abstains. Q12 gives the correct45-second sample interval despite frozen concise-value false fail; Kingy abstains. Q27 supplies the supported deadline/event and below-rim interval in requested field context while Kingy declines.", "questionIds": [ "V19-Q01", "V19-Q19", "V19-Q12", "V19-Q27" ], "exampleList": [ "Q01 gives4°C/±1°C/36hours after receipt, with relevant source, while Kingy abstains.", "Q19 names current custodian Rina Solberg while Kingy abstains.", "Q12 gives the correct45-second sample interval despite frozen concise-value false fail; Kingy abstains.", "Q27 supplies the supported deadline/event and below-rim interval in requested field context while Kingy declines." ] }, { "advantage": "LM Studio can give shorter complete answers on tasks both systems answer correctly.", "examples": "Q02 returns accession code and harvest year. Q25 returns18kilograms including liner and8hours as two concise values, versus long Kingy excerpts. Q30 preserves both zero-fee charging bases in concise fields. These examples do not imply native is always concise.", "questionIds": [ "V19-Q02", "V19-Q25", "V19-Q30" ], "exampleList": [ "Q02 returns accession code and harvest year.", "Q25 returns18kilograms including liner and8hours as two concise values, versus long Kingy excerpts.", "Q30 preserves both zero-fee charging bases in concise fields. These examples do not imply native is always concise." ] } ], "bundleCoverageDefinition": "Group key includes system/question/required fields, normalized response, raw answer, citation metadata, stored grade/error and response-only grade. Only exact equal content bundles share source assessment; clocks/runtime records are covered individually by retained source mapping.78bundles repeat3x,2repeat2x,2are singletons.", "bundleReviews": [ { "bundleSha256": "875a4a05fc25f5ee8e01af44e7837526635e8c38b737b61ab2513d5490ec7018", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q01", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 21, "questionId": "V19-Q01", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 9, "questionId": "V19-Q01", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 26, "questionId": "V19-Q01", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "fail", "frozenFactStatus": "fail", "responseOnlyStatus": "fail", "answerFields": {}, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q01-storage_condition-1", "field": "storage_condition", "documentId": "V19-D01", "page": 1, "quote": "Accepted seed lots are held at 4 degrees Celsius, with a permitted variation of plus or minus 1 degree Celsius, during\nthe first 36 hours after receipt." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q01-storage_condition-2", "field": "storage_condition", "documentId": "V19-D01", "page": 1, "quote": "Accepted seed lots are held at 4 degrees Celsius, with a permitted variation of plus or minus 1 degree Celsius, during\nthe first 36 hours after receipt." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q01-storage_condition-3", "field": "storage_condition", "documentId": "V19-D01", "page": 1, "quote": "Accepted seed lots are held at 4 degrees Celsius, with a permitted variation of plus or minus 1 degree Celsius, during\nthe first 36 hours after receipt." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Declines an answerable current storage rule. Selected D01 p2 unrelated closure/inspection context; its12 permitted passages omit the current4°C/±1°C/36-hour facts. This is a real task failure.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "b806be375cd057195c31117e694a27d2c6b718b4d0db64052ce01813e6ce78a9", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q01", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 21, "questionId": "V19-Q01", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-21.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "b7b6777d9174add2e5bda73d82c5386fd8a5d1f90f7266d0f6ec06781aadafad", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "b7b6777d9174add2e5bda73d82c5386fd8a5d1f90f7266d0f6ec06781aadafad" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 9, "questionId": "V19-Q01", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-09.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "6fb302662c4070fb92278930148af15d460b28e679315f5fbb3e737ad75b8419", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "6fb302662c4070fb92278930148af15d460b28e679315f5fbb3e737ad75b8419" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 26, "questionId": "V19-Q01", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-26.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "ba029d8b0fa11fa249bd64eb6c12f64d86d7543dd1adefae805b7fba83500d6c", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "ba029d8b0fa11fa249bd64eb6c12f64d86d7543dd1adefae805b7fba83500d6c" } ], "frozenStatus": "unresolved", "frozenFactStatus": "unresolved", "responseOnlyStatus": "unresolved", "answerFields": { "storage_condition": "4 degrees Celsius with a permitted variation of plus or minus 1 degree Celsius during the first 36 hours after receipt ." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q01-storage_condition-1", "field": "storage_condition", "documentId": "V19-D01", "page": 1, "quote": "Accepted seed lots are held at 4 degrees Celsius, with a permitted variation of plus or minus 1 degree Celsius, during\nthe first 36 hours after receipt." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q01-storage_condition-2", "field": "storage_condition", "documentId": "V19-D01", "page": 1, "quote": "Accepted seed lots are held at 4 degrees Celsius, with a permitted variation of plus or minus 1 degree Celsius, during\nthe first 36 hours after receipt." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q01-storage_condition-3", "field": "storage_condition", "documentId": "V19-D01", "page": 1, "quote": "Accepted seed lots are held at 4 degrees Celsius, with a permitted variation of plus or minus 1 degree Celsius, during\nthe first 36 hours after receipt." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "storage_condition", "documentId": "V19-D01", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "2" } ], "independentAssessment": "Semantically complete4°C, permitted±1°C and first36hours after receipt, with genuine current D01 citation. Frozen unresolved is finite composition/ordering conservatism, not wrong facts. Clear useful-answer advantage over Kingy decline.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "23f51506d04f5137a5584cf84a1c21c78fca0b23525ba516be4aabb988a78050", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q02", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 18, "questionId": "V19-Q02", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 3, "questionId": "V19-Q02", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 19, "questionId": "V19-Q02", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "packet_label": "The current packet label contains the accession code and harvest year. The donor surname belongs in the private\nintake register and must not appear on the packet label." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q02-packet_label-1", "field": "packet_label", "documentId": "V19-D01", "page": 1, "quote": "The current packet label contains the accession code and harvest year." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q02-packet_label-2", "field": "packet_label", "documentId": "V19-D01", "page": 1, "quote": "The current packet label contains the accession code and harvest year." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "packet_label", "documentId": "V19-D01", "explicitPage": 1, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct current accession-code/harvest-year label, with genuine D01 p1 citation. Also copies an unrequested donor-surname exclusion; supported but less concise than native.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "cccae1960e17f38576dce23784dffdcae49c041ce02c9d82d8fcfa0ac5fe00ac", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q02", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 18, "questionId": "V19-Q02", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-18.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "4a13ea6f6d63db4f3077305db0d57fd47817e58276191223b1e23c99d6175855", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "4a13ea6f6d63db4f3077305db0d57fd47817e58276191223b1e23c99d6175855" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 3, "questionId": "V19-Q02", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-03.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "8b65024d02e7fe98ef5288e33b91bd0ef2e8f4f2ebe1f9ff5b66dfdd6013bc36", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "8b65024d02e7fe98ef5288e33b91bd0ef2e8f4f2ebe1f9ff5b66dfdd6013bc36" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 19, "questionId": "V19-Q02", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-19.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "8ae66d6cd20e0187c03a1acb62da614479ccb2c33d04687c3e2cfaed556bca18", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "8ae66d6cd20e0187c03a1acb62da614479ccb2c33d04687c3e2cfaed556bca18" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "packet_label": "accession code and harvest year" }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q02-packet_label-1", "field": "packet_label", "documentId": "V19-D01", "page": 1, "quote": "The current packet label contains the accession code and harvest year." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q02-packet_label-2", "field": "packet_label", "documentId": "V19-D01", "page": 1, "quote": "The current packet label contains the accession code and harvest year." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "packet_label", "documentId": "V19-D01", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "5" } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct concise accession code and harvest year, current source citation; both systems succeed, native output is shorter.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "6c5779403e94cbd63920cec8da50d82c5981471fc7ee305713701dc135d3a01b", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q03", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 36, "questionId": "V19-Q03", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 19, "questionId": "V19-Q03", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 31, "questionId": "V19-Q03", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "acknowledgement_deadline": "A receipt acknowledgement is due within 2 working days after the delivery day; Saturdays, Sundays, and announced\ncooperative closure days do not count. The delivery day itself is excluded from the count. This rule governs the sender's\nacknowledgement log only." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q03-acknowledgement_deadline-1", "field": "acknowledgement_deadline", "documentId": "V19-D01", "page": 2, "quote": "A receipt acknowledgement is due within 2 working days after the delivery day; Saturdays, Sundays, and announced\ncooperative closure days do not count." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q03-acknowledgement_deadline-2", "field": "acknowledgement_deadline", "documentId": "V19-D01", "page": 2, "quote": "A receipt acknowledgement is due within 2 working days after the delivery day; Saturdays, Sundays, and announced\ncooperative closure days do not count." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "acknowledgement_deadline", "documentId": "V19-D01", "explicitPage": 2, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct2-working-day deadline after delivery day, weekend/closure exclusions and genuine D01 p2 support. Copies additional current context without changing the rule.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "8e1db7102e323015f844cbb72853eff9f17ec77bc05997dd0355dde2eaae4639", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q03", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 36, "questionId": "V19-Q03", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-36.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "e507f04b272b6ae467415d43fda7fd49f2b10d016c770c0b8eab53373115440c", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "e507f04b272b6ae467415d43fda7fd49f2b10d016c770c0b8eab53373115440c" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 19, "questionId": "V19-Q03", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-19.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "07a924d4115b696c6ef29be29f71dd6df7c68d4d7d800bccdb3e33e1b1ca5adc", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "07a924d4115b696c6ef29be29f71dd6df7c68d4d7d800bccdb3e33e1b1ca5adc" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 31, "questionId": "V19-Q03", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-31.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "2bcab0e287d0385185c87d2a8baf030adf4d8a7d5b04fd6258c76bdbafe6576c", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "2bcab0e287d0385185c87d2a8baf030adf4d8a7d5b04fd6258c76bdbafe6576c" } ], "frozenStatus": "unresolved", "frozenFactStatus": "unresolved", "responseOnlyStatus": "unresolved", "answerFields": { "acknowledgement_deadline": "2 working days after the delivery day; Saturdays, Sundays, and announced cooperative closure days are excluded from the working-day count ." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q03-acknowledgement_deadline-1", "field": "acknowledgement_deadline", "documentId": "V19-D01", "page": 2, "quote": "A receipt acknowledgement is due within 2 working days after the delivery day; Saturdays, Sundays, and announced\ncooperative closure days do not count." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q03-acknowledgement_deadline-2", "field": "acknowledgement_deadline", "documentId": "V19-D01", "page": 2, "quote": "A receipt acknowledgement is due within 2 working days after the delivery day; Saturdays, Sundays, and announced\ncooperative closure days do not count." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "acknowledgement_deadline", "documentId": "V19-D01", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "5" } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct2-working-day deadline after delivery day and all weekend/closure exclusions. are excluded is a faithful paraphrase of do not count; frozen unresolved must not be called incorrect.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "bbea49765bdedad263f54b64c129bfb4e4d2592a1cf8d0b82a9c92d72368e45c", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q04", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 17, "questionId": "V19-Q04", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 20, "questionId": "V19-Q04", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 8, "questionId": "V19-Q04", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "lacquer_rest": "After the final clear lacquer coat, a Blue Room panel rests for 30 hours before a handling inspection begins. Time starts\nwhen the brush leaves the panel, not when the panel enters the rack." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q04-lacquer_rest-1", "field": "lacquer_rest", "documentId": "V19-D02", "page": 1, "quote": "After the final clear lacquer coat, a Blue Room panel rests for 30 hours before a handling inspection begins. Time starts\nwhen the brush leaves the panel, not when the panel enters the rack." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q04-lacquer_rest-2", "field": "lacquer_rest", "documentId": "V19-D02", "page": 1, "quote": "After the final clear lacquer coat, a Blue Room panel rests for 30 hours before a handling inspection begins. Time starts\nwhen the brush leaves the panel, not when the panel enters the rack." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "lacquer_rest", "documentId": "V19-D02", "explicitPage": 1, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct30-hour final-lacquer rest and brush-leaves-panel start; D02 p1 directly supports both.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "7b6757ff54b7f9cac30f1fa6d696ccc31bc9bdd2ab1edc6aca0c1074045d946e", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q04", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 17, "questionId": "V19-Q04", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-17.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "729a41f22ad371ba8f57c2e0c94259b9ef9b8a82f2ad87282e6dec26ba43b200", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "729a41f22ad371ba8f57c2e0c94259b9ef9b8a82f2ad87282e6dec26ba43b200" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 20, "questionId": "V19-Q04", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-20.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "bb5db464cf0f2011223cd60d5aca41c64bb332ff21531cdd1f015a7a0c448229", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "bb5db464cf0f2011223cd60d5aca41c64bb332ff21531cdd1f015a7a0c448229" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 8, "questionId": "V19-Q04", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-08.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "bf109e0d641db136fae2c409067e6d72390a3e25478cf576e958634914b0f16e", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "bf109e0d641db136fae2c409067e6d72390a3e25478cf576e958634914b0f16e" } ], "frozenStatus": "unresolved", "frozenFactStatus": "unresolved", "responseOnlyStatus": "unresolved", "answerFields": { "lacquer_rest": "30 hours after the final clear lacquer coat, the period starts when the brush leaves the panel ." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q04-lacquer_rest-1", "field": "lacquer_rest", "documentId": "V19-D02", "page": 1, "quote": "After the final clear lacquer coat, a Blue Room panel rests for 30 hours before a handling inspection begins. Time starts\nwhen the brush leaves the panel, not when the panel enters the rack." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q04-lacquer_rest-2", "field": "lacquer_rest", "documentId": "V19-D02", "page": 1, "quote": "After the final clear lacquer coat, a Blue Room panel rests for 30 hours before a handling inspection begins. Time starts\nwhen the brush leaves the panel, not when the panel enters the rack." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "lacquer_rest", "documentId": "V19-D02", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "1" } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct30hours and brush-leaves-panel starting event. Frozen unresolved is wording/composition conservatism despite both obligations matching.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "823e4c68e84e7def3ba4e5a5da21bea1bed0b59ca7bad5258ec5ef7ec1c9eb65", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q05", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 3, "questionId": "V19-Q05", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 31, "questionId": "V19-Q05", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 4, "questionId": "V19-Q05", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "solvent_permission": "Solvent wiping is permitted only after written approval from the conservation lead and only on an unpainted test margin.\nBoth restrictions apply even when a client has requested faster work." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q05-solvent_permission-1", "field": "solvent_permission", "documentId": "V19-D02", "page": 1, "quote": "Solvent wiping is permitted only after written approval from the conservation lead and only on an unpainted test margin." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q05-solvent_permission-2", "field": "solvent_permission", "documentId": "V19-D02", "page": 1, "quote": "Solvent wiping is permitted only after written approval from the conservation lead and only on an unpainted test margin." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "solvent_permission", "documentId": "V19-D02", "explicitPage": 1, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct written-lead-approval and unpainted-test-margin restrictions; D02 p1 directly supports both.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "dd2058692171e7a7b33fcaca05894823bcd974ed554d73ad552a3b561bd1cfb6", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q05", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 3, "questionId": "V19-Q05", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-03.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "aaadfa8eaf3524f8ddf93c526937cb59dabd5427da87d08c9859f09b0016c6e1", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "aaadfa8eaf3524f8ddf93c526937cb59dabd5427da87d08c9859f09b0016c6e1" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 31, "questionId": "V19-Q05", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-31.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "7f59a5a031b31bc3db17a51350c563125ed19469f4e499b55d81f6bdbefdaa82", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "7f59a5a031b31bc3db17a51350c563125ed19469f4e499b55d81f6bdbefdaa82" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 4, "questionId": "V19-Q05", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-04.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "b15ae682a00c503050bee25dca1566f66d8196b0856d720601ed9d825af5a037", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "b15ae682a00c503050bee25dca1566f66d8196b0856d720601ed9d825af5a037" } ], "frozenStatus": "unresolved", "frozenFactStatus": "unresolved", "responseOnlyStatus": "unresolved", "answerFields": { "solvent_permission": "Solvent wiping is permitted only after written approval from the conservation lead and only on an unpainted test margin. Both restrictions apply even when a client has requested faster work. Approval for one panel does not extend to another panel in the same order. The technician photographs the margin before wiping. Painted detail is examined with a dry optical method under the bench lamp rather than treated under this permission." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q05-solvent_permission-1", "field": "solvent_permission", "documentId": "V19-D02", "page": 1, "quote": "Solvent wiping is permitted only after written approval from the conservation lead and only on an unpainted test margin." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q05-solvent_permission-2", "field": "solvent_permission", "documentId": "V19-D02", "page": 1, "quote": "Solvent wiping is permitted only after written approval from the conservation lead and only on an unpainted test margin." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "solvent_permission", "documentId": "V19-D02", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "6" } ], "independentAssessment": "Both restrictions correctly quoted with valid source. Extra sentences about approval scope/photos/painted detail are supported; this native response is itself verbose. Frozen unresolved is not an incorrect-policy finding.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "0cad47fb7e380f13aa781cd55ccfeb4fdcb03817e8352151b1140d64a16e3e3a", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q06", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 40, "questionId": "V19-Q06", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 17, "questionId": "V19-Q06", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 3, "questionId": "V19-Q06", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "humidity_band": "During the resting period, the rack is kept between 44 and 48 percent relative humidity. A rack reading is recorded at\nthe start and finish of the hold. These readings describe the room environment; they do not determine the moisture\ncontent inside historic wood framing. If a reading falls outside the band, the technician notes the event and asks the\nconservation lead whether the hold should be extended." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q06-humidity_band-1", "field": "humidity_band", "documentId": "V19-D02", "page": 1, "quote": "During the resting period, the rack is kept between 44 and 48 percent relative humidity." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "humidity_band", "documentId": "V19-D02", "explicitPage": 1, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct44–48% relative-humidity band with genuine D02 p1 support. The long copied paragraph adds unrequested room/moisture/escalation context.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "9e61be6ec39aa7b1acf3d935b452657cf0cd0ae66d5d28ea707b11a68c870ecd", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q06", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 40, "questionId": "V19-Q06", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-40.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "53580ecc0feb0676d139309fca5baa584b7da95ac51b3caf036f0d6db59085b5", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "53580ecc0feb0676d139309fca5baa584b7da95ac51b3caf036f0d6db59085b5" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 17, "questionId": "V19-Q06", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-17.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "3d19f4622ea5c184471b8d481625441491810d553da190b6968c2da40f776420", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "3d19f4622ea5c184471b8d481625441491810d553da190b6968c2da40f776420" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 3, "questionId": "V19-Q06", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-03.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "ae5e2c488d510ed20eca4a0b80a12f7a6536bf7608d5794e7fb8ca713dc7537d", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "ae5e2c488d510ed20eca4a0b80a12f7a6536bf7608d5794e7fb8ca713dc7537d" } ], "frozenStatus": "fail", "frozenFactStatus": "fail", "responseOnlyStatus": "fail", "answerFields": { "humidity_band": "UNKNOWN" }, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q06-humidity_band-1", "field": "humidity_band", "documentId": "V19-D02", "page": 1, "quote": "During the resting period, the rack is kept between 44 and 48 percent relative humidity." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "UNKNOWN for an answerable44–48% band; no supporting answer. Real omission; Kingy supplies correct band.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "c507ef1ccab802b8295d91aecd3809c6e1c1e6c74852d06331efdb6b38b40706", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q07", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 1, "questionId": "V19-Q07", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 4, "questionId": "V19-Q07", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 15, "questionId": "V19-Q07", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "night_discharge": "On the night route, the sample-water discharge rate is 1.8 liters per minute after the first purge." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q07-night_discharge-1", "field": "night_discharge", "documentId": "V19-D03", "page": 1, "quote": "On the night route, the sample-water discharge rate is 1.8 liters per minute after the first purge." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q07-night_discharge-2", "field": "night_discharge", "documentId": "V19-D03", "page": 1, "quote": "On the night route, the sample-water discharge rate is 1.8 liters per minute after the first purge." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "night_discharge", "documentId": "V19-D03", "explicitPage": 1, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct1.8L/min after the first purge; D03 p1 supplies both rate and requested condition. Native omits the purge condition.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "f439308cca16ee70d10c9da106602d497aa228483af909f3a11a6d21e3a23ef4", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q07", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 1, "questionId": "V19-Q07", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-01.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "05a8f095125dd4e2abd81e154419ac294dcdf5d4931c587050dfd72d1f8b8d29", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "05a8f095125dd4e2abd81e154419ac294dcdf5d4931c587050dfd72d1f8b8d29" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 4, "questionId": "V19-Q07", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-04.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "5932e922e49e3b562a4115cbe62c24a60c9a574567c0abbdd586172e89e2eb5d", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "5932e922e49e3b562a4115cbe62c24a60c9a574567c0abbdd586172e89e2eb5d" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 15, "questionId": "V19-Q07", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-15.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "71ae86804f1d131bf2a40b28c382535344f22438f7c54b6d393f7ce905b0c715", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "71ae86804f1d131bf2a40b28c382535344f22438f7c54b6d393f7ce905b0c715" } ], "frozenStatus": "unresolved", "frozenFactStatus": "unresolved", "responseOnlyStatus": "unresolved", "answerFields": { "night_discharge": "1.8 liters per minute" }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q07-night_discharge-1", "field": "night_discharge", "documentId": "V19-D03", "page": 1, "quote": "On the night route, the sample-water discharge rate is 1.8 liters per minute after the first purge." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q07-night_discharge-2", "field": "night_discharge", "documentId": "V19-D03", "page": 1, "quote": "On the night route, the sample-water discharge rate is 1.8 liters per minute after the first purge." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "night_discharge", "documentId": "V19-D03", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "3" } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct rate1.8L/min but omits explicitly requested after-first-purge condition. Citation contains the condition, yet answer field does not. Genuine task incompleteness, regardless conservative unresolved grade.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "d955b3915eb158768d0830e702ed3f8b06d74ff7e53a81800e9ed98daf8aa39b", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q08", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 29, "questionId": "V19-Q08", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 34, "questionId": "V19-Q08", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 37, "questionId": "V19-Q08", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "route_suspension": "The outer pontoon route is suspended when the observed wave height is greater than 0.7 meters at the approach\nmarker. A reading of exactly 0.7 meters does not itself trigger suspension under this rule. The route supervisor can\nsuspend travel for another recorded hazard, such as floating debris, even below that threshold. A suspension means no\nsampling landing at the outer pontoon; it does not erase earlier samples from the same day." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q08-route_suspension-1", "field": "route_suspension", "documentId": "V19-D03", "page": 1, "quote": "The outer pontoon route is suspended when the observed wave height is greater than 0.7 meters at the approach\nmarker." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q08-route_suspension-2", "field": "route_suspension", "documentId": "V19-D03", "page": 1, "quote": "The outer pontoon route is suspended when the observed wave height is greater than 0.7 meters at the approach\nmarker." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "route_suspension", "documentId": "V19-D03", "explicitPage": 1, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct strict>0.7m boundary at approach marker, including source clarification that equality does not itself suspend. Genuine D03 p1 support; extra supported context is verbose.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "cbbe88d309d7dda7c3f6af5e5b84b04b34bc7aac3874656d9042f246bab83609", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q08", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 29, "questionId": "V19-Q08", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-29.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "a4e4a25716f8a7faa02062fa4bd042d0259175db90750f1476b8592f1d8e24f8", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "a4e4a25716f8a7faa02062fa4bd042d0259175db90750f1476b8592f1d8e24f8" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 34, "questionId": "V19-Q08", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-34.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "baf918b5cd1e50c772cdc423a8b348f54f8e2d846a7fda5bc9c45bf7236f4f46", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "baf918b5cd1e50c772cdc423a8b348f54f8e2d846a7fda5bc9c45bf7236f4f46" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 37, "questionId": "V19-Q08", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-37.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "d37d1ae53098b8aebf8e21d350879236fa1fc2cfb7b534e4a9dcbf6fca38d026", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "d37d1ae53098b8aebf8e21d350879236fa1fc2cfb7b534e4a9dcbf6fca38d026" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "route_suspension": "The outer pontoon route is suspended when the observed wave height is greater than 0.7 meters at the approach marker." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q08-route_suspension-1", "field": "route_suspension", "documentId": "V19-D03", "page": 1, "quote": "The outer pontoon route is suspended when the observed wave height is greater than 0.7 meters at the approach\nmarker." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q08-route_suspension-2", "field": "route_suspension", "documentId": "V19-D03", "page": 1, "quote": "The outer pontoon route is suspended when the observed wave height is greater than 0.7 meters at the approach\nmarker." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "route_suspension", "documentId": "V19-D03", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "2" } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct strict>0.7m at approach marker with genuine source; concise complete sentence.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "c2cefa1903b54da64f510f7dfe3c77ab4831f5ef832d8ec5013c0f314ff0faa4", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q09", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 11, "questionId": "V19-Q09", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 27, "questionId": "V19-Q09", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 23, "questionId": "V19-Q09", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "cancellation_charge": "The cancellation charge for a research booking cancelled before departure is 0 dollars." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q09-cancellation_charge-1", "field": "cancellation_charge", "documentId": "V19-D03", "page": 2, "quote": "The cancellation charge for a research booking cancelled before departure is 0 dollars." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "cancellation_charge", "documentId": "V19-D03", "explicitPage": 2, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct explicit0-dollar predeparture cancellation charge; D03 p2 support. Native B1/B2 also answer correctly; interrupted B3 is not a quality comparison.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "b20858683bc7d357dcf8aaeca4a4b96ae1f26bd27fb659bb3c70a7207dedbf7b", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q09", "attemptsCovered": 1, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 23, "questionId": "V19-Q09", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-23.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "d98481153cec34f759ee58a1dc1a429f8238d08857a0c2811ae13e2ce90b6a6c", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "d98481153cec34f759ee58a1dc1a429f8238d08857a0c2811ae13e2ce90b6a6c" } ], "frozenStatus": "fail", "frozenFactStatus": "fail", "responseOnlyStatus": "fail", "answerFields": { "cancellation_charge": "" }, "abstain": false, "error": "Expected one original native generation.", "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q09-cancellation_charge-1", "field": "cancellation_charge", "documentId": "V19-D03", "page": 2, "quote": "The cancellation charge for a research booking cancelled before departure is 0 dollars." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "No documented original generation/final answer after host restart. Retained exact native source is incomplete/unverified, not a wrong model answer. No resubmission; exclude from semantic advantage/reliability claims and hold measurement-completion gate.", "specialScope": "host-gap-incomplete-unverified" }, { "bundleSha256": "924be098157be2b01cafbba98ef817fa11a445c46429e8953b837b7b89abc250", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q09", "attemptsCovered": 2, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 11, "questionId": "V19-Q09", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-11.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "ce028d2a4b5b90959c7afb2157326bf4c7d81587e324fd4bc1770264c7ed80ca", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "ce028d2a4b5b90959c7afb2157326bf4c7d81587e324fd4bc1770264c7ed80ca" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 27, "questionId": "V19-Q09", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-27.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "abae2b28eec2193f7d4f5ba2fbdc7292c20a8b9bdcac13cc813ecf3bea3c396e", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "abae2b28eec2193f7d4f5ba2fbdc7292c20a8b9bdcac13cc813ecf3bea3c396e" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "cancellation_charge": "0 dollars" }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q09-cancellation_charge-1", "field": "cancellation_charge", "documentId": "V19-D03", "page": 2, "quote": "The cancellation charge for a research booking cancelled before departure is 0 dollars." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "cancellation_charge", "documentId": "V19-D03", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "1" } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct0-dollar predeparture charge with genuine source in B1/B2. B3missing-generation row is separately reviewed and cannot imply an inferior answer.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "1534a40f1b9c4a3a3a20c0a62dd8bdbf2f2af32a64d5425ffa9f007c72e0990a", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q10", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 27, "questionId": "V19-Q10", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 32, "questionId": "V19-Q10", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 33, "questionId": "V19-Q10", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "transcript_retention": "An assisted-reading audio transcript is retained for 21 calendar days after the reader receives it, then deleted from the\nservice folder. The day of receipt is the starting event, and weekends are included. A transcript is a service aid for the\nrequesting reader, not a new catalog record. Deleting it does not alter a source manuscript or a catalog description." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q10-transcript_retention-1", "field": "transcript_retention", "documentId": "V19-D04", "page": 1, "quote": "An assisted-reading audio transcript is retained for 21 calendar days after the reader receives it, then deleted from the\nservice folder." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q10-transcript_retention-2", "field": "transcript_retention", "documentId": "V19-D04", "page": 1, "quote": "An assisted-reading audio transcript is retained for 21 calendar days after the reader receives it, then deleted from the\nservice folder." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "transcript_retention", "documentId": "V19-D04", "explicitPage": 1, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct21-calendar-day retention after reader receives transcript; D04 p1 supports value/start. Extra source context is supported.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "08ca9e18c54909c42966d36c1f373b4b4052d9487abd8b4ac81603c36900eedb", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q10", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 27, "questionId": "V19-Q10", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-27.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "4662948174113adba8d4e03cce926844de7de5706f1b3aa22b4bb2b50ad8cf37", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "4662948174113adba8d4e03cce926844de7de5706f1b3aa22b4bb2b50ad8cf37" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 32, "questionId": "V19-Q10", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-32.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "71809e77397d9fb6591c456025b8c2399a6c3766380b3ad4b135f86da5c1ebf4", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "71809e77397d9fb6591c456025b8c2399a6c3766380b3ad4b135f86da5c1ebf4" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 33, "questionId": "V19-Q10", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-33.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "d0cc7d17b18651168ea4dd7e1d9f64ffe8473419eb09e4f059e237d656147bc6", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "d0cc7d17b18651168ea4dd7e1d9f64ffe8473419eb09e4f059e237d656147bc6" } ], "frozenStatus": "unresolved", "frozenFactStatus": "unresolved", "responseOnlyStatus": "unresolved", "answerFields": { "transcript_retention": "21 calendar days after the reader receives it, then deleted from the service folder. The day of receipt is the starting event, and weekends are included." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q10-transcript_retention-1", "field": "transcript_retention", "documentId": "V19-D04", "page": 1, "quote": "An assisted-reading audio transcript is retained for 21 calendar days after the reader receives it, then deleted from the\nservice folder." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q10-transcript_retention-2", "field": "transcript_retention", "documentId": "V19-D04", "page": 1, "quote": "An assisted-reading audio transcript is retained for 21 calendar days after the reader receives it, then deleted from the\nservice folder." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "transcript_retention", "documentId": "V19-D04", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "2" } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct21calendar days after reader receives it; deletion and weekends wording is source-supported. Frozen unresolved is not a factual error.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "ddcfe3b7b50d51ec4bc68ff148a4cf987438a22cb6a7e4c1214eb522961afa43", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q11", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 30, "questionId": "V19-Q11", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 24, "questionId": "V19-Q11", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 28, "questionId": "V19-Q11", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "unresolved", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "unresolved", "answerFields": { "supervision_status": "Supervision remains\nrequired while the reader handles a red-band manuscript." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q11-supervision_status-1", "field": "supervision_status", "documentId": "V19-D04", "page": 2, "quote": "A reader's prior volunteer service provides no waiver of the supervised-handling requirement. Supervision remains\nrequired while the reader handles a red-band manuscript." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "supervision_status", "documentId": "V19-D04", "explicitPage": 2, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Answer is the genuine D04 p2 sentence saying supervision remains required for red-band handling, an accepted policy meaning. Frozen fact check passes but citation stays unresolved because its preregistered evidence span includes the preceding no-waiver sentence too. This is conservative span uncertainty, not a demonstrated fabricated citation.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "5b2a5c81a0c32f410e9bed0c5bccc370e8445f4bbea5a8c4e0c2e0cf7764ea6f", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q11", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 30, "questionId": "V19-Q11", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-30.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "ac40108abd8ff21d86f0e696f0acc15b80160618c25799d315b2fc430a3af863", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "ac40108abd8ff21d86f0e696f0acc15b80160618c25799d315b2fc430a3af863" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 24, "questionId": "V19-Q11", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-24.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "7dfa934e3a7c9a297cf0e960209f3abc132e00650ba8ee29a90e8c40d6891d6c", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "7dfa934e3a7c9a297cf0e960209f3abc132e00650ba8ee29a90e8c40d6891d6c" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 28, "questionId": "V19-Q11", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-28.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "47e9c266b59cc4570fc8ab4bf10e2f2c1ecedaf620f68bd5697d9d0d5337a97f", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "47e9c266b59cc4570fc8ab4bf10e2f2c1ecedaf620f68bd5697d9d0d5337a97f" } ], "frozenStatus": "fail", "frozenFactStatus": "fail", "responseOnlyStatus": "fail", "answerFields": { "supervision_status": "required" }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q11-supervision_status-1", "field": "supervision_status", "documentId": "V19-D04", "page": 2, "quote": "A reader's prior volunteer service provides no waiver of the supervised-handling requirement. Supervision remains\nrequired while the reader handles a red-band manuscript." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "supervision_status", "documentId": "V19-D04", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "2" } ], "independentAssessment": "Bare required plausibly means supervision still required in supervision_status, and citation contains the exact policy; it does not explicitly say no waiver. Treat as contextual/underspecified concise answer and possible false fail, not a proven wrong waiver policy or a clean semantic winner.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "d76bd32985e2f6a2ed9cbdaafd4af65d7b49016c4e6502a56f7345f6ef0f0cca", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q12", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 37, "questionId": "V19-Q12", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 10, "questionId": "V19-Q12", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 34, "questionId": "V19-Q12", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "fail", "frozenFactStatus": "fail", "responseOnlyStatus": "fail", "answerFields": {}, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q12-sample_interval-1", "field": "sample_interval", "documentId": "V19-D05", "page": 1, "quote": "The air sensor records one sample every 45 seconds while a station is in ordinary logging mode." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Declines answerable45-second sampling interval. Recorded focused question drops the preceding Pell Grove/ordinary-logging sentence and retains only Give sample_interval; permitted candidates omit the actual interval. Native gives the correct concise interval.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "334c09615fca8830ab1037c907ee281e9681ea39a594adef1997e2ef2e3d7509", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q12", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 37, "questionId": "V19-Q12", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-37.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "a56b77c0b63388800f2379cc25594026d3b6c164d32a8b21b7a78fc1636fa8ab", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "a56b77c0b63388800f2379cc25594026d3b6c164d32a8b21b7a78fc1636fa8ab" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 10, "questionId": "V19-Q12", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-10.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "b67cbe424e3e6a318527c7d3618b837e9cdcbf6ab2eaf4c62d54151f79587d44", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "b67cbe424e3e6a318527c7d3618b837e9cdcbf6ab2eaf4c62d54151f79587d44" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 34, "questionId": "V19-Q12", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-34.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "e54d0e157d3777089bfe29fc933fd43d47698a8e9012a9b94dc31424674a7973", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "e54d0e157d3777089bfe29fc933fd43d47698a8e9012a9b94dc31424674a7973" } ], "frozenStatus": "fail", "frozenFactStatus": "fail", "responseOnlyStatus": "fail", "answerFields": { "sample_interval": "45 seconds" }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q12-sample_interval-1", "field": "sample_interval", "documentId": "V19-D05", "page": 1, "quote": "The air sensor records one sample every 45 seconds while a station is in ordinary logging mode." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "sample_interval", "documentId": "V19-D05", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "3" } ], "independentAssessment": "sample_interval:45seconds is a complete contextual interval answer with source citation. Frozen fail incorrectly treats this concise value as an incomplete alias substring, even though field/question provide interval scope. Definite concise-value false fail; do not alter original grade.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "6a3a3a317e3c659722161269c4dc442776c6709100529cab04e72039dc254bb8", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q13", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 8, "questionId": "V19-Q13", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 38, "questionId": "V19-Q13", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 13, "questionId": "V19-Q13", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "wind_alert_condition": "A wind alert is raised when speed stays above 12 meters per second for 90 consecutive seconds. An isolated reading\nabove the threshold does not meet the duration condition." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q13-wind_alert_condition-1", "field": "wind_alert_condition", "documentId": "V19-D05", "page": 1, "quote": "A wind alert is raised when speed stays above 12 meters per second for 90 consecutive seconds." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q13-wind_alert_condition-2", "field": "wind_alert_condition", "documentId": "V19-D05", "page": 1, "quote": "A wind alert is raised when speed stays above 12 meters per second for 90 consecutive seconds." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "wind_alert_condition", "documentId": "V19-D05", "explicitPage": 1, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct strict speed above12m/s for90consecutive seconds; genuine D05 p1 support, conditions retained.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "1e2fdec7dbf1c3e2719f78662980fb3043f1ccb020124186d730e5404758e8d8", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q13", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 8, "questionId": "V19-Q13", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-08.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "de907e8dd4d055298358951564f0bd6fd86bbff9576dac975e7ae76ba8e262fa", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "de907e8dd4d055298358951564f0bd6fd86bbff9576dac975e7ae76ba8e262fa" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 38, "questionId": "V19-Q13", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-38.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "969552fc8d32ddaf95be91f0891812536b44ac6854cb12225da246f3bf79205e", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "969552fc8d32ddaf95be91f0891812536b44ac6854cb12225da246f3bf79205e" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 13, "questionId": "V19-Q13", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-13.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "f23870492eed4d1dc0fcc598a9436bcdc3b7f3e0ca98285ff4696f6eedc51541", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "f23870492eed4d1dc0fcc598a9436bcdc3b7f3e0ca98285ff4696f6eedc51541" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "wind_alert_condition": "A wind alert is raised when speed stays above 12 meters per second for 90 consecutive seconds." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q13-wind_alert_condition-1", "field": "wind_alert_condition", "documentId": "V19-D05", "page": 1, "quote": "A wind alert is raised when speed stays above 12 meters per second for 90 consecutive seconds." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q13-wind_alert_condition-2", "field": "wind_alert_condition", "documentId": "V19-D05", "page": 1, "quote": "A wind alert is raised when speed stays above 12 meters per second for 90 consecutive seconds." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "wind_alert_condition", "documentId": "V19-D05", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "1" } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct strict>12m/s for90consecutive seconds, valid source; concise complete sentence.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "48783e987e665587e5bf18efdae4cd016be76665cdf7b8fca33f9a4eb1ff8c35", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q14", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 14, "questionId": "V19-Q14", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 29, "questionId": "V19-Q14", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 20, "questionId": "V19-Q14", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "temperature_correction": "Station PG-4 applies a temperature correction of minus 0.6 degrees Celsius to its raw air reading before displaying the\ncorrected reading. The correction is negative, not an uncertainty band." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q14-temperature_correction-1", "field": "temperature_correction", "documentId": "V19-D05", "page": 1, "quote": "Station PG-4 applies a temperature correction of minus 0.6 degrees Celsius to its raw air reading before displaying the\ncorrected reading." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "temperature_correction", "documentId": "V19-D05", "explicitPage": 1, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct signed minus0.6°C correction for PG-4; genuine D05 p1 support. No conversion to positive uncertainty band.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "4820dcb797cf699ba1b9348f7ae7b7cda1893c89b5231446f49861616edc4e7e", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q14", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 14, "questionId": "V19-Q14", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-14.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "9c1d63266004b9390cd73ffbd41ea5d60c4a99cf1d3d64f866285355c831fa05", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "2ae24b56e090bac29e515ddf134021907252c8d1884f8a29b21d0930dcf3020d" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 29, "questionId": "V19-Q14", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-29.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "601c61fe6cd701c1661dccfd4204dd0e1dbeed796121fbfb51721a6896eedbcf", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "601c61fe6cd701c1661dccfd4204dd0e1dbeed796121fbfb51721a6896eedbcf" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 20, "questionId": "V19-Q14", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-20.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "1f293f73502faa5fa331bd1461dc48ded7f2b61e70931c91658052f52ceb891d", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "1f293f73502faa5fa331bd1461dc48ded7f2b61e70931c91658052f52ceb891d" } ], "frozenStatus": "unresolved", "frozenFactStatus": "unresolved", "responseOnlyStatus": "unresolved", "answerFields": { "temperature_correction": "minus 0.6 degrees Celsius to its raw air reading before displaying the corrected reading." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q14-temperature_correction-1", "field": "temperature_correction", "documentId": "V19-D05", "page": 1, "quote": "Station PG-4 applies a temperature correction of minus 0.6 degrees Celsius to its raw air reading before displaying the\ncorrected reading." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "temperature_correction", "documentId": "V19-D05", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "1" } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct minus0.6°C signed correction with supported display context. Frozen unresolved is composition conservatism, not sign/value error.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "4e5a2173c8ffaef3a522e83a59d8228fe9e5c3ab29639e6c1a1e9cd9bfeba20a", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q15", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 35, "questionId": "V19-Q15", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 22, "questionId": "V19-Q15", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 35, "questionId": "V19-Q15", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "account_bicycle_cap": "An account may have at most 2 bicycles checked out simultaneously. A returned bicycle leaves the count only when a\ndesk assistant records the return." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q15-account_bicycle_cap-1", "field": "account_bicycle_cap", "documentId": "V19-D06", "page": 1, "quote": "An account may have at most 2 bicycles checked out simultaneously." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "account_bicycle_cap", "documentId": "V19-D06", "explicitPage": 1, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct at-most2 simultaneous bicycles; genuine D06 p1 support. Native bare2 is also contextually sufficient despite frozen false fail.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "256a68244bdf404d380939994b3a5e52f46a74d51cf0ea46e61e48ea7373a062", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q15", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 35, "questionId": "V19-Q15", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-35.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "9165a1a79c1d1234557db1d5fe55caeb2eec5a152b975e4a244b48cdfd73944d", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "9165a1a79c1d1234557db1d5fe55caeb2eec5a152b975e4a244b48cdfd73944d" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 22, "questionId": "V19-Q15", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-22.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "ac32a80f6d77f6792378fb7c9a0f1c9cd5f3c66613fc15f2df637791f0ec8fa3", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "ac32a80f6d77f6792378fb7c9a0f1c9cd5f3c66613fc15f2df637791f0ec8fa3" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 35, "questionId": "V19-Q15", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-35.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "2ec1e32943b0fa77c3c4cbeeedff0c5dcd8b52907aabe7e643a25d9c2e7e6fef", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "2ec1e32943b0fa77c3c4cbeeedff0c5dcd8b52907aabe7e643a25d9c2e7e6fef" } ], "frozenStatus": "fail", "frozenFactStatus": "fail", "responseOnlyStatus": "fail", "answerFields": { "account_bicycle_cap": "2" }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q15-account_bicycle_cap-1", "field": "account_bicycle_cap", "documentId": "V19-D06", "page": 1, "quote": "An account may have at most 2 bicycles checked out simultaneously." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "account_bicycle_cap", "documentId": "V19-D06", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "2" } ], "independentAssessment": "account_bicycle_cap:2 is contextually sufficient for the explicitly named simultaneous-bicycle cap; valid source states at most2bicycles. Frozen fail rejects an adequate concise count. Definite false fail; no replacement grade is issued.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "5b3a2a102ab77e6b3c04b111c474ab59569d760e3334ebad2424b5ab4edeb722", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q16", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 7, "questionId": "V19-Q16", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 23, "questionId": "V19-Q16", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 2, "questionId": "V19-Q16", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "helmet_hold": "After a loan helmet is wiped with the approved cleaner, it remains on the drying shelf for at least 8 hours before another\nloan. The drying period begins after wiping is complete. Closing the workshop does not pause the clock. A dry\nappearance after a shorter time does not shorten the minimum hold." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q16-helmet_hold-1", "field": "helmet_hold", "documentId": "V19-D06", "page": 2, "quote": "After a loan helmet is wiped with the approved cleaner, it remains on the drying shelf for at least 8 hours before another\nloan. The drying period begins after wiping is complete." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q16-helmet_hold-2", "field": "helmet_hold", "documentId": "V19-D06", "page": 2, "quote": "After a loan helmet is wiped with the approved cleaner, it remains on the drying shelf for at least 8 hours before another\nloan. The drying period begins after wiping is complete." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "helmet_hold", "documentId": "V19-D06", "explicitPage": 2, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct at-least8-hour hold starting after wiping is complete; genuine D06 p2 support. Additional source context does not change either condition.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "cad19f901b9a456f1dc0d86357b35d705816432c7ddc7202124cf18dfd8599c7", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q16", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 7, "questionId": "V19-Q16", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-07.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "921ebb786501d347974f53a0e01fa06168e3f88f10b849e075c7ce498552f007", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "921ebb786501d347974f53a0e01fa06168e3f88f10b849e075c7ce498552f007" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 23, "questionId": "V19-Q16", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-23.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "5370629a6b8f54d4b8f26f83932d250bfa09b892e290658822e49fd569babe51", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "5370629a6b8f54d4b8f26f83932d250bfa09b892e290658822e49fd569babe51" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 2, "questionId": "V19-Q16", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-02.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "17c65c79ee47ff1f82832952ca0b3659a7c2f6718db6b7b75fb887e680ad6ace", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "17c65c79ee47ff1f82832952ca0b3659a7c2f6718db6b7b75fb887e680ad6ace" } ], "frozenStatus": "unresolved", "frozenFactStatus": "unresolved", "responseOnlyStatus": "unresolved", "answerFields": { "helmet_hold": "At least 8 hours before another loan, starting after wiping is complete ." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q16-helmet_hold-1", "field": "helmet_hold", "documentId": "V19-D06", "page": 2, "quote": "After a loan helmet is wiped with the approved cleaner, it remains on the drying shelf for at least 8 hours before another\nloan. The drying period begins after wiping is complete." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q16-helmet_hold-2", "field": "helmet_hold", "documentId": "V19-D06", "page": 2, "quote": "After a loan helmet is wiped with the approved cleaner, it remains on the drying shelf for at least 8 hours before another\nloan. The drying period begins after wiping is complete." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "helmet_hold", "documentId": "V19-D06", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "4" } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct at-least8hours and start after wiping complete; native paraphrase is complete. Frozen unresolved is finite composition conservatism.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "8cee6726030955b641590855e2bbbbf252e5833846a511f1b717488f10b5faf7", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q17", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 31, "questionId": "V19-Q17", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 28, "questionId": "V19-Q17", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 25, "questionId": "V19-Q17", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "scan_timing": "It is not the name of a celestial source or a claim that a detection occurred.\nEach ordinary scan cycle lasts 75 seconds, including a 15-second reference segment at the end." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q17-scan_timing-1", "field": "scan_timing", "documentId": "V19-D07", "page": 1, "quote": "Each ordinary scan cycle lasts 75 seconds, including a 15-second reference segment at the end." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q17-scan_timing-2", "field": "scan_timing", "documentId": "V19-D07", "page": 1, "quote": "Each ordinary scan cycle lasts 75 seconds, including a 15-second reference segment at the end." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "scan_timing", "documentId": "V19-D07", "explicitPage": 1, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct75-second ordinary cycle including15-second reference segment at its end; genuine D07 p1. Copies an unrelated adjacent celestial-source disclaimer, so correct but unnecessarily long.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "aae4887f84034f906af3fd215c2bae72459afc8ac2eb2d4210ddef6ad142ddc0", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q17", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 31, "questionId": "V19-Q17", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-31.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "92a6bc6199a66ff58c24d66f48e31b490b19955dfc0bf8dc0e2c73dadc1d9de4", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "92a6bc6199a66ff58c24d66f48e31b490b19955dfc0bf8dc0e2c73dadc1d9de4" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 28, "questionId": "V19-Q17", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-28.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "2eed2dcd42ed127805b5b552bbeeafe31fca52ab15fd46dff7c9d25b36810a5a", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "2eed2dcd42ed127805b5b552bbeeafe31fca52ab15fd46dff7c9d25b36810a5a" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 25, "questionId": "V19-Q17", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-25.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "cdfad6c1137fa947e9fb674816625c4b06b1ca9ff04982195556b029f4847286", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "cdfad6c1137fa947e9fb674816625c4b06b1ca9ff04982195556b029f4847286" } ], "frozenStatus": "unresolved", "frozenFactStatus": "unresolved", "responseOnlyStatus": "unresolved", "answerFields": { "scan_timing": "75 seconds" }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q17-scan_timing-1", "field": "scan_timing", "documentId": "V19-D07", "page": 1, "quote": "Each ordinary scan cycle lasts 75 seconds, including a 15-second reference segment at the end." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q17-scan_timing-2", "field": "scan_timing", "documentId": "V19-D07", "page": 1, "quote": "Each ordinary scan cycle lasts 75 seconds, including a 15-second reference segment at the end." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "scan_timing", "documentId": "V19-D07", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "4" } ], "independentAssessment": "75seconds alone omits specifically requested15-second reference segment and its inclusion. Genuine incomplete answer; source citation includes both, but cannot fill an absent answer field fact.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "10033e41bb022dfb3557a1f7f1c3902a7882a14ab8c1860034c117b8d5af7bb9", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q18", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 33, "questionId": "V19-Q18", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 26, "questionId": "V19-Q18", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 1, "questionId": "V19-Q18", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "receiver_reset_conditions": "A receiver reset is allowed only after the observation queue is empty and the control log has been saved. Both\nconditions must be satisfied." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q18-receiver_reset_conditions-1", "field": "receiver_reset_conditions", "documentId": "V19-D07", "page": 1, "quote": "A receiver reset is allowed only after the observation queue is empty and the control log has been saved." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q18-receiver_reset_conditions-2", "field": "receiver_reset_conditions", "documentId": "V19-D07", "page": 1, "quote": "A receiver reset is allowed only after the observation queue is empty and the control log has been saved." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "receiver_reset_conditions", "documentId": "V19-D07", "explicitPage": 1, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct both reset prerequisites: queue empty and control log saved; genuine D07 p2. Native supplies an irrelevant historical timing paragraph instead.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "455a236099715752547dce4cd11810949b4d767c3f7c4951070aace7b1fe2550", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q18", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 33, "questionId": "V19-Q18", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-33.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "0da5aa628395d0b7c01b7201d956fe559b694f61e50900a36ab65a95c886eb9e", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "0da5aa628395d0b7c01b7201d956fe559b694f61e50900a36ab65a95c886eb9e" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 26, "questionId": "V19-Q18", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-26.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "a5f536f6742d2304c9f8ee6ff7292e043563dd148368812748a1441ffac094f5", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "a5f536f6742d2304c9f8ee6ff7292e043563dd148368812748a1441ffac094f5" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 1, "questionId": "V19-Q18", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-01.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "3123e54126978c10f497085a42e688e961d260438feaa267dd1ef5976c60028c", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "3123e54126978c10f497085a42e688e961d260438feaa267dd1ef5976c60028c" } ], "frozenStatus": "fail", "frozenFactStatus": "unresolved", "responseOnlyStatus": "fail", "answerFields": { "receiver_reset_conditions": "The current guide increased both durations to support the revised student exercise. A comparison of two semesters should state the guide version. Multiplying an old cycle count by the current duration would produce a false total observing time, even when both sessions used the same target name." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q18-receiver_reset_conditions-1", "field": "receiver_reset_conditions", "documentId": "V19-D07", "page": 1, "quote": "A receiver reset is allowed only after the observation queue is empty and the control log has been saved." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q18-receiver_reset_conditions-2", "field": "receiver_reset_conditions", "documentId": "V19-D07", "page": 1, "quote": "A receiver reset is allowed only after the observation queue is empty and the control log has been saved." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "receiver_reset_conditions", "documentId": "V19-D07", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "2" } ], "independentAssessment": "Answers with historical scan-version comparison paragraph instead of either reset prerequisite; cited chunk is genuine but wrong support for this task. Kingy answers both prerequisites.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "c857919a8bf0e2250289b2b1bbc643ee0f1a2f03b817bbc3f24b2428cb0a682c", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q19", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 38, "questionId": "V19-Q19", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 15, "questionId": "V19-Q19", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 29, "questionId": "V19-Q19", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "fail", "frozenFactStatus": "fail", "responseOnlyStatus": "fail", "answerFields": {}, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q19-custodian_name-1", "field": "custodian_name", "documentId": "V19-D07", "page": 1, "quote": "The evening session custodian is Rina Solberg." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Declines answerable current custodian Rina Solberg. Focused question drops the preceding Quartzline/current/evening-custodian sentence; candidates contain no Rina and selected D07 p1 discusses duties without naming her. Native supplies the current name.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "3bd27c444bea784ba54f0e586e114351404ca5c404a90a84df969b5b69ce0cd8", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q19", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 38, "questionId": "V19-Q19", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-38.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "6a717e04ef02fe3105420112db8d142cef36031e26e9039337c3210d9c968af6", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "6a717e04ef02fe3105420112db8d142cef36031e26e9039337c3210d9c968af6" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 15, "questionId": "V19-Q19", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-15.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "94c71ac58b71308a7829b7ae81b97479799d561fa5aa1374e35d8d582741816e", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "94c71ac58b71308a7829b7ae81b97479799d561fa5aa1374e35d8d582741816e" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 29, "questionId": "V19-Q19", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-29.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "d6df6bdd996ced45fc49c6f3e27d9dc9a4f51c309268d3f65f812cfcbfc2bffd", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "d6df6bdd996ced45fc49c6f3e27d9dc9a4f51c309268d3f65f812cfcbfc2bffd" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "custodian_name": "Rina Solberg" }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q19-custodian_name-1", "field": "custodian_name", "documentId": "V19-D07", "page": 1, "quote": "The evening session custodian is Rina Solberg." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "custodian_name", "documentId": "V19-D07", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "4" } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct current custodian Rina Solberg with valid current D07 citation. Clear advantage over Kingy decline.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "4210e37d33a2c1a2ef7e61177af762cec76f871fe0d5938c08d57ebc24edc163", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q20", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 25, "questionId": "V19-Q20", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 6, "questionId": "V19-Q20", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 16, "questionId": "V19-Q20", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "cold_review": "Each\ncard follows its vessel through preparation, the monitored room, and the cold-review shelf.\nA batch transferred to cold review remains there for at least 18 hours before the instructor evaluates it. The time starts\nwhen the sealed vessel reaches the cold-review shelf." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q20-cold_review-1", "field": "cold_review", "documentId": "V19-D08", "page": 1, "quote": "A batch transferred to cold review remains there for at least 18 hours before the instructor evaluates it. The time starts\nwhen the sealed vessel reaches the cold-review shelf." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q20-cold_review-2", "field": "cold_review", "documentId": "V19-D08", "page": 1, "quote": "A batch transferred to cold review remains there for at least 18 hours before the instructor evaluates it. The time starts\nwhen the sealed vessel reaches the cold-review shelf." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "cold_review", "documentId": "V19-D08", "explicitPage": 1, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct current minimum18-hour cold review and sealed-vessel-arrival start; genuine D08 p1. Native answers archived12hours and omits start.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "fdfc086723f1c163d87823ed29edb6b8825e4b852448b87bd9c9cfd674beb19c", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q20", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 25, "questionId": "V19-Q20", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-25.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "4ca5c9cf5cae7c0b77d38d6dd1f2eb75a2f1a036c689ad38916ff3d5faa077b5", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "4ca5c9cf5cae7c0b77d38d6dd1f2eb75a2f1a036c689ad38916ff3d5faa077b5" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 6, "questionId": "V19-Q20", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-06.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "dd32416ddf057978a86670d5cbf66846fab44dae545a666d763a53cb742ea6d0", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "dd32416ddf057978a86670d5cbf66846fab44dae545a666d763a53cb742ea6d0" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 16, "questionId": "V19-Q20", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-16.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "fde829612b10c5d9f575a9b8a8bc9ca7cb66a02cfa42f79bf1cc4119e08c8f72", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "fde829612b10c5d9f575a9b8a8bc9ca7cb66a02cfa42f79bf1cc4119e08c8f72" } ], "frozenStatus": "fail", "frozenFactStatus": "unresolved", "responseOnlyStatus": "fail", "answerFields": { "cold_review": "12 hours" }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q20-cold_review-1", "field": "cold_review", "documentId": "V19-D08", "page": 1, "quote": "A batch transferred to cold review remains there for at least 18 hours before the instructor evaluates it. The time starts\nwhen the sealed vessel reaches the cold-review shelf." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q20-cold_review-2", "field": "cold_review", "documentId": "V19-D08", "page": 1, "quote": "A batch transferred to cold review remains there for at least 18 hours before the instructor evaluates it. The time starts\nwhen the sealed vessel reaches the cold-review shelf." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "cold_review", "documentId": "V19-D08", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "3" } ], "independentAssessment": "12hours is the archived value, not current minimum18hours, and starting event is absent. Citation points to historical material; real current-rule failure.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "aed3d5842ea3aeb061df05f28da21496a117976d5ec76e05fadc6d3ec1921321", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q21", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 16, "questionId": "V19-Q21", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 30, "questionId": "V19-Q21", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 38, "questionId": "V19-Q21", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "brine_ratio": "The demonstration brine uses 24 grams of salt per liter of water. The ratio is based on the water volume before\nvegetables are added, not on the final filled-vessel volume." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q21-brine_ratio-1", "field": "brine_ratio", "documentId": "V19-D08", "page": 1, "quote": "The demonstration brine uses 24 grams of salt per liter of water. The ratio is based on the water volume before\nvegetables are added, not on the final filled-vessel volume." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q21-brine_ratio-2", "field": "brine_ratio", "documentId": "V19-D08", "page": 1, "quote": "The demonstration brine uses 24 grams of salt per liter of water. The ratio is based on the water volume before\nvegetables are added, not on the final filled-vessel volume." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "brine_ratio", "documentId": "V19-D08", "explicitPage": 1, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct24g/L and explicit pre-vegetable water-volume basis; genuine D08 p1. Native gives only ratio, without the explicitly requested before-vegetables basis.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "c401bddc2dc9d1960aaf9b5ee85e892a327adeb2fff121c4be70c18d3689f638", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q21", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 16, "questionId": "V19-Q21", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-16.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "ec9fef74d1570446439c7efa93f4265c210338c18870b1888f3d4007fb10ea75", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "ec9fef74d1570446439c7efa93f4265c210338c18870b1888f3d4007fb10ea75" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 30, "questionId": "V19-Q21", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-30.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "2cbfda1afca0c21db77cabc5c8a667e9152b30a60d80aff59037745a1ee33e1b", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "2cbfda1afca0c21db77cabc5c8a667e9152b30a60d80aff59037745a1ee33e1b" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 38, "questionId": "V19-Q21", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-38.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "9af33f7f853013f15db8faf39a8a5217c1e5c60333ae7c82c1e25fcfbdede224", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "9af33f7f853013f15db8faf39a8a5217c1e5c60333ae7c82c1e25fcfbdede224" } ], "frozenStatus": "unresolved", "frozenFactStatus": "unresolved", "responseOnlyStatus": "unresolved", "answerFields": { "brine_ratio": "24 grams of salt per liter of water." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q21-brine_ratio-1", "field": "brine_ratio", "documentId": "V19-D08", "page": 1, "quote": "The demonstration brine uses 24 grams of salt per liter of water. The ratio is based on the water volume before\nvegetables are added, not on the final filled-vessel volume." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q21-brine_ratio-2", "field": "brine_ratio", "documentId": "V19-D08", "page": 1, "quote": "The demonstration brine uses 24 grams of salt per liter of water. The ratio is based on the water volume before\nvegetables are added, not on the final filled-vessel volume." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "brine_ratio", "documentId": "V19-D08", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "5" } ], "independentAssessment": "24g/L is correct but answer does not state the requested pre-vegetable water-volume basis. Do not equate genuine citation coverage with explicit task completeness.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "cbd1fc14104a63e9bca9a6277ab7cd4f89a5967e0e788050d91c966fc1797f53", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q22", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 10, "questionId": "V19-Q22", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 13, "questionId": "V19-Q22", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 10, "questionId": "V19-Q22", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "visitor_cordon": "During a public demonstration, the visitor cordon is at least 1.6 meters from the robot's starting marker. The distance is\nmeasured from the marker to the nearest part of the standing line, not from the robot after it has moved. The operator\nchecks the line before each session. If a visitor enters the zone, the operator pauses the demonstration and asks the\nfloor assistant to restore the cordon." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q22-visitor_cordon-1", "field": "visitor_cordon", "documentId": "V19-D09", "page": 1, "quote": "During a public demonstration, the visitor cordon is at least 1.6 meters from the robot's starting marker." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q22-visitor_cordon-2", "field": "visitor_cordon", "documentId": "V19-D09", "page": 1, "quote": "During a public demonstration, the visitor cordon is at least 1.6 meters from the robot's starting marker." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "visitor_cordon", "documentId": "V19-D09", "explicitPage": 1, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct minimum1.6m from starting marker; genuine D09 p1. Long supported paragraph includes unrequested procedure; native shorter value/location is semantically adequate in minimum-question context.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "2f386de037e3f504bba91c82fdc8675490c0710ae77123df51f7ff80a40c87a1", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q22", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 10, "questionId": "V19-Q22", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-10.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "1f08700b85db853a59142f0566ad0596714dc51dc053a5a35de5e5c4be3e5a57", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "1f08700b85db853a59142f0566ad0596714dc51dc053a5a35de5e5c4be3e5a57" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 13, "questionId": "V19-Q22", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-13.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "b26ebc84be0e72724f164b9c36aedf7310ccfec2dd7abbd3c7db96055c91a3e5", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "b26ebc84be0e72724f164b9c36aedf7310ccfec2dd7abbd3c7db96055c91a3e5" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 10, "questionId": "V19-Q22", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-10.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "71ac7f8e6cf8085fe2ff45a372eb60fcedb067a34ccf829f0fb2887cce14fca4", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "71ac7f8e6cf8085fe2ff45a372eb60fcedb067a34ccf829f0fb2887cce14fca4" } ], "frozenStatus": "unresolved", "frozenFactStatus": "unresolved", "responseOnlyStatus": "unresolved", "answerFields": { "visitor_cordon": "1.6 meters from the robot's starting marker ." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q22-visitor_cordon-1", "field": "visitor_cordon", "documentId": "V19-D09", "page": 1, "quote": "During a public demonstration, the visitor cordon is at least 1.6 meters from the robot's starting marker." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q22-visitor_cordon-2", "field": "visitor_cordon", "documentId": "V19-D09", "page": 1, "quote": "During a public demonstration, the visitor cordon is at least 1.6 meters from the robot's starting marker." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "visitor_cordon", "documentId": "V19-D09", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "7" } ], "independentAssessment": "1.6m from robot starting marker answers the requested minimum value/location in context. Missing at least is not evidence of a wrong distance; frozen unresolved remains conservative, not wrong.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "eae414253f9d351ca01fb250c974f7b17eba8f4d631757e64ff489b70d16ce68", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q23", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 32, "questionId": "V19-Q23", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 1, "questionId": "V19-Q23", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 6, "questionId": "V19-Q23", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "debrief_deadline": "After an unplanned demonstration stop, the operator files a debrief within 40 minutes after the session ends. The\nsession end is the event that starts the deadline, not the instant of the stop. The debrief names the session, records\nwhat staff observed, and lists any equipment removed from use." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q23-debrief_deadline-1", "field": "debrief_deadline", "documentId": "V19-D09", "page": 1, "quote": "After an unplanned demonstration stop, the operator files a debrief within 40 minutes after the session ends." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q23-debrief_deadline-2", "field": "debrief_deadline", "documentId": "V19-D09", "page": 1, "quote": "After an unplanned demonstration stop, the operator files a debrief within 40 minutes after the session ends." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "debrief_deadline", "documentId": "V19-D09", "explicitPage": 1, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct within40minutes after session ends, explicitly distinguishes session end from stop; genuine D09 p1. Native incorrectly claims exact deadline unspecified.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "5ae1dc0a9206b518e726bb19f7d9a1a29c27effeed2abee4674577155397fa2c", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q23", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 32, "questionId": "V19-Q23", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-32.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "e747b5a21cb3aac27577bafe63e6e60788f3cca132f4804ab0726fa47cbb5451", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "e747b5a21cb3aac27577bafe63e6e60788f3cca132f4804ab0726fa47cbb5451" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 1, "questionId": "V19-Q23", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-01.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "fa6065e87bb42f72cd9f5554f86de99dd53a9d75fee57d40fbaecc411ebba07d", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "fa6065e87bb42f72cd9f5554f86de99dd53a9d75fee57d40fbaecc411ebba07d" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 6, "questionId": "V19-Q23", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-06.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "c7905da89f3b18fa102a3d3825acd40e371ccd9e6a61175d6888988034d29f5c", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "c7905da89f3b18fa102a3d3825acd40e371ccd9e6a61175d6888988034d29f5c" } ], "frozenStatus": "fail", "frozenFactStatus": "unresolved", "responseOnlyStatus": "fail", "answerFields": { "debrief_deadline": "The debrief deadline is described as \"a debrief deadline\" in the document, but the exact value is not specified. UNKNOWN" }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q23-debrief_deadline-1", "field": "debrief_deadline", "documentId": "V19-D09", "page": 1, "quote": "After an unplanned demonstration stop, the operator files a debrief within 40 minutes after the session ends." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q23-debrief_deadline-2", "field": "debrief_deadline", "documentId": "V19-D09", "page": 1, "quote": "After an unplanned demonstration stop, the operator files a debrief within 40 minutes after the session ends." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "debrief_deadline", "documentId": "V19-D09", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "7" } ], "independentAssessment": "Claims exact debrief deadline is unspecified/UNKNOWN despite current40minutes after session end. Cites a genuine irrelevant scope passage. Real false documentary-absence answer.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "99278252c3436e40c87e42e8ed210bcb02fe5c4a03698192bea5a6ac2b6893cf", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q24", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 19, "questionId": "V19-Q24", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 11, "questionId": "V19-Q24", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 17, "questionId": "V19-Q24", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "fail", "frozenFactStatus": "fail", "responseOnlyStatus": "fail", "answerFields": {}, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q24-routine_revisit-1", "field": "routine_revisit", "documentId": "V19-D10", "page": 1, "quote": "After a routine water-depth reading, the same observation point is revisited 6 hours later." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Declines answerable current6-hour revisit although a correct6-hour candidate exists. Selects archived R3 four-hour passage instead; sufficiency rejects it. Native returns that obsolete4hours, so neither completes the current task.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "5095fb82393cc3a63e1be63051c733de8a89907523c69986bed86bc20f9173f9", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q24", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 19, "questionId": "V19-Q24", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-19.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "a9e6d8abc6d24ec71e363d5c87d7cbd900ff3ddd9ed31060325d2dae401247e9", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "a9e6d8abc6d24ec71e363d5c87d7cbd900ff3ddd9ed31060325d2dae401247e9" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 11, "questionId": "V19-Q24", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-11.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "0bade0fb9d02896f2af4d37c86b6a18180407c885cc883ee89d4fe7d29c78358", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "0bade0fb9d02896f2af4d37c86b6a18180407c885cc883ee89d4fe7d29c78358" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 17, "questionId": "V19-Q24", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-17.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "a1009800c8f83809ebdaf86bd802c0ff50afda0c2b721818ae0341bb23d5abf5", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "a1009800c8f83809ebdaf86bd802c0ff50afda0c2b721818ae0341bb23d5abf5" } ], "frozenStatus": "fail", "frozenFactStatus": "fail", "responseOnlyStatus": "fail", "answerFields": { "routine_revisit": "4 hours" }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q24-routine_revisit-1", "field": "routine_revisit", "documentId": "V19-D10", "page": 1, "quote": "After a routine water-depth reading, the same observation point is revisited 6 hours later." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "routine_revisit", "documentId": "V19-D10", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "5" } ], "independentAssessment": "4hours is archived R3, not current R4 six-hour revisit. Both systems fail the current task; Kingy declines instead of asserting old value.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "c8733a70182fd32da11e20a3ddfd24ea7e0d30957caf23d5c34b716e44129675", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q25", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 15, "questionId": "V19-Q25", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 35, "questionId": "V19-Q25", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 27, "questionId": "V19-Q25", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "crate_limit": "At dispatch, each sealed crate may weigh at most 18 kilograms, including its reusable liner. The crate lid is weighed\nwith the crate and must never be listed as separate packaging. A crate above the limit is divided into two crates even if\nthe courier offers to lift it. The dispatcher retains both weight tickets with the same dispatch record.", "helmet_release": "A replacement helmet is recorded against the loan so the inventory can distinguish the item\noriginally issued from a later replacement.\nAfter a loan helmet is wiped with the approved cleaner, it remains on the drying shelf for at least 8 hours before another\nloan." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q25-crate_limit-1", "field": "crate_limit", "documentId": "V19-D01", "page": 2, "quote": "At dispatch, each sealed crate may weigh at most 18 kilograms, including its reusable liner." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q25-crate_limit-2", "field": "crate_limit", "documentId": "V19-D01", "page": 2, "quote": "At dispatch, each sealed crate may weigh at most 18 kilograms, including its reusable liner." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q25-helmet_release-1", "field": "helmet_release", "documentId": "V19-D06", "page": 2, "quote": "After a loan helmet is wiped with the approved cleaner, it remains on the drying shelf for at least 8 hours before another\nloan." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "crate_limit", "documentId": "V19-D01", "explicitPage": 2, "nativeId": null }, { "field": "helmet_release", "documentId": "V19-D06", "explicitPage": 2, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Both requested logistics entries complete: ≤18kg including liner and minimum8-hour helmet hold. Genuine D01 p2/D06 p2; copied adjacent replacement context is verbose. Native compact values also complete this question.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "c4e5d04ed62cf76bf2abc24036dcb5606abba2500f568c60f9274406a3cb2edb", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q25", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 15, "questionId": "V19-Q25", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-15.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "aa2d85abc3e7b5b96973597e1225cd14846ef6ec2baaf5855b42cd30564a75e1", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "aa2d85abc3e7b5b96973597e1225cd14846ef6ec2baaf5855b42cd30564a75e1" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 35, "questionId": "V19-Q25", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-35.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "425e867ccb0f6d1be16192a42149919d4fe579f18e532404cb760eba51c505f9", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "425e867ccb0f6d1be16192a42149919d4fe579f18e532404cb760eba51c505f9" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 27, "questionId": "V19-Q25", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-27.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "642ecd81b28285d4386e5af9640a8bffec23ac060d009b9bd812346a22b875df", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "642ecd81b28285d4386e5af9640a8bffec23ac060d009b9bd812346a22b875df" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "crate_limit": "18 kilograms, including its reusable liner", "helmet_release": "8 hours" }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q25-crate_limit-1", "field": "crate_limit", "documentId": "V19-D01", "page": 2, "quote": "At dispatch, each sealed crate may weigh at most 18 kilograms, including its reusable liner." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q25-crate_limit-2", "field": "crate_limit", "documentId": "V19-D01", "page": 2, "quote": "At dispatch, each sealed crate may weigh at most 18 kilograms, including its reusable liner." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q25-helmet_release-1", "field": "helmet_release", "documentId": "V19-D06", "page": 2, "quote": "After a loan helmet is wiped with the approved cleaner, it remains on the drying shelf for at least 8 hours before another\nloan." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "crate_limit", "documentId": "V19-D01", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "1" }, { "field": "helmet_release", "documentId": "V19-D06", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "6" } ], "independentAssessment": "Both current fields complete:18kg including liner and8-hour minimum hold in question context, with relevant citations. Much shorter than correct Kingy excerpts.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "35e8cbf84ad0e8c9ef5d72c148a0a2048dc5d4322e825da6ae79a30cae40013c", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q26", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 13, "questionId": "V19-Q26", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 12, "questionId": "V19-Q26", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 9, "questionId": "V19-Q26", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "courier_authority": "A courier release requires the conservation lead's signature; a client email does not waive that signature requirement.", "school_pupil_cap": "A school demonstration session admits at most 17 pupils, excluding accompanying adults. The pupil cap applies\nseparately to each session." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q26-courier_authority-1", "field": "courier_authority", "documentId": "V19-D02", "page": 2, "quote": "A courier release requires the conservation lead's signature; a client email does not waive that signature requirement." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q26-courier_authority-2", "field": "courier_authority", "documentId": "V19-D02", "page": 2, "quote": "A courier release requires the conservation lead's signature; a client email does not waive that signature requirement." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q26-school_pupil_cap-1", "field": "school_pupil_cap", "documentId": "V19-D09", "page": 2, "quote": "A school demonstration session admits at most 17 pupils, excluding accompanying adults." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q26-school_pupil_cap-2", "field": "school_pupil_cap", "documentId": "V19-D09", "page": 2, "quote": "A school demonstration session admits at most 17 pupils, excluding accompanying adults." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "courier_authority", "documentId": "V19-D02", "explicitPage": 2, "nativeId": null }, { "field": "school_pupil_cap", "documentId": "V19-D09", "explicitPage": 2, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Both current rules complete: lead signature/nonwaiver by client email and17pupils excluding adults. Genuine D02 p2/D09 p2; native paraphrases also convey all facts.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "5ba0a2ff6b0df278b8bc5e5f70a0e699c287460bbaee8fa709eeb89ba5fb4d99", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q26", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 13, "questionId": "V19-Q26", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-13.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "4fba57d1dc49672748904865007eca8bc7a38980f3ac5641758d791eb759f1ff", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "4fba57d1dc49672748904865007eca8bc7a38980f3ac5641758d791eb759f1ff" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 12, "questionId": "V19-Q26", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-12.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "45b66f1e94a06195ad2453550e1dab6e873877969be7b2c6e4796a69edecdf4c", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "45b66f1e94a06195ad2453550e1dab6e873877969be7b2c6e4796a69edecdf4c" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 9, "questionId": "V19-Q26", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-09.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "877e7e408711c4e5f784338b7c0eb8a6616be4eb667857632caa991685631ded", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "877e7e408711c4e5f784338b7c0eb8a6616be4eb667857632caa991685631ded" } ], "frozenStatus": "unresolved", "frozenFactStatus": "unresolved", "responseOnlyStatus": "unresolved", "answerFields": { "courier_authority": "The conservation lead's signature is required for a courier release; a client email does not waive that signature requirement .", "school_pupil_cap": "The Kestrel Robotics Museum allows a maximum of 17 pupils per demonstration session, excluding accompanying adults; accompanying adults do not count toward the pupil cap ." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q26-courier_authority-1", "field": "courier_authority", "documentId": "V19-D02", "page": 2, "quote": "A courier release requires the conservation lead's signature; a client email does not waive that signature requirement." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q26-courier_authority-2", "field": "courier_authority", "documentId": "V19-D02", "page": 2, "quote": "A courier release requires the conservation lead's signature; a client email does not waive that signature requirement." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q26-school_pupil_cap-1", "field": "school_pupil_cap", "documentId": "V19-D09", "page": 2, "quote": "A school demonstration session admits at most 17 pupils, excluding accompanying adults." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q26-school_pupil_cap-2", "field": "school_pupil_cap", "documentId": "V19-D09", "page": 2, "quote": "A school demonstration session admits at most 17 pupils, excluding accompanying adults." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "courier_authority", "documentId": "V19-D02", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "2" }, { "field": "school_pupil_cap", "documentId": "V19-D09", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "3" } ], "independentAssessment": "Lead signature required/client email cannot waive, and maximum17pupils excluding adults, are all conveyed. Frozen unresolved is finite paraphrase/composition conservatism; no Kingy semantic-accuracy advantage here.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "a524181e03ba4fb2b6cb0d606625ef0711fc78ebd7ed7aec1b2e224af851497e", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q27", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 39, "questionId": "V19-Q27", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 8, "questionId": "V19-Q27", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 32, "questionId": "V19-Q27", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "fail", "frozenFactStatus": "fail", "responseOnlyStatus": "fail", "answerFields": {}, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q27-storm_report-1", "field": "storm_report", "documentId": "V19-D03", "page": 2, "quote": "A storm interruption report must reach the research office within 14 calendar hours after the vessel returns to the base\npier." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q27-storm_report-2", "field": "storm_report", "documentId": "V19-D03", "page": 2, "quote": "A storm interruption report must reach the research office within 14 calendar hours after the vessel returns to the base\npier." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q27-outlet_reinspection-1", "field": "outlet_reinspection", "documentId": "V19-D10", "page": 2, "quote": "After an overflow, the crew reinspects the outlet only after water has remained below the painted rim for 5 continuous\nhours." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q27-outlet_reinspection-2", "field": "outlet_reinspection", "documentId": "V19-D10", "page": 2, "quote": "After an overflow, the crew reinspects the outlet only after water has remained below the painted rim for 5 continuous\nhours." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Global decline after first storm-report selection supplies heading/initial safety check rather than deadline;14hours/return-to-base start absent from candidate set. No outlet field attempt follows. Native gives useful complete deadline/event and5continuous below-rim hours in the requested field context.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "ecc83c006c624fa148f8c61f7150f89e8a5d31cd98ba1fa1da9fe542306a7588", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q27", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 39, "questionId": "V19-Q27", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-39.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "3925102fdb5a129c209dbf1e4c30fb12ba15fe1a9b0717d814a81ee6c9f40b87", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "3925102fdb5a129c209dbf1e4c30fb12ba15fe1a9b0717d814a81ee6c9f40b87" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 8, "questionId": "V19-Q27", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-08.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "9215de27777d7f2196da0908051c4cebee0a64834fc053e93d27de063d9d1aa4", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "9215de27777d7f2196da0908051c4cebee0a64834fc053e93d27de063d9d1aa4" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 32, "questionId": "V19-Q27", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-32.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "2d0311542e1046a1dc51c891e89209e716bde784082cc8772fa25153303c49c6", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "2d0311542e1046a1dc51c891e89209e716bde784082cc8772fa25153303c49c6" } ], "frozenStatus": "unresolved", "frozenFactStatus": "unresolved", "responseOnlyStatus": "unresolved", "answerFields": { "storm_report": "14 calendar hours after the vessel returns to the base pier", "outlet_reinspection": "5 continuous hours below the painted rim" }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q27-storm_report-1", "field": "storm_report", "documentId": "V19-D03", "page": 2, "quote": "A storm interruption report must reach the research office within 14 calendar hours after the vessel returns to the base\npier." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q27-storm_report-2", "field": "storm_report", "documentId": "V19-D03", "page": 2, "quote": "A storm interruption report must reach the research office within 14 calendar hours after the vessel returns to the base\npier." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q27-outlet_reinspection-1", "field": "outlet_reinspection", "documentId": "V19-D10", "page": 2, "quote": "After an overflow, the crew reinspects the outlet only after water has remained below the painted rim for 5 continuous\nhours." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q27-outlet_reinspection-2", "field": "outlet_reinspection", "documentId": "V19-D10", "page": 2, "quote": "After an overflow, the crew reinspects the outlet only after water has remained below the painted rim for 5 continuous\nhours." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "storm_report", "documentId": "V19-D03", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "1" }, { "field": "outlet_reinspection", "documentId": "V19-D10", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "2" } ], "independentAssessment": "14calendar hours after vessel returns to base pier supplies deadline/event in deadline-question context;5continuous hours below painted rim supplies outlet interval. within is implicit in the requested deadline, so do not label this useful supported response wrong. Kingy declines whole task.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "05889d5c9d71e506235fd745a8ec71e0ad44cd05dcd840100146cce84e8c4387", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q28", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 9, "questionId": "V19-Q28", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 7, "questionId": "V19-Q28", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 7, "questionId": "V19-Q28", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "fail", "frozenFactStatus": "fail", "responseOnlyStatus": "fail", "answerFields": {}, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q28-loan_exception_fee-1", "field": "loan_exception_fee", "documentId": "V19-D04", "page": 2, "quote": "An approved facsimile-loan exception carries an administration fee of 0 dollars, including requests received on a\nSaturday." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q28-batch_discard_condition-1", "field": "batch_discard_condition", "documentId": "V19-D08", "page": 2, "quote": "A batch is discarded if its recorded room exposure is above 29 degrees Celsius for more than 3 continuous hours." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q28-batch_discard_condition-2", "field": "batch_discard_condition", "documentId": "V19-D08", "page": 2, "quote": "A batch is discarded if its recorded room exposure is above 29 degrees Celsius for more than 3 continuous hours." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Whole answer declined. Loan fee field individually obtains correct0-dollar source, but batch field selects cold-review text instead of discard threshold; global abstention suppresses the valid first field. Native supplies fee but fails to express strict discard comparisons, so neither completes whole task.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "f0989024b8abd3f4f2ac3fabf95651b096f60e9fbb12486062e4f4038af02c50", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q28", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 9, "questionId": "V19-Q28", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-09.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "4578255a6b726f63cc0b7ffd0b6a5c72aaee3f65708abf831bbfaa2794596e41", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "4578255a6b726f63cc0b7ffd0b6a5c72aaee3f65708abf831bbfaa2794596e41" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 7, "questionId": "V19-Q28", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-07.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "70e68a2287dd5271b5b3c160697025900eff6738315018ab78a097a99573be93", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "70e68a2287dd5271b5b3c160697025900eff6738315018ab78a097a99573be93" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 7, "questionId": "V19-Q28", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-07.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "8c219277085735a3ea43e75d4480ecf4423d9a76bdecb08ff733cf8115f37ccf", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "8c219277085735a3ea43e75d4480ecf4423d9a76bdecb08ff733cf8115f37ccf" } ], "frozenStatus": "unresolved", "frozenFactStatus": "unresolved", "responseOnlyStatus": "unresolved", "answerFields": { "loan_exception_fee": "0 dollars", "batch_discard_condition": "29 degrees Celsius and 3 continuous hours" }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q28-loan_exception_fee-1", "field": "loan_exception_fee", "documentId": "V19-D04", "page": 2, "quote": "An approved facsimile-loan exception carries an administration fee of 0 dollars, including requests received on a\nSaturday." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q28-batch_discard_condition-1", "field": "batch_discard_condition", "documentId": "V19-D08", "page": 2, "quote": "A batch is discarded if its recorded room exposure is above 29 degrees Celsius for more than 3 continuous hours." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q28-batch_discard_condition-2", "field": "batch_discard_condition", "documentId": "V19-D08", "page": 2, "quote": "A batch is discarded if its recorded room exposure is above 29 degrees Celsius for more than 3 continuous hours." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "loan_exception_fee", "documentId": "V19-D04", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "1" }, { "field": "batch_discard_condition", "documentId": "V19-D08", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "3" } ], "independentAssessment": "0-dollar exception fee correct, but29°C and3continuous hours omit both strict above/more-than comparisons required for discard. Useful partial answer, not complete current condition; Kingy whole decline also fails.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "62ce194b189d04a327d277833b5e9536f669a70efffb80070b658a1e2aa7c88c", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q29", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 6, "questionId": "V19-Q29", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 25, "questionId": "V19-Q29", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 18, "questionId": "V19-Q29", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "battery_replacement": "A battery pack is replaced when its resting voltage is below 11.7 volts after a 20-minute disconnected rest. The voltage\nthreshold and the rest period both belong to this rule.", "calibrator_rate": "The reference calibrator emits 4 pulses per second during the stability check. The assistant counts pulses over the\nmarked check interval and writes the count beside the session identifier. An old front-panel sticker shows another rate\nand is covered by a revision label. The control guide defines the current rate." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q29-battery_replacement-1", "field": "battery_replacement", "documentId": "V19-D05", "page": 2, "quote": "A battery pack is replaced when its resting voltage is below 11.7 volts after a 20-minute disconnected rest." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q29-battery_replacement-2", "field": "battery_replacement", "documentId": "V19-D05", "page": 2, "quote": "A battery pack is replaced when its resting voltage is below 11.7 volts after a 20-minute disconnected rest." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q29-calibrator_rate-1", "field": "calibrator_rate", "documentId": "V19-D07", "page": 2, "quote": "The reference calibrator emits 4 pulses per second during the stability check." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "battery_replacement", "documentId": "V19-D05", "explicitPage": 2, "nativeId": null }, { "field": "calibrator_rate", "documentId": "V19-D07", "explicitPage": 2, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Both fields complete: below11.7V after20-minute disconnected rest and calibrator4pulses/s. Genuine D05 p2/D07 p2. Native omits voltage direction but retains rest and pulse rate.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "f15b1e85ad9f9f2596b93bb5be29cebe1a144af2ac3e995ce08d59501b7576ff", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q29", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 6, "questionId": "V19-Q29", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-06.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "e6ab5576cf1cb4b45f3e6627d6d8d7d71269767cac24e8228916b92589ce07d8", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "e6ab5576cf1cb4b45f3e6627d6d8d7d71269767cac24e8228916b92589ce07d8" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 25, "questionId": "V19-Q29", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-25.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "39dac066c6e7cb8b2f2dc65ef0977138835e3a5025551d4c9443669392a49b7b", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "39dac066c6e7cb8b2f2dc65ef0977138835e3a5025551d4c9443669392a49b7b" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 18, "questionId": "V19-Q29", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-18.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "b911942fca273888f63e7ae8ced99665eb07e00d3c26289a17bb4c886e9e2c98", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "b911942fca273888f63e7ae8ced99665eb07e00d3c26289a17bb4c886e9e2c98" } ], "frozenStatus": "unresolved", "frozenFactStatus": "unresolved", "responseOnlyStatus": "unresolved", "answerFields": { "battery_replacement": "11.7 volts, 20-minute disconnected rest", "calibrator_rate": "4 pulses per second" }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q29-battery_replacement-1", "field": "battery_replacement", "documentId": "V19-D05", "page": 2, "quote": "A battery pack is replaced when its resting voltage is below 11.7 volts after a 20-minute disconnected rest." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q29-battery_replacement-2", "field": "battery_replacement", "documentId": "V19-D05", "page": 2, "quote": "A battery pack is replaced when its resting voltage is below 11.7 volts after a 20-minute disconnected rest." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q29-calibrator_rate-1", "field": "calibrator_rate", "documentId": "V19-D07", "page": 2, "quote": "The reference calibrator emits 4 pulses per second during the stability check." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "battery_replacement", "documentId": "V19-D05", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "4" }, { "field": "calibrator_rate", "documentId": "V19-D07", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "2" } ], "independentAssessment": "4pulses/s and20-minute rest correct, but11.7V alone does not establish below-versus-above replacement direction. Cannot import that direction from a threshold question. Incomplete voltage rule.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "000ae1a90b1a250d3b68077b33b354cfd4cd90a25008bf0c4fa22b3dbcc19dd2", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q30", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 28, "questionId": "V19-Q30", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 2, "questionId": "V19-Q30", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 30, "questionId": "V19-Q30", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "late_return_fee": "The late-return fee is 0 dollars per calendar day. Staff still record the number of late days so that the cooperative can\nstudy availability. Zero is an explicit fee value and must not be shown as an empty amount. The fee does not excuse a\nborrower from returning the bicycle.", "soil_check_fee": "The resident soil-check service has a fee of 0 dollars per submitted sample." }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q30-late_return_fee-1", "field": "late_return_fee", "documentId": "V19-D06", "page": 1, "quote": "The late-return fee is 0 dollars per calendar day." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q30-soil_check_fee-1", "field": "soil_check_fee", "documentId": "V19-D10", "page": 1, "quote": "The resident soil-check service has a fee of 0 dollars per submitted sample." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "late_return_fee", "documentId": "V19-D06", "explicitPage": 1, "nativeId": null }, { "field": "soil_check_fee", "documentId": "V19-D10", "explicitPage": 1, "nativeId": null } ], "independentAssessment": "Both zero amounts and charging bases correct:0$/calendar day and0$/submitted sample. Genuine D06 p1/D10 p1; native concise values also correct.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "948bdee3fecf1897fff3b96f46ba34598f57a51df5140344c5796b6a6c09b284", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q30", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 28, "questionId": "V19-Q30", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-28.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "ba0fc3222a688f07762aa7299cfbbbcfcac46031c94f0cc2f28cff1597178969", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "ba0fc3222a688f07762aa7299cfbbbcfcac46031c94f0cc2f28cff1597178969" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 2, "questionId": "V19-Q30", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-02.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "0e4733f429b77352c88352d3d14d41618f53ed2ff07af5f34b712aedeb616ea3", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "0e4733f429b77352c88352d3d14d41618f53ed2ff07af5f34b712aedeb616ea3" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 30, "questionId": "V19-Q30", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-30.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "349d6b7139ffcd68c30a1263fc4627440ff3487f630268869a6ef50f00fbfba9", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "349d6b7139ffcd68c30a1263fc4627440ff3487f630268869a6ef50f00fbfba9" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": "pass", "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "late_return_fee": "0 dollars per calendar day", "soil_check_fee": "0 dollars per submitted sample" }, "abstain": false, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [ { "claimId": "V19-Q30-late_return_fee-1", "field": "late_return_fee", "documentId": "V19-D06", "page": 1, "quote": "The late-return fee is 0 dollars per calendar day." }, { "claimId": "V19-Q30-soil_check_fee-1", "field": "soil_check_fee", "documentId": "V19-D10", "page": 1, "quote": "The resident soil-check service has a fee of 0 dollars per submitted sample." } ], "returnedCitationMetadata": [ { "field": "late_return_fee", "documentId": "V19-D06", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "8" }, { "field": "soil_check_fee", "documentId": "V19-D10", "explicitPage": null, "nativeId": "3" } ], "independentAssessment": "Correct concise0$/calendar day and0$/submitted sample, both charging bases retained with supporting citations.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "50809cdea1d326baf891c4c59d009aff72fb09d3f32315d6e6362a617099b50c", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q31", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 26, "questionId": "V19-Q31", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 14, "questionId": "V19-Q31", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 40, "questionId": "V19-Q31", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": {}, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct clean UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet. Documentary abstention, not a factual zero or an outside-world claim.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "2bcf18014297dba7f1e2a7c9ffc1de108897b59607de01a324f1bf9607bbe629", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q31", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 26, "questionId": "V19-Q31", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-26.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "a8c46403cc591f29e7db13406eb0f0806151ec3c88cb0edd16ff520aa0037313", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "a8c46403cc591f29e7db13406eb0f0806151ec3c88cb0edd16ff520aa0037313" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 14, "questionId": "V19-Q31", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-14.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "3d4c208cae97f6f240bc3f12ddeba959cdc068b7961ba8fa9a15ada031e6199a", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "3d4c208cae97f6f240bc3f12ddeba959cdc068b7961ba8fa9a15ada031e6199a" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 40, "questionId": "V19-Q31", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-40.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "ba25042348f6172b5036fa71869c67330e721fc01de7ad1cdd04f3a566199d01", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "ba25042348f6172b5036fa71869c67330e721fc01de7ad1cdd04f3a566199d01" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "packet_barcode_symbology": "UNKNOWN" }, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct labelled UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet; no extra guess/citation. Not a unique Kingy advantage.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "7484cd0a8b6f4a9c71cd48a3148dab5da69c36f69e22ea05a16f32ebbd5ff42c", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q32", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 34, "questionId": "V19-Q32", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 16, "questionId": "V19-Q32", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 12, "questionId": "V19-Q32", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": {}, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct clean UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet. Documentary abstention, not a factual zero or an outside-world claim.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "b50e50e3e79bf2279874670c4068713195094dac7d0dc14f071c9afb9081f32a", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q32", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 34, "questionId": "V19-Q32", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-34.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "30142bf361a2156db12bb3fa9ad18beab633a2031bc010d46652d7ecebf9ace3", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "30142bf361a2156db12bb3fa9ad18beab633a2031bc010d46652d7ecebf9ace3" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 16, "questionId": "V19-Q32", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-16.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "ef4160d7e97c0be9f185f9976c924cc20d934ff30bc62672716291ed2b8ecf10", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "ef4160d7e97c0be9f185f9976c924cc20d934ff30bc62672716291ed2b8ecf10" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 12, "questionId": "V19-Q32", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-12.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "23a73c9632aeefb38647532927a455ad2b1cae7c1e5c96284885477e18890b65", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "23a73c9632aeefb38647532927a455ad2b1cae7c1e5c96284885477e18890b65" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "annual_insurance_premium": "UNKNOWN" }, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct labelled UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet; no extra guess/citation. Not a unique Kingy advantage.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "cfcb7042b5ad5ed497c5e6f4683235694649ae83ea4569eaa31e034a89e647c1", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q33", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 2, "questionId": "V19-Q33", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 40, "questionId": "V19-Q33", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 36, "questionId": "V19-Q33", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": {}, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct clean UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet. Documentary abstention, not a factual zero or an outside-world claim.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "8623299a16141a2077baf7634c36798fa3252aca4e50892eb30e2d87082056cc", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q33", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 2, "questionId": "V19-Q33", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-02.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "563b25ca268fd0cb544d7fec635e7df3e0e8432a5ec30b608c0aa46ecea052dc", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "563b25ca268fd0cb544d7fec635e7df3e0e8432a5ec30b608c0aa46ecea052dc" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 40, "questionId": "V19-Q33", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-40.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "1d60ac2c791aae43e6e31e11b09a70e0b25e7e7f3935765e514157bacfdd0e09", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "1d60ac2c791aae43e6e31e11b09a70e0b25e7e7f3935765e514157bacfdd0e09" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 36, "questionId": "V19-Q33", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-36.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "ea661373cb15ef42e88fce09d86c9b154aa698128bf5c496745a53cf0860ab7d", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "ea661373cb15ef42e88fce09d86c9b154aa698128bf5c496745a53cf0860ab7d" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "engine_displacement": "UNKNOWN" }, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct labelled UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet; no extra guess/citation. Not a unique Kingy advantage.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "1203567bfa10dd39569d59bb8dd74ebc0fd8749cea6cebe517ca8501d325157e", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q34", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 24, "questionId": "V19-Q34", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 36, "questionId": "V19-Q34", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 11, "questionId": "V19-Q34", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": {}, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct clean UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet. Documentary abstention, not a factual zero or an outside-world claim.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "db2fdfa78dc3679cc935aad9617b43f1c0519a664c48068fdeb8c25555b197d4", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q34", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 24, "questionId": "V19-Q34", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-24.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "1e7db1b6c6e1748b4d1124011cd4431c76b316eed152a8b7304e6d2f80ea1195", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "1e7db1b6c6e1748b4d1124011cd4431c76b316eed152a8b7304e6d2f80ea1195" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 36, "questionId": "V19-Q34", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-36.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "ec23d29e8319b28221bd16761c72acc9b13aaa03f8a54ee2ffccc5050796b69e", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "ec23d29e8319b28221bd16761c72acc9b13aaa03f8a54ee2ffccc5050796b69e" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 11, "questionId": "V19-Q34", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-11.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "304a969656f4a699469be3a5abbe05741fbffddff81b7929bde5cb5aafdbbf25", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "304a969656f4a699469be3a5abbe05741fbffddff81b7929bde5cb5aafdbbf25" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "copyright_jurisdiction": "UNKNOWN" }, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct labelled UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet; no extra guess/citation. Not a unique Kingy advantage.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "5d5eefd9ae41e5d75e0f3323d3597f6d8c6acd9fc92c92fdb3b089b3f4e14123", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q35", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 12, "questionId": "V19-Q35", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 21, "questionId": "V19-Q35", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 14, "questionId": "V19-Q35", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": {}, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct clean UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet. Documentary abstention, not a factual zero or an outside-world claim.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "ca0b35cdd7c47d40dc337b2277bedb52e91e50fac7397ec98c3ced4bc851ce6b", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q35", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 12, "questionId": "V19-Q35", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-12.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "60b0f09e71a3a6f84d77a186486e571b1f99c34ecbb25fa953063b94d1debbe0", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "60b0f09e71a3a6f84d77a186486e571b1f99c34ecbb25fa953063b94d1debbe0" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 21, "questionId": "V19-Q35", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-21.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "0f18a0f791974deda97e875662d866c66c875098ec3ddacd7e4bf7f3aeef04f1", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "0f18a0f791974deda97e875662d866c66c875098ec3ddacd7e4bf7f3aeef04f1" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 14, "questionId": "V19-Q35", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-14.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "2606d22828bb1b2c7b6422bd0f4dab7b7e7f42532265b7f1231aababaf1e45b5", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "2606d22828bb1b2c7b6422bd0f4dab7b7e7f42532265b7f1231aababaf1e45b5" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "mast_warranty_years": "UNKNOWN" }, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct labelled UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet; no extra guess/citation. Not a unique Kingy advantage.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "4bf96dc9ba99156fc3c19acd0428f60015948e8e4680adb9a0697057f3051291", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q36", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 5, "questionId": "V19-Q36", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 18, "questionId": "V19-Q36", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 24, "questionId": "V19-Q36", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": {}, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct clean UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet. Documentary abstention, not a factual zero or an outside-world claim.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "2b711b2a12255d2a345196f94c17888c9a7f5f3ef72a45536d83d2eaba4700be", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q36", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 5, "questionId": "V19-Q36", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-05.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "46cc839a0c127938d8f40a6aad7ac761b3eb68540bacf75fc21bd30f31dd972a", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "46cc839a0c127938d8f40a6aad7ac761b3eb68540bacf75fc21bd30f31dd972a" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 18, "questionId": "V19-Q36", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-18.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "16ca2a4ce829d3890fb43c352ef5238b9d9d574cee84360406ce72300dd98c2c", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "16ca2a4ce829d3890fb43c352ef5238b9d9d574cee84360406ce72300dd98c2c" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 24, "questionId": "V19-Q36", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-24.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "44447fb8d14d6bd006cdbf36f15dc172e1a07cbf47d348a4e77da7d16dc0600a", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "44447fb8d14d6bd006cdbf36f15dc172e1a07cbf47d348a4e77da7d16dc0600a" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "replacement_tire_unit_price": "UNKNOWN" }, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct labelled UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet; no extra guess/citation. Not a unique Kingy advantage.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "340459bbdde70a8a31bde179ae0a64151cbdf25244abdf4da3b1c2f5beb41df7", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q37", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 23, "questionId": "V19-Q37", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 39, "questionId": "V19-Q37", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 5, "questionId": "V19-Q37", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": {}, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct clean UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet. Documentary abstention, not a factual zero or an outside-world claim.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "aa255995a0ecbf5bf50cbeaaec776882e33d4228cf6114a3b0c5fd36bbeac0dc", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q37", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 23, "questionId": "V19-Q37", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-23.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "4a4a4b254b0f1d56a50b9beeee0bfff83307b31fe6711d8b9a1fa7083e005f27", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "4a4a4b254b0f1d56a50b9beeee0bfff83307b31fe6711d8b9a1fa7083e005f27" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 39, "questionId": "V19-Q37", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-39.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "1c673f79f19be83fd193693febacc5769f832602c0ca2d9d5e3d937f88baf371", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "1c673f79f19be83fd193693febacc5769f832602c0ca2d9d5e3d937f88baf371" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 5, "questionId": "V19-Q37", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-05.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "4d0c1662f5680744b08153d90d7fa626e768e781f1b750755610568cd49ca784", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "4d0c1662f5680744b08153d90d7fa626e768e781f1b750755610568cd49ca784" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "equatorial_mount_mass": "UNKNOWN" }, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct labelled UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet; no extra guess/citation. Not a unique Kingy advantage.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "2bb3a75a5544caff145312c0a5ecdffd76c8e5f2c6461da7d88cfaf6920fcf5c", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q38", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 20, "questionId": "V19-Q38", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 37, "questionId": "V19-Q38", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 22, "questionId": "V19-Q38", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": {}, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct clean UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet. Documentary abstention, not a factual zero or an outside-world claim.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "c393589dd58f45e14c4b043a17718b3b35e628cc582aaea5f9a30d53a1ade1ad", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q38", "attemptsCovered": 1, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 22, "questionId": "V19-Q38", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-22.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "7646c0cf120cffad3b7d94b1c594d430dbf11e9d3d07dec7356ea272ff34b437", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "7646c0cf120cffad3b7d94b1c594d430dbf11e9d3d07dec7356ea272ff34b437" } ], "frozenStatus": "fail", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "culture_genomic_strain": "UNKNOWN" }, "abstain": true, "error": "Complete native answer exceeded frozen 90-second deadline.", "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Response content UNKNOWN is correct and response_only_grade passes. Unique final model-log event is92536ms after submission, exceeding frozen90000ms; deadline failure is authoritative and is not merely a CUA timeout. No claim of semantic wrong answer or causal product unreliability.", "specialScope": "authoritative-native-deadline" }, { "bundleSha256": "f906f7d9f3fd3abf4f3ffb4eab44e6a2c158f1ad5d698f0b09b66e7639235655", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q38", "attemptsCovered": 2, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 20, "questionId": "V19-Q38", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-20.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "838addcc885ac2a12e7d651bc459a83ba2fc01a846c074723fc650a625a41c36", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "838addcc885ac2a12e7d651bc459a83ba2fc01a846c074723fc650a625a41c36" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 37, "questionId": "V19-Q38", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-37.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "0bbddd19698df4d10797ae74f6c2a7e86b4344e11b9b80077d66bc7a826d9fe7", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "0bbddd19698df4d10797ae74f6c2a7e86b4344e11b9b80077d66bc7a826d9fe7" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "culture_genomic_strain": "UNKNOWN" }, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct labelled UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet; no extra guess/citation. Not a unique Kingy advantage.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "2c9392567c4a7eca60ecbd302f813a825ae9c87ea290599f4e613ecc519d6e12", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q39", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 4, "questionId": "V19-Q39", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 33, "questionId": "V19-Q39", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 21, "questionId": "V19-Q39", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": {}, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct clean UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet. Documentary abstention, not a factual zero or an outside-world claim.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "f48600e780ddd4d7ee1aed087e591da03a3d9413f52cc7d6f491df5025cbfb27", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q39", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 4, "questionId": "V19-Q39", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-04.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "a34e74a3dca326ca5aed04f649883f22be4568b55c5604a2a43c98f270a812a6", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "a34e74a3dca326ca5aed04f649883f22be4568b55c5604a2a43c98f270a812a6" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 33, "questionId": "V19-Q39", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-33.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "4fe6a5533d697f2f683ed5352d4b16a91af8c960a4944a82227a2557d8e732e8", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "4fe6a5533d697f2f683ed5352d4b16a91af8c960a4944a82227a2557d8e732e8" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 21, "questionId": "V19-Q39", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-21.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "b1aac91a9bb5b88af8103fc2ed4a49289843f80dbc27210c90f87d1961d2be2f", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "b1aac91a9bb5b88af8103fc2ed4a49289843f80dbc27210c90f87d1961d2be2f" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "motor_stall_torque": "UNKNOWN" }, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct labelled UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet; no extra guess/citation. Not a unique Kingy advantage.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "93c28205bd6263ac636fef1849dd233c0f51f0e6eb5943377ed7897d08792b9a", "system": "A", "questionId": "V19-Q40", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "A", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 22, "questionId": "V19-Q40", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A1/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "288b5439384436ef6f9affd58739866a549569d05c8155e408e722f50c397adc" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 5, "questionId": "V19-Q40", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A2/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "01342616a9dfb753ed58aca815c3c532c921bb2879d0c1208512b1d986bdf269" }, { "system": "A", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 39, "questionId": "V19-Q40", "originalSourceFile": "sessions/A3/attempts.jsonl", "originalSourceSha256": "84c90623997a4ec0f4f13d61196a08c005107bdc2063216704c89a41496b38f8" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": {}, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct clean UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet. Documentary abstention, not a factual zero or an outside-world claim.", "specialScope": null }, { "bundleSha256": "e0309062c048f1deb747e33a26ad553d4889e624ba854e62b4b5bb146936da3e", "system": "B", "questionId": "V19-Q40", "attemptsCovered": 3, "coverage": [ { "system": "B", "repetition": 1, "scheduledPosition": 22, "questionId": "V19-Q40", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B1/native-22.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "6e525b49d8a5c3875b084a98b5baee778d4b49bd8d408ddecd28749bec53bbac", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "6e525b49d8a5c3875b084a98b5baee778d4b49bd8d408ddecd28749bec53bbac" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 2, "scheduledPosition": 5, "questionId": "V19-Q40", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B2/native-05.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "0b86f6ea05b5d9b41ddbe3859e046a7506ce5374e822c6e24762ce1a01f5b7fa", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "0b86f6ea05b5d9b41ddbe3859e046a7506ce5374e822c6e24762ce1a01f5b7fa" }, { "system": "B", "repetition": 3, "scheduledPosition": 39, "questionId": "V19-Q40", "originalSourceFile": "analysis/results/native-finalization/B3/native-39.conversation.json", "originalSourceSha256": "692f538476fc45d831838860a7bf3c0480d518fd6b64eb8e461dd4dc88ae8b6f", "retainedInitialSourceSha256": "692f538476fc45d831838860a7bf3c0480d518fd6b64eb8e461dd4dc88ae8b6f" } ], "frozenStatus": "pass", "frozenFactStatus": null, "responseOnlyStatus": "pass", "answerFields": { "outlet_pipe_wall_thickness": "UNKNOWN" }, "abstain": true, "error": null, "sourceAnchors": [], "returnedCitationMetadata": [], "independentAssessment": "Correct labelled UNKNOWN for a value not supplied by the frozen packet; no extra guess/citation. Not a unique Kingy advantage.", "specialScope": null } ], "modelCalls": 0, "gradeResponseInvoked": false }